It's a worktable I'm building from scrap that'll end up indoors at some point, I just don't see the point of grinding all that rust off if I can avoid it.Depends on how bad the rust is and what you are doing. If you're painting over it even por15 isn't a permanent solution and it can continue to rust underneath it ending up worse then when you started. Anything non drying like Krown, Rust Check or fluid film are the best ways of protecting it.
yeah, after watching some vids, looks like rustoleum is the way to go. There's a 'rust reformer' and 'rusty metal primer' that may be worth a shot but the later is a ****** color and the former only comes in a rattle can.If that's all you're doing wire brush the coarse rust off it and paint it with tremclad or rustoelum. No special prep and tons of color choices.
Your answer is Woolwax and they are currently having their Memorial Day 20% off sale (promo code: freedom). Just use compressed air to blow off the loose scale, hose it down and apply....I know POR-15 works but I don't need the hardness for my application. What other alternatives are out there (other than bathing metal in motor oil) that will cling to rust and prevent further rust?

I am wondering about the prep. I'm hesitant to wire brush as this just creates a rust dust layer. I hear you on the heavy scale and I think POR's best result is after using a needler, which is way too much work for my purpose over just using a grinder. I'm thinking I'll use a degreaser first and power washer 2nd then letting it air dry & give it a paint thinner wipe prior to paint last. Power washer should knock much of what would've chipped/blown away.Another vote for rustoleum. Will look great for years inside on benches/equipment etc.
Same as anything it will look as good as the effort you put into it. At the least knock off any heavy rust, wipe down with acetone and giver.