To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Hanging air filtration systems? Waste of money?

Hobby_Man22

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 16, 2020
Messages
3,581
Location
tx
Have you guys seen these? They hang from the ceiling typically and it's basically a fan that has filters and obviously filters the air. lol Anyone have one of these? Does it do much good to keep dust down on surfaces?

 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
I have a home built one. It is worth having. I use mine if I am painting or welding too. It helps clear the air.
 

mwalsh9152

Well-known member
Joined
May 14, 2016
Messages
349
I just bought a WEN filtration system for $100 on Black Friday. Once I get through my Christmas build rush I can empty the new work shop and actually complete it then I will install the filter and an extraction system. Seems like a good idea for protecting my lungs. Ive always worked outside and just used a fan to blow dust away from myself, so this is all new.
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
I should add, my filtration box is and old furnace that I cut off the lower section where the blower sits, and then I built a filter rack to fit it. I just use a simple 2" MERV 10 or 11 filter.

It is surprising how well it removes welding fumes from the air. With the doors closed it was not long before there was a haze in the air. I will weld in the winter and in the past I would open the door and let the air circulate at a loss of comfort and the gas bill. Today I just turn on the filter and it keeps the air clear.

Of course with wood working it catches most of the air borne dust.

In both instances at the end of the day my nose would be blowing out dirty boogers. With the filter running my boogers are pristine!
 

turbowoodworker

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2012
Messages
3,536
Location
Apex NC
I have a Jet and a Delta. They work well for the suspended fine dust and if you use the timer and let it run for two hours after stopping work, it makes a world of difference.
Fully agree that you must collect dust at the tool or site of origin. These air filters are for the fine stuff that will settle everywhere.
 

Sherk

Active member
Joined
Jun 18, 2016
Messages
43
Location
Southwest MI
I have a 20x20 furnace filter on each side of a box fan running continuously in my shop. I also have a blower fan mounted in a mobile box that I set up with 4 16x25 furnace filters as intakes.

I have a Dylos DC1100 air quality monitor. If I run sanders, etc without dust collection on particle counts skyrocket. The box fan will slowly knock out down (over 24 hours or so, on low). The blower fan setup takes 30 mins to clear the air to acceptable levels. Old pic attached, shop is laid out very differently now.

In short, yes these things work.

20220509_185031.jpg
 

CraigStu

Well-known member
Joined
May 22, 2014
Messages
4,027
Location
Blacksburg, Va
HobbyMan I am glad you asked. I have had asthma since I was a kid. No huge deal, never needed a hospital. I could go for years w/ no onsets and then have them semi regularly for a year or two. I always get along w/ an inhaler. About 7 yrs ago it started getting a little worse. Now at 74 I never leave the house w/o an inhaler. Maybe 2 years ago I got real religous about hooking my shop vac to the bandsaws and disc/belt sander when using them. And the radial arm saw is on wheels and never gets used inside. And I now put on a good face mask when using any of the above. I think it is time to do better. I think I will start w/ Kay's box fan and a filter. Our previous house had a heat pump upgrade and we started using those 4 inch thick filters. I think this may be a really good application for one of them. Thanks for the reminder.
 

dfiler2

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 15, 2014
Messages
2,858
Location
NW Minnesota
I built my own also using a 1 hp blower fan and then stacked 4 20x25 furnace filters, I use it mainly for when I use spray paint in the shop during the winter. It works really well. I have a couple of dust extraction systems set up for controlling dust on the larger tools.
 

Miss the Pontiacs

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 7, 2016
Messages
16,450
Location
Saskatchewan Canada
Mine is a King 1400.. I had originally wanted the one smaller in size and got placed on a waiting list. I believe it took something like 6 months for delivery. When my buddy picked his up ordered before He did get the smaller unit. By the time I phoned those units were all gone. The larger is just fine. I had been using it and then started hearing this metal expansion/contraction sound. Went up to investigate and was very surprised at the amount (as my buddy says) wood flour was collected.
My buddy picked up a back up filter. He operates in his basement and is a little more concerned about flour capture.
King is probably the same or similar to the Grizzly. I think
I think they are worth the investment.
E958CA9E-4F53-43AD-BBD2-B513D256C73E.jpeg22845AAA-8D40-487F-9F0A-8337DFE7B633.jpeg
 

Buckgnarly

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
7,651
Location
VT
Thought about getting one a while back, are they good for woodshops or metal/garage stuff? I have zero woodworking stuff, but get that fine metal/welding/spray paint **** dust on everything in my shop. Would love to avoid that.
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
Thought about getting one a while back, are they good for woodshops or metal/garage stuff? I have zero woodworking stuff, but get that fine metal/welding/spray paint **** dust on everything in my shop. Would love to avoid that.
I mentioned earlier that I use mine when welding and painting. It helps a bunch.
 

Jackfre

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 26, 2010
Messages
4,410
Location
N CA
I have a JDS filter box. I’ve run it in my shop for about 15 yrs. Do they work? Work in the shop without hem and if you notice a bit of coughing…well!
 

acer66

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 4, 2010
Messages
4,418
Location
Western North Carolina
I have a 20x20 furnace filter on each side of a box fan running continuously in my shop. I also have a blower fan mounted in a mobile box that I set up with 4 16x25 furnace filters as intakes.

I have a Dylos DC1100 air quality monitor. If I run sanders, etc without dust collection on particle counts skyrocket. The box fan will slowly knock out down (over 24 hours or so, on low). The blower fan setup takes 30 mins to clear the air to acceptable levels. Old pic attached, shop is laid out very differently now.

In short, yes these things work.

20220509_185031.jpg
Nice, I like that it is sitting low.
Stumpy nub was talking about air filters and he said it makes more sense to have them low because if they are high they pull the dust from the machine below you up to the ceiling above you and you are in between.
Not sure if that holds up to any science based test though just sounds right imho.
 

MadeByMiller

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2018
Messages
1,230
Location
Rapid City, SD
I can't speak for the smaller units that you mostly see used for woodworking, but my Industrial Maid air scrubber is absolutely one of the top investments I made in my small shop, second only to my heater I suppose. I used to do a lot of welding/grinding in my shop, like 15 hour days, and the air scrubber almost entirely eliminated the haze, fumes, smell, and dust from all of that dirty work. I highly recommend it, and you can see it in my shop thread HERE
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

paredown

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 12, 2012
Messages
544
Location
Pomona, NY
I inherited a Jet with my new set of tools--and it really helps. I'm doing almost all woodworking in a small (i car garage) shop. For source collection, I have a souped up Delta 220v for the table saw and planer, plus a Festool vac hooked up to the chop saw/handtools as needed.

I'm amazed at how much airborne fine dust that the Jet picks up. And since the door to the garage opens into the house, it's made a difference in the rooms closest to the garage as far as dust buildup.

One annoyance though--the Jet mounting points only let you mount it one direction on standard 16" joist spacing--apparently no one thought to add a second set of holes on the top (or a top bar arrangement that swiveled)--so I have mine pointed in a less than optimal direction.
 

djjsr

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2006
Messages
4,796
Location
In the cornfields
If you buy one, be sure it uses a filter that you can buy locally. The unit I got about 15 years ago had an oddball size filter that had to be purchased from the unit manufacturer. I built a box extension on the inlet so I could use common furnace filters. Works well.
 

LeonardY

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 16, 2011
Messages
5,048
Location
Southern California
I have a Jet for over 10 years. It less noisy than my Gorilla dust collector. It works well and I use whenever I am woodworking.
The right location in the shop helps too.
The jet has an odd filter size. I got the washable filter and it's been working well.
The best thing you can do is try to collect the dust at the source. When sanding I use a downdraft table.
 

ar2stp48

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 20, 2008
Messages
503
Location
Magnolia, Arkansas
The Jet is 3 speed. I would compare it to a 3 speed box fan for low and medium; high may be a bit louder.

I have had no problem finding the exterior filters for it; I think Ace and W/M have both had them. They are 12 x 24 if I recall correctly. The interior filter is cloth and a factory replacement

Placement is important. I mounted it on a long wall of shop about a foot from the wall, with the blower output on near side to wall. Works great and creates excellent circulation.

The unit is a bit heavy and awkward to hang by one person but can be done

I was convinced the day I ripped a few pieces of 3/4 MDF; turned the filter on med; and watched the dust haze clear.


I was lucky and found my unit at an auction, both remotes, and both filters showed no dust. cost: $65





the
 

turbowoodworker

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2012
Messages
3,536
Location
Apex NC
They are not loud at all. Nothing like the main dust collector.
The Jet, and others have two filters, a pre filter, that looks like the furnace filter and is easily replaced, and the multipleated inner filter.
 

rbgearz

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
2,899
Location
Illinois
They are not loud at all. Nothing like the main dust collector.
The Jet, and others have two filters, a pre filter, that looks like the furnace filter and is easily replaced, and the multipleated inner filter.
We put one in our grinding room and cuts down on the dust a lot. It's the Jet 3 speed and it's not loud at all.
 

brownbagg

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2006
Messages
5,208
got a 24 inch lovere fan on end wall, hell with filters, its will **** everything out the bldg in less than a minute. I pity my neighbors
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
got a 24 inch lovere fan on end wall, hell with filters, its will **** everything out the bldg in less than a minute. I pity my neighbors
Including the heat and/or cooled air conditioned air. I can leave a window open and the door on the other end and the breeze will blow right on through, but at -20F or 95F and 100% humidity it get a bit uncomfortable, that is why i use an air cleaner.
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
If using a box fan I would get five 20x20x2 filters and tape them together to form a box, then tape the open end to the fan. Cheap propeller type box fans don't move a lot of air if you choke them down and the larger filter area helps a lot.
 
