I have the now discontinued HF 95136 40A Plasma Cutter and I've cut thousands of feet in 1/4" steel with it. For the $650 I paid, it's been well worth the last 8yrs of use. When it dies it will be a new HyperTherm 45 or 65 for me, but I might just look for another 95136 on eBay

I've spent a few hundred in consumables so far.
That said not all of the S45 consumables are the same. The cheapos in bulk on Ebay, etc from many sellers are Chinese made and do not last as long as the Italian OEM tips. The copper cups burn out 2-3 times faster. I will say that the silver electrodes from China are cheap and seem to last a long time. I usually swap a cup/electrode at the same time as when the electrode blows it will take the cup with it.
Plasma's need DRY DRY DRY air. My airline setup is not ideal right now coming into the humid summer but I get at least 100ft of cutting in 1/4" material with a few pierces on a set of tips. Sometimes though I can cut all weekend and I know it's been 200ft+
I use a roller stand off for the Trafimet torch, about $50 on eBay, and run the 40A pipe tips mostly. I've also had good luck with the thicker looking drag tips. I do not buy any of the lower amperage tips since I usually have the machine set on max all the time. I think the only difference is kerf thickness anyway and I'm not cutting thinner material with detail.