To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Are Pittsburg ratchets comparable in quality and durability to Tekton?

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
I don't know much about Pittsburgh ratchets. Most of my ratchets are Tekton, and I have a few Gearwrench ones. But I've always seen good reviews on forums, websites, and even on YouTube about these Pittsburgh ratchets.
So, what would be a realistic opinion—one that isn't biased against the brand or simply repeating the negative things others say—from users who actually use these ratchets, compared to Tekton or Gearwrench?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

T45

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2014
Messages
3,253
For a generic tool into a generic box, GW or similar mid-grade taiwan ratchet is fine choice. HF that would be quinn, you can go higher/lower price/features if you have a pressing need or concern like budget or something is particularly valuable job.

Pitt pro is for DIY and travel bags, the Icon G2 is for "need something nicer than GW" occastions. Price varies widely with brand/tier and whether you buy on sale or not.
 

shoggoth80

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 28, 2013
Messages
858
Location
Seattle
I would argue that it's a little more model specific than that. Pretty sure the Tekton and Pittsburgh composite ratchets are the same. Surprisingly inexpensive (I don't think Tekton offers one anymore though), very comfortable for a basic ratchet, and super low back drag (felt, not measured) with a little grease (in both cases).

I want to say the Icon and Tekton roto heads are very similar as well. Though that's veering off a bit.

I have the old Pittsburgh Pro flex head in 3/8. I think Tekton's versions are nicer. Better flex joint area, nicer comfort handle. That said, it's been a very good ratchet. I've warranty swapped it once... After many years of use, and even loaning it to a coworker for two of those. It wasn't a catastrophic failure... It started slipping.

I still use the replacement regularly. It's a good ratchet for the money. That said, increasing the budget marginally gets you a tool that has better attention to details, where if it fails, the company will supply you the stuff to rebuild it. Nothing wrong with either. Just a matter of what you want to spend.

Gearwrench would not be my first choice these days for a lot of things. However if I was in the market for an inexpensive locking flex head, I would consider them I suppose. I've had mixed success with getting them to warranty their failures... And their products aren't what they were 10 years ago. Where HF has stepped up to their quality and offerings with some of their tool lines, and Tekton has coming out with new stuff often while having fantastic customer support.

It's kind of a time of plenty in regards to affordable, serviceable tools. What's your use case, proximity to stores etc. Those all help inform your decision. I know e commerce lessens that impact, but it's still a consideration.
 

Kurt4440

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 3, 2009
Messages
2,471
Location
Western New York
I would say to try some of the Tekton and Harbor Freight ratchets that are manufactured in Taiwan. They are not expensive and you will probably realize that they will all get the job done.
 
OP
S

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
For a generic tool into a generic box, GW or similar mid-grade taiwan ratchet is fine choice. HF that would be quinn, you can go higher/lower price/features if you have a pressing need or concern like budget or something is particularly valuable job.

Pitt pro is for DIY and travel bags, the Icon G2 is for "need something nicer than GW" occastions. Price varies widely with brand/tier and whether you buy on sale or not.
Good info! Thanks!
 
OP
S

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
I would argue that it's a little more model specific than that. Pretty sure the Tekton and Pittsburgh composite ratchets are the same. Surprisingly inexpensive (I don't think Tekton offers one anymore though), very comfortable for a basic ratchet, and super low back drag (felt, not measured) with a little grease (in both cases).

I want to say the Icon and Tekton roto heads are very similar as well. Though that's veering off a bit.

I have the old Pittsburgh Pro flex head in 3/8. I think Tekton's versions are nicer. Better flex joint area, nicer comfort handle. That said, it's been a very good ratchet. I've warranty swapped it once... After many years of use, and even loaning it to a coworker for two of those. It wasn't a catastrophic failure... It started slipping.

I still use the replacement regularly. It's a good ratchet for the money. That said, increasing the budget marginally gets you a tool that has better attention to details, where if it fails, the company will supply you the stuff to rebuild it. Nothing wrong with either. Just a matter of what you want to spend.

Gearwrench would not be my first choice these days for a lot of things. However if I was in the market for an inexpensive locking flex head, I would consider them I suppose. I've had mixed success with getting them to warranty their failures... And their products aren't what they were 10 years ago. Where HF has stepped up to their quality and offerings with some of their tool lines, and Tekton has coming out with new stuff often while having fantastic customer support.

