To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

workbench question

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
I am making a workbench out of primed Douglas fir and pine and am looking for a finish for it. It will be in the garage but the garage is not temp controlled so it will be getting descent temp changes throughout the year. I have read about a lot of people using boiled linseed oil but am not sure if it can take the temp changes.

Any suggestions?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

bmwpowere36m3

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2012
Messages
1,125
Primed? You want to stain/clear it or paint it? Honestly doesn't really matter... anything will work, even untreated (unless its sitting in a wet area or dirt).
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
Primed? You want to stain/clear it or paint it? Honestly doesn't really matter... anything will work, even untreated (unless its sitting in a wet area or dirt).

Sorry, it's prime douglas fir. I want to just coat it with something since the area can get wet at times on the floor and I don't want a warping or mold issue.
 

bmwpowere36m3

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2012
Messages
1,125
If its primed then oil won't do anything other than make a mess. Get a small can of exterior paint (oil or latex) and put a few coats on lower portion of the workbench legs.
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
If its primed then oil won't do anything other than make a mess. Get a small can of exterior paint (oil or latex) and put a few coats on lower portion of the workbench legs.

It's not primed, it's called prime Douglas fir. Just the type of wood I used. There is nothing on it.
 

Maui

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2012
Messages
2,897
Location
Upstate NY
What type of finish do you want? I have used tongue oil with good success. It produces a beautiful finish that will not allow water to be absorbed into the wood provided you put on enough coats (I use 5 coats). With daily use the finish is very durable.

Maui
 

astroracer

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2005
Messages
3,001
Location
Mid_Michigan
Any finish you want to use will work just fine. Polyurethane is good as is any of the gel stains if you want some color. Do a few test samples to make your decision. Many of the stains are available in sample sizes.
Mark
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
Thanks for the suggestions. I was thinking of using an oil like teak or boiled linseed. Something that will protect it but not make it slick.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

SteveCh

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 21, 2012
Messages
1,053
Thanks for the suggestions. I was thinking of using an oil like teak or boiled linseed. Something that will protect it but not make it slick.

I have used linseed for many, many things like this. It will smell a while, but eventually that will be gone. If you use it, I recommend you make a solution of a gallon of paint thinner or turpentine, mix in a cup of linseed oil, and brush it on. One good coat should do it, though I've been known to use more than one coat [letting the first thoroughly dry] if something is gonna be left outdoors.] This is a recipe the US Forest Service worked out way back in the sixties or earlier for use on some of their remote cabins [the window sills, etc.]. The cheapest house brand of paint thinner is fine. Store the solution in an air-tight jug or other container. I often use an empty five-qt. oil jug. If the stuff has been sitting a while, shake or stir it before using as the linseed oil can separate a bit and collect in the bottom of the container. Some of it, any way.

Note: I have increased that ratio of oil to paint thinner, time or two, thinking maybe it would give even better protection. However, sometimes that resulted in leaving a sticky surface. You don't want that on a work surface.
 
Last edited:

BikerDad

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 24, 2014
Messages
975
Location
Utah
Go out to the garage. Find whatever clear(ish) finish you have. Slap it liberally on the bench. Top and bottom. Call it good.

In the event you don't have any clear(ish) finishes, head down to your local paint monger. Find whatever clear(ish) finish that is inexpensive and easy to apply. Buy it. Head home, slap it liberally on the bench. Top and bottom. Call it good.

Do NOT sand the workbench top past 120 grit. I wouldn't even sand it past 80 grit. The finer the sanding, the smoother, and thus, slicker, the top will be.

3 days after you put the finish on, go out to the bench carrying your coffee. Slosh the coffee around so some drips down the sides of the cup. Set the cup down on the bench. Find a couple of condiment packets. Set them down on the bench. Smash the packets with the coffee cup. Get a greasy rag and play with it for a while, then play patty-cake on your bench.

Go back inside. Wash your hands. Finish your coffee. Clean the bench next day. Now it's broken in and you won't obsessively try to keep it pristine.

It's a workbench, not the table in a formal dining room.
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
Go out to the garage. Find whatever clear(ish) finish you have. Slap it liberally on the bench. Top and bottom. Call it good.

In the event you don't have any clear(ish) finishes, head down to your local paint monger. Find whatever clear(ish) finish that is inexpensive and easy to apply. Buy it. Head home, slap it liberally on the bench. Top and bottom. Call it good.

Do NOT sand the workbench top past 120 grit. I wouldn't even sand it past 80 grit. The finer the sanding, the smoother, and thus, slicker, the top will be.

3 days after you put the finish on, go out to the bench carrying your coffee. Slosh the coffee around so some drips down the sides of the cup. Set the cup down on the bench. Find a couple of condiment packets. Set them down on the bench. Smash the packets with the coffee cup. Get a greasy rag and play with it for a while, then play patty-cake on your bench.

Go back inside. Wash your hands. Finish your coffee. Clean the bench next day. Now it's broken in and you won't obsessively try to keep it pristine.

It's a workbench, not the table in a formal dining room.

Darn it! Now I have to buy condiment packets! This is getting expensive.
 

Zeeman

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 21, 2016
Messages
1,185
Location
Bartow County Georgia
I would not put a urethane finish or varnish on it if it was mine. I have just finished up two work benches, and I put BLO (boiled linseed oil) on the maple one. It soaked in pretty fast, and it does smell like mentioned above. Several coats is the way to go. anything like urethane that does not penetrate the wood will just crack and come off over time.
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
I would not put a urethane finish or varnish on it if it was mine. I have just finished up two work benches, and I put BLO (boiled linseed oil) on the maple one. It soaked in pretty fast, and it does smell like mentioned above. Several coats is the way to go. anything like urethane that does not penetrate the wood will just crack and come off over time.

Thanks for the comment. I think I am definitely going with an oil, just torn between boiled and teak.
 

jeremy v

Banned
Joined
Jul 26, 2011
Messages
784
What kind of work will you mainly be doing on it? Lots of water based liquids, building furniture, oils and/or fuels dripping, heavy impact forces, etc? Depending on what you will be using it for you might be better off just laying a thin sheet of masonite, plywood, etc. over the top and leaving it as is. Do whatever you want to the top without worry, because you just change out the surface sheet to a new one whenever it wears out, gets beaten up, cut up from a utility knife, covered in many layers of spray paint, etc.

In as far as oils, I just use regular mineral oil from the drug store for all my wood tool handles. It works great and it's cheap. That's the same oil most people use for wood cutting boards in the kitchen to give you an idea of what the surface would be like. I get that nice velvety feel without any smell, stickiness, etc. on my tool handles. Sometimes I warm up the wood handle first with a propane torch or a heat gun to help aid absorption and reduce the wet time, but it is usually absorbed pretty completely within a day or two.

Just don't put too much of any oil on the end grain of the lumber at one time or it might crack the ends a little bit from the oil absorbing and swelling the wood too fast.

I don't have any experience with oiling an actual workbench, so I don't know much about how well any oiled surface would hold up to something like gasoline drips or a spilled solvent for instance.
 
OP
F

fech

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 22, 2015
Messages
116
What kind of work will you mainly be doing on it? Lots of water based liquids, building furniture, oils and/or fuels dripping, heavy impact forces, etc? Depending on what you will be using it for you might be better off just laying a thin sheet of masonite, plywood, etc. over the top and leaving it as is. Do whatever you want to the top without worry, because you just change out the surface sheet to a new one whenever it wears out, gets beaten up, cut up from a utility knife, covered in many layers of spray paint, etc.

In as far as oils, I just use regular mineral oil from the drug store for all my wood tool handles. It works great and it's cheap. That's the same oil most people use for wood cutting boards in the kitchen to give you an idea of what the surface would be like. I get that nice velvety feel without any smell, stickiness, etc. on my tool handles. Sometimes I warm up the wood handle first with a propane torch or a heat gun to help aid absorption and reduce the wet time, but it is usually absorbed pretty completely within a day or two.

Just don't put too much of any oil on the end grain of the lumber at one time or it might crack the ends a little bit from the oil absorbing and swelling the wood too fast.

I don't have any experience with oiling an actual workbench, so I don't know much about how well any oiled surface would hold up to something like gasoline drips or a spilled solvent for instance.

Thanks for the info bud. I will put on light coats
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom