It all depends.
I use a range of different drawer lining materials, based upon the conditions. For example, I use tool foam to manage certain tools like pliers that I want to see in the same place every time. Tool foam means the stuff will not slide around as the drawer is opened and closed. It also makes it easy to see when tools are missing- very important if you want to avoid FOD and/or make sure your tools don't get borrowed by others at the end of a work session. In other drawers, I use a non-slip liner that reduces (but does not stop entirely) tool movement. These drawers tend to have a lot of relatively low-value objects in them where tracking is not so important, and where speed of locating them is not as important (compared to tool foam, where the same tool is always in exactly the same place). In still others, I use plastic boxes to organize loose parts, supplies, etc. so they will always stay separated, yet be able to be organized by style, etc (e.g, all screws are together, and all bolts are located together). And finally, for certain kinds of tools (e.g., sockets and wrenches) I use custom or store-bought organizers that label and locate everything in the drawer.
Most "kitchen" style liners are not heavy enought to resist sliding, and they tend to end up looking like dried-up taco shells in the drawer over time, at least in my experience. Another problem with the kitchen-oriented solutions is that they tend to allow moisture to pool and cause oxidation. This is a Bad Thing.
IMO, of course!
-Will