I think I've tried everything on the market, or close. I have original Matco, Mac, Torin, Craftsman etc. liners in boxes I have used for years. I have used shelf liner from Big Lots, the weave stuff, which is like the weave stuff from HF, or the weave stuff from Costco.
The weave stuff from Torin is like the weave from Costco-Big Lots-HF, but possibly thicker than the Big Lots stuff.
The single mats sold by HF, not the weave but the rough/slick rubber is excellent but if you put it shiny side up slick tools slide on it. The other way works well, but isn't as pretty.
Best price in bulk is Costco, cut it yourself. There will be waste.
Best deal that makes me most happy with results is HF single sheets on sale. When you get it for a buck a drawer, it makes me happy.
Complaints about it are sorta silly as it is better than stock Craftsman and if it were fractionally thicker it would look like stock Snap-On. Put in two layers for two bucks and your tools wouldn't know you don't have Snap-On.
Not that your tools care anyway...
None of these have 'gathered' moisture. None of these corrode the tools.
All of these keep the tools from scratching up the box paint.
All of these stop the tools from sliding too much.
None of these stop the tools from sliding if you get vigorous with opening and
closing.
Get angry enough with the slams and tools pop out of trays, so of course they slide on mats. Any mats.
Best way to control the roll on the tools is with magnetic sign material, cut strips the size you want, with the tools laying on the strip.
This keeps my bits in order even when I get flamboyant with the drawer closing.
This doesn’t work on screwdrivers of course, but about everything else.
.
. I would recommend it and you can cut it to fit on the sides which is what I have done also. funny how someone else had the same idea I had, 
.
