xxaler
Well-known member
Picked up a Chars.Parker #104. Jaws are beat, but I'll order a new set and make this my permanent bench vise once I've cleaned it up.
Parker jaws are not exactly easily replaced, so I can see the tops have a lot of abuse, but how are the faces? Decide that after wire wheeling them clean (being loaded up can look a lot like damage...)
If the faces are decent, just take the worst of the hacking off the top with a flap disk and call it good. (it really doesn't look all that deep)
There is zero checkering left on either jaw. Both are basically flat. Looks like 2-pins per jaw holding them in, just use a punch and pop them out.
TM: it looks like a Coulton vise. nice find.
Colten pat. Vise :
George A. Colton patent holder, No. 320,224. Patented June 16, 1885.
Examples marked H&B, "Inmarks" and unmarked exist.

Getting them off is no big deal, FITTING them is a whole new ball game, and as Drives said, they are not cheap.
Most Parkers have VERY light teeth to begin with. Which if you want to minimize marks on the parts gripped in it, is a good thing. some have completely smooth jaws on purpose. The heavily cut teeth often leave permanent damage to whatever is put in them.
I prefer the light tooth Parker's came with, and I want one vise to have completely smooth well fitting jaws...
How rare are the Craftsman 5196? Have the opportunity to buy one but I can't find any on ebay to determine a fair price...
How rare are the Craftsman 5196? Have the opportunity to buy one but I can't find any on ebay to determine a fair price...
If you don't want it for yourself. Sell it to me. I am looking for one. Just so you have options.
Outlaw,---I've never done the Electrolysis bath yet, but when I do I've already got two big plastic tubs ready.---But was curious about what would happen if you did use a nonmagnetic stainless steel vat.---What chemical reaction will take place or not take place?
Outlaw,---I've never done the Electrolysis bath yet, but when I do I've already got two big plastic tubs ready.---But was curious about what would happen if you did use a nonmagnetic stainless steel vat.---What chemical reaction will take place or not take place?
You will produce hexavalent chromium.
Put some weld on the threads of the bolts, it'll be easy enough for you to grind them off if you need to remove it but will stop it getting stolen unless they want to make a lot of noise. Look at security measures that 4x4 owners take to stop winches being stolen, all of those would work for you.I was slightly concerned about scrapers but this is a quiet neighborhood and strangers are quickly noticed and frequently questioned. Small town.
That said I did use Allen head bolts and lock nuts to make it a little more difficult to easily remove.
To ship a 70 lb vise across the country would cost quite a bit, no?If you don't want it for yourself. Sell it to me. I am looking for one. Just so you have options.
To ship a 70 lb vise across the country would cost quite a bit, no?
Hey! That was me!? Sorry buddy...oldldh, I missed a 5196 today. He was about to meet with the buyer as we spoke. Sold for $80
For lack of nothing else to do (waiting on supper) here is a picture of the American Scale I am working on. This one is truly naked, fresh out of the media blaster.
Hope everyone up North is OK in the storm going on.
It's not a 5196, it's a 5917...
Great score, check the top of the slide near the static jaw, it should be date stamped.
Hey! That was me!? Sorry buddy...
Real estate is location--location--location!!!
Old vises are condition--condition--condition!!!
Left to right---
5196 sold on Ebay for over $300.00 including freight...original paint...pristine...I dropped out at $ 150.00/+frt over $ 200.00...
5197 (Balane's) did very well at auction, but I'm old, and I don't remember how much it sold for...too expensive for this old retiree...
5198 (Big Caddy's unicorn, that I found for him---was too expensive for me, at the time, and too far away---California...so I made sure it had a good home...)...
The last photo is Big Caddy's 51XX Craftsman Vise Collection...
If it's pristine and located close by---I'd go $ 150.00/5196, $ 200.00/5197, and more than $ 200.00 for a 5198, if I ever find another one...
Any one else think of this??
Super nice collection of vices! Maybe one day I will get one of these to restoreIt's not a 5196, it's a 5917... paid $80
I love the grooves and lines on those. Enjoy it. 
Good to know I may have something interesting to look at.Joseph, I'll have to say, that little clamp-on is unique in my experience. I've seen many versions of the double dowel small clamp-on, but never with an anvil support for the dowels.
Correction: THREE!ok I just ran them all and found a crappy work bench attached to a big ol craftsman. The owner wants 200 firm for the bench. What's wrong with people?


1948, I think.It's not a 5196, it's a 5917...
Great score, check the top of the slide near the static jaw, it should be date stamped.