It's kind of a time of plenty in regards to affordable, serviceable tools. What's your use case, proximity to stores etc. Those all help inform your decision. I know e commerce lessens that impact, but it's still a consideration.
Great info, man! Thanks!
 
OP
S

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
I would say to try some of the Tekton and Harbor Freight ratchets that are manufactured in Taiwan. They are not expensive and you will probably realize that they will all get the job done.
I have some Tekton in 1/2 and 3/8
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Aaron_W

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
2,931
Location
Northern California
I don't own any, but touching them in the store, some models feel pretty stout, while others kind of flimsy.

Just figured chances are good they don't come from the same source.

I feel like Pittsburgh comes in a wider range of quality than the better HF brands.

You can buy a whole ratchet and socket set of Pittburgh for less than a single Pittsburgh ratchet. The ratchets included in those Pittsburgh sets are functional, but clearly budget ratchets. The Pittsburgh ratchets sold individually are noticeably better.


The only somewhat apples to apples comparison I could make between Pittsburgh and Tekton, would be the super cheapo Pittsburgh 1/4" set ($16) I have in my cars and a pretty nice Tekton 1/4" set ($100). Pittsburgh does not even come close.

I also have a 3/8" Quinn set I keep in the house, and while I'd still give it to Tekton, Quinn at least gives Tekton a good run.
 
Last edited:
OP
S

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
I feel like Pittsburgh comes in a wider range of quality than the better HF brands.

You can buy a whole ratchet and socket set of Pittburgh for less than a single Pittsburgh ratchet. The ratchets included in those Pittsburgh sets are functional, but clearly budget ratchets. The Pittsburgh ratchets sold individually are noticeably better.


The only somewhat apples to apples comparison I could make between Pittsburgh and Tekton, would be the super cheapo Pittsburgh 1/4" set ($16) I have in my cars and a pretty nice Tekton 1/4" set ($100). Pittsburgh does not even come close.

I also have a 3/8" Quinn set I keep in the house, and while I'd still give it to Tekton, Quinn at least gives Tekton a good run.
Good info! Thanks bro!
 

ecotec

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
5,468
I had a lot of the Pittsburgh ratchets, and I still have a few of them. My opinion is that they are great ratchets for the money (especially the sale prices of years ago).

I have better ratchets now, but for a long time my “good” ratchet drawer was mostly Snap-on, high tooth count Wright and Pittsburgh… to the exclusion of a lot of Proto, Armstrong, Williams, Craftsman and most SK. Only recently has the last of the Pittsburgh moved to my cart, car kits, and workbench.

I gave away/donated all of my Craftsman and some of the Pittsburgh. At some point, as I find more ratchets, I will probably give away the rest of the Pittsburgh with the exception of the composite ones.

To this day, I think that they are wonderful for the money.
 
OP
S

Sbl777

Active member
Joined
Aug 24, 2023
Messages
43
I had a lot of the Pittsburgh ratchets, and I still have a few of them. My opinion is that they are great ratchets for the money (especially the sale prices of years ago).

I have better ratchets now, but for a long time my “good” ratchet drawer was mostly Snap-on, high tooth count Wright and Pittsburgh… to the exclusion of a lot of Proto, Armstrong, Williams, Craftsman and most SK. Only recently has the last of the Pittsburgh moved to my cart, car kits, and workbench.

I gave away/donated all of my Craftsman and some of the Pittsburgh. At some point, as I find more ratchets, I will probably give away the rest of the Pittsburgh with the exception of the composite ones.

To this day, I think that they are wonderful for the money.
Good info, man! Thank you so much!
 

mikey03

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2024
Messages
2,152
If I were real tight on funds or I wanted loaner tools I’d wait for some HF sales and buy Pittsburgh on discount.

But honestly I’d just rather get Tekton for Taiwan. So easy to warranty If it brakes. So easy to buy spare parts if you want to have them or change anvils from 1/4 to 3/8

all the different styles and sizes
 

Basskiller

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 7, 2009
Messages
489
Location
s cal
I have the 3/8 long handle flex and a 1/4 flex in my wrecking yard bag for some years now. I have no complaints with them. The 3/8 has held up to some abuse.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom