I’ve mentioned the yard sump pump at my beach cottage before. In July, I was told that the pump failed, yard flooded, and we lost a renter. Not being local, I had to send “a guy” over, in a hurry, to fix it. This was a Wednesday, new renters are arriving on Saturday.
Thursday, he tells me that he replaced the pump. He misunderstood how I had protected the power cable from damage, so he cut it. He also decided that the 3/4hp 140 gallon/minute pump I had was too expensive, so he replaced it with a 3/4hp 80 gallon/minute pump. This needed PVC changes, because the old pump has a 2” outlet, the new one is 1 1/2”.
I did get him to save the parts. Pump is two years old, with a three year warranty.
While there on vacation the last couple of weeks, I was able to get the pump replaced under warranty. As it turns out, they don’t want you to return the pump, it could be filled with nasty. So the directions are to cut the cord and return just the cord with the attached tags indicating what it was from, along with the original purchase receipt to prove the age. Did that. Got new pump.
Back at the cottage, I reinstalled the new 140 gal/minute pump, and fixed up the PVC to put it all back to 2”. I now have a like new 80 gal/minute pump to get rid of.
Back home with the remains of the “dead” pump. I put a repair plug on the stub of cord, plugged it in, and it runs fine. “?” At least the motor is good. Haven‘t had a look at the impeller yet. I also reconnected the (cut) float switch, and confirmed that it works fine too.
I don’t care about saving the pump, I already got its replacement for no additional cost to me. But now I’m left wondering what the original failure was in the first place. If it wasn’t the pump, then what?
For the price and time needed to do this twice, driving out there and doing it myself looks more and more attractive. It’s just under 1000 miles, 13 hours driving time, each way. Not great, but not having to re-fix someone else’s fix, and finding out what the actual problem is, does appeal. I guess I’ll see what happens next time it “fails”. As part of the re-fix, I added water flow and water level monitors. It should let me know every time the pump kicks in, and if the water level gets above the pump float, indicating that the pump has failed.
Edit: Impeller looks ok.