Sigh.
I talked to the customer service folks at MAC yesterday. Spent over 38 minutes on hold while multi-tasking on other things, then had to discuss with a front line rep before he put me in queue to get a supervisor that could take a look into the issue. It's worth pointing out that when I tried to explain the warranty debacle with this guy, it was clear he had no idea what I was talking about. "You know how ratchets and extensions work, with the spring loaded (detent) ball to retain the socket, right? That's what was broken." "No, sorry, I'm not a technician and I don't know anything about tools." Good to know this is who MAC Tools has answering the phones in customer service. I could tell where this was going to go, but I pressed on regardless.
Fast forward to the 62 minute mark, after lots of hold time, a supervisor comes on the line and one of the first things she tells me is that she doesn't really understand their warranty terms or how it works but to "go ahead and explain" my issue. I did so, and she points out that my shipment was inspected by "Brenda" and then signed off on by "Missy" her supervisor, which is consistent with what was scribbled on the rejection paperwork they sent back with the tools.
I asked her how it was that Brenda and Missy could **** up warranty inspection on a 6", 1/4" drive extension that has literally one moving part, the same moving part that I indicated in my included note (per their warranty requirements) was defective. She had no answer except maybe the note got lost when they opened the box and they didn't know what the issue was because "not everyone here is familiar with hand tools and how they're supposed to work." I pointed out that if you're not at least familiar with the basics like a socket or an extension, that was pretty embarrassing, and that if you don't know how the **** works, maybe you shouldn't have a job inspecting WHETHER OR NOT IT WORKS when people send it in for warranty. I also asked how it was that two people between them didn't have the wherewithal to figure out it was broken. "Well, Missy does not actually audit 100% of the warranty claims that she signs off on, so she may not have ever seen this and just signed off because she trusted Brenda." I pointed out that your signature makes you responsible regardless. Apparently this concept was as foreign to them as the operation of detent ball.
I also told her that it was incredibly asinine to get a box of brand new, untouched tools and send them right back to the customer without trying to assess the problem first. The paperwork they sent back had my phone # on it, so I know they had to have gotten my note in the box. They could have called if they didn't understand. Instead, they thought the most customer-centric, empathetic thing to do after someone spent good money to mail the tools in was to send it all back with a terse note about "no damage, warranty rejected." I was told to give them a day to look into it and for customer service to connect with MIssy about this piss poor warranty experience. Shocker of shockers, I never heard back from anyone.
Sorry to say, but never again will I spend a nickel with these clowns. What a ******* circus.