I know you said you didn't really want to program the lights, but I installed a programmable timer switch from Home Depot in place of a regular switch for two sets of lights at my house. The switch was in the garage, same as yours, and in order for me to turn the lights on and off I had to go into the garage each time to do so. That got old real fast, because my wife and I would sometimes forget to shut them off and they would stay on all day, so I installed one of these.
It can be programed to turn the lights on whenever you want, and shut off whenever you want on different days of the week (7 day programmable), or it can be set to turn the lights on at dusk and off at dawn. Or you can even use it like a regular switch by pushing the big button.
I have it set to come on at dusk and then shut off at midnight. I can't even tell you how many headaches this thing has saved me, as well as the savings on the electricity. Don't throw out the idea of programing the lights with one of these. It is cheap, easy to install, and requires no afterthought when you are laying in bed and thinking did I shut off those lights or not?
Sorry for the big picture, but I copied the link right from the Home Depot website.
Jim