Last edited:

wes73

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2013
Messages
218
Location
South Central PA
I have the Delta one tarmy posted. Originally used when sanding drywall in each room of the house. Did a great job containing the dust to the one room with a door closed. Now it hangs in the garage on a timer switch. Run it when working, then set the timer before I leave. As said it works great with a dust collection system.
 

jmiller_2308

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 16, 2013
Messages
552
Location
Shakopee, MN
If using a box fan I would get five 20x20x2 filters and tape them together to form a box, then tape the open end to the fan. Cheap propeller type boxe fans don't move a lot of air if you choke them down and the larger filter area helps a lot.

I struggle with this type of a home grown solution. From a cost perspective does it really make sense to build a corsi-rosenthal type box when you can buy some low end hanging air filtration systems for less than $150?

Buying 5 20x20x2 filters of MERV 13 looks like it could easily cost close to $100. Now add in a dedicated box fan for another $20+ and you are getting awfully close to the cost of a complete low cost air filtration system that will have a remote, timers, 5 and 1 micron filtration, and a max capacity of roughly 400-500 CFM.

I like doing stuff myself and have been accused of "McGivering" plenty of stuff but in this case I don't understand the benefit of building vs. buying the solution. What am I missing?
 

Youngandfree

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 29, 2020
Messages
877
Location
VA
I struggle with this type of a home grown solution. From a cost perspective does it really make sense to build a corsi-rosenthal type box when you can buy some low end hanging air filtration systems for less than $150?

Buying 5 20x20x2 filters of MERV 13 looks like it could easily cost close to $100. Now add in a dedicated box fan for another $20+ and you are getting awfully close to the cost of a complete low cost air filtration system that will have a remote, timers, 5 and 1 micron filtration, and a max capacity of roughly 400-500 CFM.

I like doing stuff myself and have been accused of "McGivering" plenty of stuff but in this case I don't understand the benefit of building vs. buying the solution. What am I missing?
Got a link?
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
I struggle with this type of a home grown solution. From a cost perspective does it really make sense to build a corsi-rosenthal type box when you can buy some low end hanging air filtration systems for less than $150?

Buying 5 20x20x2 filters of MERV 13 looks like it could easily cost close to $100. Now add in a dedicated box fan for another $20+ and you are getting awfully close to the cost of a complete low cost air filtration system that will have a remote, timers, 5 and 1 micron filtration, and a max capacity of roughly 400-500 CFM.

I like doing stuff myself and have been accused of "McGivering" plenty of stuff but in this case I don't understand the benefit of building vs. buying the solution. What am I missing?
Well, the filters are needed no matter and disposible, most people have a box fan laying around. With 15 seconds of shopping I found 20x20x2 filters for $10 each. So about $80 all in.

A cheap Grizzly is $160 and up. The better ones, Grizzly and Jet are $500.

Sure it isn't a fantastic deal, but not as bad as your numbers.
 

PoorUB

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 29, 2021
Messages
11,632
Location
Fargo, ND
Really the best deal is to find an old furnace blower and build a box, or do like I did and just use the lower portion of the furnace cabinet. You get a 1,000 CFM+ filter.

HVAC shops toss them in the garbage everyday so they have no value. Toss someone $20 to save a decent one and have at it.
 

MongoTA

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 10, 2018
Messages
1,000
Location
CT
I've had a Delta unit for maybe 20 years.
I use it for wood and metal. Works great for both. Three-speed is nice, as is the timer and remote.
Mine hangs on the ceiling of my basement shop on a small sliding frame. It can filter as is, or if I really want to generate fresh air exchange, I can open or remove a basement window from its buck. I can slide the fan back towards the window buck and all of the exhaust goes out the window with fresh air being drawn in from the other side of the shop.
If you think you need one, yeah, you probably do.
Home-built or bought, as long as it works, you'll enjoy having it.
 

vrinner

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 29, 2006
Messages
1,078
Location
Placentia, CA
I use a box fan on low with a taped on filter when doing soldering of stained glass. I sits on top of my bench about 5 feet away and greatly reduces the fumes that I used to breath in a lot of. To me its a benefit having something more portable in a big shop.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom