makita MAC700 vs California Air Tools 6310

i've narrowed my choices down to just these two , they seem to offer the best quality/features for $200 , don't wanna spend more money but i want something better than the typical $120-$140 HF/husky etc. . the biggest tool used on it will be a single framing nailer for occasional cherry picked side jobs (building/repairing decks) , but no construction on a regular basis ...... maybe 1-3 times a month .

the 700 and 6310 are very different from one another oil vs. air , small/narrow vs. wheeled , fairly quiet vs. not very loud , very durable (700) vs. unknown durability .... but both are ranked at the top of amazon's customer ratings and both get great comments in forums . the 6310 looks to be enough SCFM for a framer and the 700 has almost a CF more power (2.4 vs.s 3.3 , both @ 90) . but the 6310 has well over twice the tank storage(2.6 vs, 6.3) . both are $200 locally .

i suspect the makita will last longer , and i suspect i will get at least several years (maybe more) from the california air tools . but the CAT has the larger tank and is close to the quietest compressors available . the sound difference of the CAT in videos is very appealing . will the CAT cycle a framing nailer and should it last a solid 5 years or more ? i'd expect the makita to last at least 10 and potentially 15 or more . but if i get 5 years out of either i fell i will have gotten my money's worth . if i spend 200 and only get 2-3 years i'll be disappointed though ......

so which will y'all recommend ? and why .
LOL , this will be my last thread on compressor choices , thanks for putting up with me and for the helpful replies in my other two threads .
jeff

BTW , talked to a gentleman at CAT today , asked what the duty cycle was on it and he replied %70 . i was surprised ! i asked how it would do with a framing gun , he said it would depend on how fast it was shot , that for fast folks it may slow them down (i appreciate a honest negative comment about a product and it always give me some instant respect for the sales person) , but for medium or slower folks it should keep up .

here's what looks to be a pretty thorough review of it that does mention some shortcomings .

http://powertoolsninja.com/california-air-tools-cat-6310-ultra-quiet-compressor-review/

so i'm gonna go with the CAT . if it doesn't keep up i got 90 days to return it to HD and get the makita to replace it . won't cost me a penny more and their 2 year extended warranty is the same $20 .

i found a great deal on the california air tools 4620A and ordered it saturday

http://www.californiaairtools.com/u...compressors/2-0-hp-air-compressors/cat-4620a/

thanks for all the replies folks

How much was your price on California Air compressor ??

You'll be satisfied for many years with lightweight portable compressor. I've got similar design DeWalt but it's oil-splash and pretty heavy to haul around (all steel). However, it runs great and no problem running a framing nailer.

i got them to do a online price match for $189 plus free shipping . had to call 3 times before i got them to honor their company policy . and then i added HD's 2 year extended warranty for $50 ...... it's $252 and change with tax delivered .