Sounds like it depends on what industry you're talking about. The electrical industry is very different. Can't tell you how many times I've heard it's the journeymans job to teach from the higher ups. The apprentice's job to learn is a given. Duh. But there is a BIG difference between telling an apprentice hey go do that, vs. do this instead of that because of this reason. There is a thought process and a logical reason to do things a certain way, and to make the apprentice better, you need to share that information. People don't become professional athletes by watching sports on TV, they have experienced veterans others coach them.
I'm an apprentice and have learned next to nothing at work in the past few months doing something very similar to what you describe. Lately I've only asked questions to avoid being yelled at. Seriously, all of the time, I ask how to do something that I already know how to do excellently in every sense of the word because either I'll get stopped and told to do it in an inferior way, or because it's just a ****** no win situation, and by passing the decision buck to the journeyman, not allowing them to ***** about the decision.
NOTHING annoys me more than being expected to become skilled and develop expertise at a trade, but instead being instructed to perform mindless monotonous labor every day. The street goes both ways.
and nothing annoys the guys who have been doing it for a while more than a newbie who already knows it all but obviously isn't skilled enough to be called a journeyman or any other higher paid rate of mechanic or electrician depending on the place of work.
the first problem with some newbies/apprentice/etc is the sense of "ugh, why the hell do i have to do this, this is stupid". because they feel that it's pointless to do something like..... clean the shop, or clean up the press/lathe/mill, etc. when they could be out working on a project.
first thing to learn about being the new guy in an industry is that you are going to get the jobs that everyone else has already done as well that has to be done anyway, cleaning up, taking the trash out, organizing stock racks, running for parts.... it's all helpful in it's own way because if you get it in the new guys head that everybody has done it, and still does it, then they don't get that high and mighty sense that it's a waste of time.
i agree with cryan after reading through his posts, you don't seem to understand the relationship between a new guy and the guys who have been working in a shop for a while. work is a serious place, especially when it's a dangerous environment, but without the casual chatter, the once in a while joke, and the "hazing" as you think it should be called. then there is much less of a bond between the workers and more of a feeling of "being here because we have to be".
final words for you, chill out, deal with it, go with the flow, bite your tongue. you are apparently new to the game and think you know a better way of doing something.... great, then tell them that you think you know a better way and do it next time you do the job on your own and maybe it will work out. or even tell them while you are doing it and ask why it can't be done a certain way, they may have never thought about it like that. but if you get upset because they won't listen or don't want to listen because they've heard 100 other apprentice who know it all tell them the same thing before, then just shut up and wait til you are doing the job on your own then do your own thing. til then, be an apprentice