I've never had much luck getting a truly good surface. There's just too much dust or bugs in the air. When I made the maple peninsula top for my kitchen, I finished it with a product called Waterlox, kind of an old-school varnish, I guess. After building up enough coats, it looked good, but had the usual dust in it. I used a cabinet scraper to get it smooth, then buffed it with fine steel wool. It was a lot of work, but came out gorgeous! Satiny smooth. After 60+ years, I finally figured out how to get a furniture-grade finish.
I have a friend that builds really high-dollar guitars. He sands and buffs and polishes until they look like glass. They look like **** when they come out of the spray booth; the magic happens in finishing.