Looking good there, Dan
As you probably already know, that model Craftsman was made in the USA by Columbian.
Most of the Craftsman vises in that category I remember as being red. But as many on these pages say...”your vise, your color”
Whether it’s a user or a shelf queen, it’s your eyes that will be looking at it, not ours. I've seen pink vises, bright purple, camouflage, chrome, racing stripes, college colors, favorite sports team colors, weird decals... the list goes on.
Vises aren’t too hard to repaint so don’t lose any sleep worrying about what’s correct. I once rehabbed a Wilton Tradesman and painted it Sunrise red to closely match SnapOn tool boxes. It came out nice if I say so myself. I found a buyer but when he saw the vise he said it was too bright. To save the deal, I threw in a new can of Rustoleum Verde Green. He was very happy and I put $200 in my wallet.