Do you guys really see good results with Evaporust? I got two gallons of it from HD on clearance and... It didn't really seem to do a whole lot. I've got bins of rusty old tools from auctions to clean up.
I get excellent results with Evaporust but you really need to know how to use it, soaking time and knowing what it cleans well and what it doesn't.
As mentioned earlier, it's critical to degrease the items before, Evaporust is not a degreaser and the grease will only prevent Evaporust getting to the rust & metal. Quickly degrease the items, let it dry as degreaser can neutralize the evaporust, when dry then soak in Evaporust, you will then get much better results.
I found 8-12 hrs to be the magic length of soaking time. You can get away with 16 hours but If you forget about it you could be in trouble. After 30 hrs in hot dry weather I had a tray full of black goop and tools sticking to the tray, it was a total mess.
It's best to cover the tray while soaking as it will quickly evaporate.
Evaporust works best with chrome plated items like sockets, the results can be astonishingly good. Non-plated steel items with iron can become dark grey but that will clean off with light wire brushing, Brasso or polishing. If the item is heavily rusted then there will most likely be pitting and there's nothing that can be done about that, Evaporust or anything else on this planet can not fill in the pits and make it shiny without wire brushing or polishing down smooth.
What's great about Evaporust is that it can go into spots that is not normally reachable and kill the rust in there. You don't have to use water to rinse the evaporust off, if you do it can sometimes give you flash rust.
A gallon actually goes a long way if you recycle it. I use a funnel with two coffee filters in it with great results to refill what I have left back into the Evaporust container.
Walmart has free shipping to your nearest store and currently its $17/gallon.
https://www.walmart.com/ip/Evapo-Rust-Super-Safe-Rust-Remover-Gallon/48810395
Electrolysis is great and I agree it's easier for larger parts like a big vise but it will not give you the same shiny clean results as I can get with Evaporust cleaning hand tools.
I hope this helps