I've thought about buying that, but it gets a lot of negative reviews for product quality.
I didn't see any complaints about OTC's tool product quality. There was a complaint about the case breaking, and someone received an obviously used kit, but nothing about the parts breaking, screw stripping, etc. unlke the HF version.
Mike
I'm not seeing a lot of negative.
Reviews for the OTC
4.8 out of 5
99% rated between 5 and 3 stars
Reviews for HF's Maddox
4.7 out of 5
97% of customers would recommend this item
On the Maddox there are 3 different SKUs indicating changes have possibly been made.
2017 - 5 complaints
2018 - 2 complaints
2019 - 3 complaints
2020 - 0
2021 - 3 complaints
2022 - 3 complaints
2023 - 1 complaint
2024 - 2 complaints
2025 - 2 complaints
This doesn't represent a failing product and some issues are probably user error. Points to HF that it can easily be returned in 90 days and extended warranty can likely be purchased if desired.
OTC can be returned in 30 days to Amazon and they were not forthcoming with their warranty if there is one, you have to request it. There is an extended warranty available.
If you need to attach 5/8 thread accessories Maddox isn't for you, however a comment Oct 17, 2021 says
"This has the 5/8 thread pitch which fits most auto parts rental attachments". Comment Aug. 10, 2024
"I have since picked up a 5/8" x 18tpi x 36 threaded rod and made an extension for it...".
There was a ITC coupon to buy it for $74.99 that just expired and I do have wheel hubs I need to remove. When its on sale again I'll buy it.