To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Reznor UDAP vs Hot Dawg - 45K what is quieter?

ED26

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 2, 2016
Messages
107
Location
MI
Reznor UDAP 45K vs Hot Dawg HD45A - 45K what is quieter?

Looking at tech specs listed online

MODINE Hot Dawg HD45A 45K BTU @ 5' 57 db

Reznor UDAP 45K BTU @ 15' 40 db

Obviously the distance further away will be quieter, trying to do a apples to apples comparison.

Reznor is around $300 more for the unit; but if quieter will be better in my attached garage

Thanks
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Chevy-SS

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 11, 2010
Messages
1,492
Location
Rhode Island
I believe my Hot Dawg is a 45k model. It is fairly loud, not obnoxious at all, but definitely not whisper quiet.
 
OP
E

ED26

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 2, 2016
Messages
107
Location
MI
Search online

Both manufacturers will list their DBA levels

Looking at tech specs listed online

MODINE Hot Dawg HD45A 45K BTU @ 5' 57 db

Reznor UDAP 45K BTU @ 15' 40 db

Obviously 15' away will be quieter, trying to get a real world apples to apples comparison, or if someone actually has a DB meter that would be perfect for some real world noise levels
 
OP
E

ED26

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 2, 2016
Messages
107
Location
MI
I believe my Hot Dawg is a 45k model. It is fairly loud, not obnoxious at all, but definitely not whisper quiet.

You think too loud for attached garage on the “shared” wall of home ? House is ranch. Not sure if will be able to hear through the walls inside the house when the unit kicks on , etc
 

kabinenroller

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
906
Location
S.E. Wisconsin USA
I was in a friends garage yesterday, he has a 35,000 BTU Hot Dawg. I commented to him how quite it was, it was running when I arrived and shut off while we were talking, we did not have to lower our voices after the unit shut down.
 

D45

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 21, 2014
Messages
4,836
Location
NW INDIANA
35k and 45k will be quiet........they use a small 10" fan (27' heat throw)

My 75k uses a 14" fan, but the heat throw is much farther (38').........so it will be a tad louder.

I am not concerned about the DBA level, not like the heater is running all the time
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

HoosierBuddy

Well-known member
Joined
May 9, 2006
Messages
2,931
Location
Southern Indiana
I don't know the answer to your question, but I appreciate that you are asking it. As I get older it becomes much more difficult for me to hear over the hanging heaters we have at work. Add in the fact everyone is wearing a mask, and it's pretty annoying.

Quieter is better!

Love my in floor radiant in my garage. I do get some noise from the zone pumps, but not enough to write home about. I wonder if anyone makes a db meter app? That would be interesting if we had some real world data from different systems.

Phil
 

Chevy-SS

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 11, 2010
Messages
1,492
Location
Rhode Island
You think too loud for attached garage on the “shared” wall of home ? House is ranch. Not sure if will be able to hear through the walls inside the house when the unit kicks on , etc

OK, I can answer this. My master bedroom wall abuts the garage. Right on the other side of the master bedroom wall (in the garage) hangs the Hot Dawg. Sometimes it goes on in the very cold weather and I can hear it, but ever so slightly. It certainly does not wake me up, or anything even close.
 

Attachments

  • hotdawg22.jpg
    hotdawg22.jpg
    90 KB · Views: 23

Showkey

"MEMBER EMERITUS"
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Messages
8,638
Location
Wausau WI
Love my in floor radiant in my garage. I do get some noise from the zone pumps, but not enough to write home about. I wonder if anyone makes a db meter app? That would be interesting if we had some real world data from different systems.

Phil


There are apps but calibration and consistency is a concern. If you were making measurements back to back comparison the app would be valid. But app compared to published spec is a problem. Just as the published specs are different because distance, height, environment and equipment used.......DIY sound measurement would be challenging.

Simple things like sound levels in front vs back of the heater might make for huge variation. Measurements in 10-12’ tall ceiling vs 8’ the variables are endless and with sound it make a huge difference. Other things like metal walls vs drywall play a part.

Same for App light meters........they work on back to back comparison measurements if done carefully.

Similar discussions come up in the GJ with volt meters. Not many are concern with a .1 or .01 of volt resolution when working on your garden tractor. So the meter quality and user techniques are not critical in making a troubleshooting decision.

I have an old Realistic sound meter we used in measuring customer complaints on road noise in the field. Crude yes. Measuring 15’ in front of my Beacon Morris 45k heater measure about 66 db. 4’ in the back near a metal wall measures 82 db. No not very scientific.........in just about every way. But if a heater manufacturer wanted to publish good db rating it would not be too hard to get a better measurement by changing the technique slightly.

B5C0CC36-CFA4-41D9-9489-8C6D3FC57090.jpg

E7703524-ACC1-4894-B203-7397F6918D9A.jpg

Free Apple App measure 59 db 15’ in front of the heater.

252CECD2-5CBD-43EF-A69E-76F851A4EC69.jpg

The phone app in the back was much more quiet at 68db. Which plays directly to the tool and technique. Not to mention the heater changes volume with run time.
The app gives frequency so you can see the two different motors running and the noise each makes.

Back to reality...........the heater noise is not a BIG concern to me. More fun facts and interesting.
 
Last edited:

zmotorsports

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Oct 20, 2009
Messages
21,441
Location
Northern Utah
I can't speak to the 45k btu version but I had an older Reznor 75k btu in my last shop and it was very quiet compared to the Hot Dawg 75k that I replaced it with. That thing sounded like a jet taking off and was obnoxious as hell.

When I built my new shop I specified with my contractor that I wanted the Reznor UDAP-150. It is very quiet, even being as large as it is. When it kicks on it isn't annoying at all and when doing video recording of projects I found I can continue to record unlike in my last shop.
 

csp

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 23, 2010
Messages
5,720
Location
Franktown, CO
Not sure if will be able to hear through the walls inside
the house when the unit kicks on , etc

45k Hot Dawg in my attached garage, mounted to the trusses with the recommended minimum clearance to the shared wall of the house.

Yes you can hear it when it is on inside the house, but you have to be actually listening for it. It's no louder in the room sharing the same wall than the furnace in the basement is to that room, if that makes sense.
 

Showkey

"MEMBER EMERITUS"
Joined
Aug 9, 2014
Messages
8,638
Location
Wausau WI
For comparison I measured the db in the kitchen hood fan ( high end hood) it was 68 db at 4’ distance. It’s not the motor or mounting Per se.........it’s the air moving making the noise.


Ad that app to your phone.......walk around the home or shop...........you might be surprised what making noise and how much.

In the basement the power vent water heater is a real noise maker.........
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom