To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

NATIONAL TOOL LEAGUE - Fantasy Football style - 1954!

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
With the regular season over, the Wild Card weekend almost upon us, and the Divisional playoffs, Conference championships and the Super Bowl just around the corner, I thought I would have a little fun.

So, welcome to the National Tool League, fantasy football style, circa 1954!

NFL%20Vintage%20Tool%20Bowl%20LOGO_zps4gqsbwak.jpg


This league features NFL teams – with a twist.

Instead of their prowess on the old gridiron, each NFL team will be represented by the tool manufacturers that were located in the team’s host city or in their surrounding geographical fan base area (according to the NFL’s current official fan map) – in 1954.

Why 1954?

That was the last year that most of the classic US automotive toolmakers, founded in the early part of the century by men who actually knew engines and tools (as opposed to corporate wonks), would operate as full-service independent companies. There had been some acquisitions prior to that (e.g., P&C and JP Danielson to Plomb in the 40’s, PEXTO to Billings & Spencer in 1951), but most of those companies continued making tools as wholly-owned brands, in their own plants, in their own style, through the early 1950’s. In 1955, when Blackhawk’s entire hand tool line was sold to New Britain, and all their manufacturing equipment hauled back east to Connecticut, becoming a managed brand of New Britain, it was the beginning of the end. Companies fell like dominoes after that.

In 1956, Utica was bought by Kelsey-Hayes.
In 1957, Bonney, already bought out by Miller Mfgring of Detroit a few years earlier, was moved to Alliance, Ohio; and Plomb changed its name to Pendleton.
In 1959, Pendleton bought Vlchek.
In 1960, Crescent fell out of family hands and became Crescent-Niagara, run by stockbrokers.
In 1961, Kelsey-Hayes bought Herbrand.
In 1962, 1963, and 1964, Crescent-Niagara bought Billings & Spencer, Barcalo, and Bridgeport Hardware and Manufacturing, becoming the first big conglomerate. In 1964, Kelsey-Hayes bought Bonney.
In 1967, Triangle bought Kelsey-Hayes and moved the Bonney, Utica, and Herbrand lines to Orangeburg, SC, becoming the second big conglomerate.
In 1968, Crescent-Niagara, already a conglomerate, became part of Cooper Industries, an even bigger conglomerate. Ironically, New Britain, which started the ball rolling, became a part of Litton Industries, and eventually, the Stanley empire.

The rest of the modern era story is just too ugly to retell.

In short, 1954 was the end of the vintage American tool world as we know it, in my opinion. Except for a handful of famous holdouts (Snap-On, Champion DeArment –now Channellock, Ridge, Wilde, etc), it’s all gone to hell (the bookkeeper’s bottom line!) or foreign production (same as hell!) in a hand basket (standardization!) since then.

So, that’s why 1954. A Pre-Expansion fantasy tool league, if you will. If you disagree, start your own fantasy tool league!:D
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
P

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
The twist!

Not every major tool manufacturing area had a football team in 1954. The New England Patriots, for example, did not exist in the AFL until 1959, and not in the NFL until 1970. So I stuck to 1954 in terms of tool manufacturing entities, but I time-machined the modern NFL into that era.

NFL%20Vintage%20Tool%20Bowl%20MAP_zpsfldc3rkw.jpg


The Rules

The rules I used were simple. Each team scored points as follows:
- Each DYNASTY tool company with a tool factory in the team’s fan base area was worth 3 TDs (18 points)
- Each MAJOR tool company with a tool factory in the fan base area was worth 1 TD (6 points)
- Each MINOR tool company with a tool factory in the fan base area was worth 1 FG (3 points)
- Each OBSCURE tool company with a tool factory in the fan base area was worth 1 SAFETY (2 points)
- Each PATENT that each company holds was worth 1 PAT (Point After TD) (1 point)

The difference between DYNASTY, MAJOR and MINOR was arbitrary. It was decided by a panel of three (3) active GJ ‘Vintage Tool Discussion’ board members. Every panelist rated each Mfgr on a list I assembled by their informed gut-feel for each Mfgr’s “stature,” based on a set of loose criteria I gave them, including size (volume of production), quality, technological significance, and reputation. For disagreements, I used a simply majority (2 out of 3), and, I was prepared to go with a middle (MAJOR) opinion if all three panelists disagreed, but that never happened, which goes to show how close the ratings were. In fact, the ratings were unanimous for over 80% of the list.

