Koken 1/4" ratchet handles compared. Tooth count: how low can you go?
When I first started buying ratchets, I was like most folks and thought that tooth count was the be all and end all of quality. So I got a 72-tooth Tone ratchet and was quite happy with it.
But then after reading all the positive reviews of Koken ratchets here, I decided to try one, so I got the Koken 1/4" Z-EAL 2725Z 36-tooth ratchet. After playing around with the Z-EAL a bit, I understood why people love them so much. The Koken had about 1/3 the backdrag of the Tone. WIN!
The only thing I didn't like about the Z-EAL was the selector lever, which always seemed to get hung up, not switch unless you fiddled around with it, and then fail to engage positively. Frankly, it felt really cheap. So I checked out the Japanese reviews at Amazon Japan, and of the three reviewers, one gave the 1/4" Z-EAL 5 stars due to the lighter action than the KTC ratchet it replaced, but the other two gave it 1 star due the the sloppy and balky selector lever. One guy said he had many other Koken tools, but thought that this particular model was not up to Koken standards. (BTW, this only applies to the 1/4" Z-EAL, the 3/8" Z-EAL [which I also have] is absolutely great.) I also personally don't particularly care for plastic handles.
So I decided to try out the Koken 2753NB 20-tooth ratchet, even though it was inexplicably more expensive than the 36-tooth Z-EAL. The main things I like about the 2753NB are the quick release button and the knurled steel handle. The backdrag is just as low as (or maybe even lower than) the Z-EAL. In addition, the selector lever switches easily and positively and has a high quality feel.
So I guess I'm perfectly happy with a 20-tooth [!!!] ratchet. Admittedly, I might feel differently about the low tooth count if I were an auto mechanic and had to work in crowded engine bays on a daily basis, but I'm only a home handyman, so access is almost never an issue for me.
Here are some pictures. (The Z-EAL is the one with the black handle.)
View media item 84530
View media item 84531
View media item 84532
View media item 84533