I was one of the panelists. I won’t name the other two, but they can reveal their participation on their own if they choose. And if they choose to remain anonymous, I will understand. If there’s anything more contentious than favorite tool brands, it’s favorite football teams. Combining the two topics geographically may just put all the crazies completely over the edge! :lol_hitti

I think the panel’s aggregate judgment turned out to be spot-on, but if you disagree, see the note above making your own fantasy tool league! :D

Patents were researched by using AA, DATAMP, or Google. Not vouching for 100% completeness or accuracy.

Also, if I excluded any tool Mfgr’s that could possibly make a serious shift in the results, I’d be surprised, but go ahead and fire away if you think I missed one.

Best I could do for a light-hearted geographical look at the mid-century vintage American tool industry – with a football fan’s lens on, and better than me just winging it.
 
Last edited:
OP
P

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
The Results

Now that I have explained the purpose, rules, and scoring, and before I reveal the results of the 1954 National Tool League season, does anyone care to venture a guess as to who will be the champions?
 

jakemac

Well-known member
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
9,035
Location
New England
The Patriots ! View media item 49836Southern New England had a lot of smaller manufacturers feeding the larger brands for years.
Until buyouts deflated our industrial base. :mad:
 
Last edited:

d42jeep

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 22, 2014
Messages
16,498
Location
Northern California
Despite my sentimental favorite, the Barcalo Buffalo Bills, I'm going to have to go with the New York Giants! There were a lot of manufacturing Giants in New York.
-Don
 

jumbojak

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 21, 2016
Messages
1,359
Location
Surry, VA
I have a feeling Chicago might surprise some folks. Maybe not championship material but they'll do well. The Redskins don't stand a chance!
 

1982fxr

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 7, 2012
Messages
9,997
Location
Phoenix
Packers have snap-on. Miller welding. Marquette welding? Empire level, not sure when they were founded though. Kastar but again... Johnson level

If broader rules...

Harley Davidson
Evinrude
Allis chalmers
Briggs and Stratton
Milwaukee jack
More others than I can count probably similar to the bears
 
Last edited:

notlob

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 19, 2013
Messages
1,384
Location
norcal
Raiders FTW! (Proto, Thorsen)
Packers FTW! (Snap-on, Blackhawk, etc.)
Patriots FTW! (Starrett, Millers Falls, GTD, New Britain, Stanley, Billings & Spencer, Moore drop forge, Morse, etc ad nauseum)
Browns FTW! (MAC, Cornwell, Wright, vlchek, Herbrand, Lectrolite etc.)
Jets FTW! (Williams, Crescent, kraeter, utica, etc)
Bears FTW! (SK, Duro, Armstrong etc)

I dunno - that "with a tool factory in the team’s fan base area" criteria makes it all too complicated.

:3gears:
 
Last edited:
OP
P

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
All very good choices. The Pats have a big area. Philly is often overlooked. And all the Great Lakes teams have some behemoths. I will drop an admission and a hint. I went with a Great Lakes metropolitan area team before I actually did the tally, and I was wrong!

I dunno - that "with a tool factory in the team’s fan base area" criteria makes it all too complicated.
Probably got too cute with that. HQ, factory, doesn't really mater. The point was location - and I really did use the NFL official fan map, which is NOT as straightforward as you might think. I will drop another big hint and say that the State of Ohio would pose a serious challenge to the winner if it went by state. The problem is that the freaking Steelers draw a lot of fans from the Browns and Bengals! And that's not the only issue. The Eagles, Jets, and Giants have some weird fan maps, too!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Rileysan

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 11, 2015
Messages
4,298
Location
Milwaukie, Oregon
I do have a question regarding your choice of adding Sears (Craftsman) to the list of manufacturers. While I might be nitpicking in stating they didn't manufacture their own tools, I don't disagree with their inclusion. I would, however, argue that you should also include at least one other major department store tool retailer (if not others - Western Auto?) by adding Montgomery Ward's to this list - giving Chicago another 18 pts. - and moving them even closer to second place.

Edit: Adding to the Chicago area, I see no mention of Bog tools. Too obscure?

Brian
 
Last edited:

NJ Marty

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
1,157
C.S. Osborne has been around since 1826, might be the biggest name in leather working tools.
 

twertsy

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 5, 2014
Messages
6,725
Location
Reedville, VA
Well, I had no clue what you were going to do with the tool company "rankings" but that turned out pretty cool. The "fan map" was an interesting choice of dividing up the areas. One minor correction, Bonney was bought by Miller in Feb, 1953.
 
OP
P

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
What a fun way to map out the major tool companies. I loved it!
Thanks, Brian.

I do have a question regarding your choice of adding Sears (Craftsman) to the list of manufacturers. While I might be nitpicking in stating they didn't manufacture their own tools, I don't disagree with their inclusion. I would, however, argue that you should also include at least one other major department store tool retailer (if not others - Western Auto?) by adding Montgomery Ward's to this list - giving Chicago another 18 pts. - and moving them even closer to second place.

Edit: Adding to the Chicago area, I see no mention of Bog tools. Too obscure?

I probably could and should have included Monkey Wards and Western Auto for the same reasons I include Sears & Roebuck, even though they weren't an OEM. One explanation, this list is really my wartime list of verified government suppliers, expanded to early 1950's. Montgomery Ward and Western Auto did not have contracts, and I tend to overlook them as the same category. But good point.

As for Bog, unless I am mistaken, they weren't making tools in 1954, not even as Cragin. So that was a conscious decision on my part. I also chose to let PENENS be morphed into Plomb (which wasn't really Plomb in 1954, either), but counted P&C and JP Danielson as separate production entities for the tally, even though they were part of Plomb/PROTO, which I do think was mistaken on my part. Maybe I should've counted PENENS as a production entity, so you could re-coup some points (at least 3) for PENENS. :)

Honestly, I went back and forth on the date. I was going to go with 1946, or even 1939, which would be more inclusive and less messy. Probably should have.

C.S. Osborne has been around since 1826, might be the biggest name in leather working tools.
Amen, Marty. My bad. :mad: But do their points go to the Jets or the Giants? :headscrat :D

Here are some pics of a pair of NOS double-bow punches I have to make up for my oversight!

20161020_204343_zps5az4nnoh.jpg


20161020_204418_zps03p2gbbn.jpg


20161020_204502_zpsgoomqo4p.jpg


20161020_204559_zpsyqjackrb.jpg


Well, I had no clue what you were going to do with the tool company "rankings" but that turned out pretty cool. The "fan map" was an interesting choice of dividing up the areas. One minor correction, Bonney was bought by Miller in Feb, 1953.
Thanks, Todd! I didn't want to ruin the surprise! And thanks for the correction: so the beginning of the end was even sooner than I thought. :eek:

HA ! Got it in one. :rocker: :D
You did, indeed, Jake. I was not shocked, but I'm glad some others chimed in with other thoughts. I am sure you realize that the Pats had a huge advantage in this game. Unlike the football cities around the Great Lakes industrial belt (Buffalo, Cleveland, Chicago, Milwaukee..), the Pats have a monopoly as a franchise on the entire Northeast. If, for example, Hartford and Providence had an NFL team, it would be akin to the situation between Buffalo, Cleveland, and Cincinnati. But, I will admit that even with an appreciation of the tool industry in that area, I underestimated the victory, and the margin of victory.
 

NJ Marty

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 20, 2014
Messages
1,157
I would add Osborne to the Jets since the other NJ companies are with them.
 
OP
P

Private Lugnutz

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 30, 2012
Messages
30,476
Location
The Authentic Jersey Shore
If I had not missed it, that's probably what I would do. North Jersey tends to get neglected when talk turns to big tool industry areas, but man, it was chock full. Since you live here, you know it's a funny state for loyalties. As soon as you cross the Manasquan river (or anything south of I-195), it's all Eagles. North of there, it's all Giants or Jets.
 

tym

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 5, 2016
Messages
2,429
Location
MA
Question. Is Roger Goodell also commissioner of the NTL, since he is the biggest tool of all?

;)
 
Last edited:

firworks

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 29, 2015
Messages
4,079
Location
IL
I didn't quite follow in the initial setup posts but this ended up being very cool. Good work!

Edit: Also ouch on SK failing to receive Dynasty status.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom