To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Who makes the best flare nut wrenches?

stillnostrebor

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 1, 2019
Messages
622
Location
SW Missouri
I put together a set of used SO open end/Flare end SAE wrenches for roughly $85 total about a year ago. Ebay netted a partial set, and a few singles to finish it out. The wrenches are not in perfect condition, but all work like they should.

I've owned several other flavors of line wrenches. None compared to SO for loosening cranky, rusted, boogered tube nuts. These are the only SO tools I have.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Steve_P

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 15, 2010
Messages
5,188
The consensus here is always snap on, "everything else spreads", so I'm looking forward to the test results to see how awesome SO is compared to the others. I have the USA RP Craftsman in inch, they were always fine for me, and Craftsman Pro (by SK) and SO in metric. I bought the SO in metric and then got a great deal on the Cman/SK and couldn't pass them up. The SK are shorter than SO as someone mentioned. SK are a little beefier on the ends than SO. Deflection prior to plastic yielding ("spreading") is based on the geometry (OD, thickness) of the steel at the wrench end, and not the heat treat, alloy, etc. I can't remember if SK was on the test list, but I'd be surprised if it's inferior to SO.
 
Joined
Jan 31, 2022
Messages
10
So thinking of getting a flare nut wrench set looking at the MAC's are around 299ish for 6 metric around same price for Snap-Ons sk doesn't look terrible but I think they sold to China recently? Don't really wanna do matco as I'm pretty sure it's a rebrand I'd would also be interested in maybe a flare nut crows feet set just never used them so I can decide what would be the better option
the Wright flair nuts are the best, snap-on quality for much cheaper and USA-made.
 

Komet

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 27, 2022
Messages
287
Location
WA
I watched ebay for quite some time to find these Snap-On sets. The SAE set was only $100 but I paid $250 for the metric set. They are absolutely excellent, never damaged a single fastener, didn't even scratch my -AN fittings.
 

Attachments

  • 20220428_184911.jpg
    20220428_184911.jpg
    457.3 KB · Views: 98

89MustangGX

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 24, 2008
Messages
1,023
Location
Stanwood, WA
I watched ebay for quite some time to find these Snap-On sets. The SAE set was only $100 but I paid $250 for the metric set. They are absolutely excellent, never damaged a single fastener, didn't even scratch my -AN fittings.
I am working on the same, thanks to this thread. I picked up a new SAE set for $129 I believe, but hoping to find a really nice metric set for less than $250. Supply and demand I guess...
 

Willie Makeit

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 30, 2013
Messages
921
Snap On

Period... thread is done... there are no more answers
Agreed. I am not a SnapOn fanboy as I am but a humble weekend warrior & hot rodder. But I own Craftsman (raised-panel & full polished Professional versions), S-K, Proto and SnapOn flare wrench sets. I collected these sets in an effort to find the best set that works for me. I piddle with older (read: rusty) vehicles and the SnapOn units that have a flare wrench head on one end and a thicker standard open-end wrench head on the other end are hands down the outright winner. SnapOn is expensive for guys like me that don't make their living with their tools, but I am a firm believer in their screwdrivers, ratchets, body hammers and flare nut wrenches.
 
Last edited:

ecotec

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
5,474
I watched ebay for quite some time to find these Snap-On sets. The SAE set was only $100 but I paid $250 for the metric set. They are absolutely excellent, never damaged a single fastener, didn't even scratch my -AN fittings.
Those vintage sets are beautiful. They look NOS or barely used. That is my favorite kind of vintage. You did great.

They will be a joy for you to live and work with.
 

m6z

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 13, 2019
Messages
2,325
Location
Missouri
It's really not a matter of how often you use them, it's a matter of removing the flare nut or rounding it off and replacing it.

It's true.

Though, you can always use a pair of visegrips to tighten up a buggered fitting. It's not like you're going to be removing it a second time.. :D
 

Dave455

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
5,832
Location
Sussex, England
Since I first replied to this thread I’ve been assisting a friend change some brake calipers. The pipe unions were “well on”. He tried an open ender - no luck, and rounded it a bit.

Next plan - borrow a flare nut wrench. When you borrow a tool you risk getting one from the “loan box”, which we did. Older Taiwan made, decent enough, but still wouldn’t shift it, and rounded it a bit more.

In the end we did what I should have done at the start and drove to mine to use my Snap On. Took it off straight away…!

As far as current production flare nut wrenches go, it’s pretty much got to be Snap On. There may be some as good (Hazet?) but I don’t believe there are better, and there are certainly many worse.

One observation - a couple of folks have suggested it’s not worth it as a “weekend warrior” - you don’t use them enough. Given the price of labour at the moment, I reckon you only need to do one job that you couldn’t otherwise, and the tool’s paid for!

Where you can save is by just buying the size(s) you need for your own vehicle. Probably only the pro, or industrial fitter, needs full sets(s) - but to confirm my GJ credentials I have Metric Snap On, a couple of Metric Hazet, American size Snap On, older Britool BS sizes, and the older Blue Point (pre Snap On) single enders in BS - probably the most under rated of all, although those vintage Snap On’s above are exquisite!

Edit - probably should have some pics - top to bottom - Snap On, Hazet, Britool and Blue Point. The Snap On look like they are broached off centre but they are made that way deliberately.

The Britool are beasts, but they’re designed more for pulling a fuel pipe off a diesel locomotive than a brake pipe from a Morris Minor! The handles on the Blue Point are proportionally shorter, which can be very handy.136A092C-325C-475F-81F1-2A43FC66466E.jpeg0924F506-756D-483B-B7B7-3F5A971C8F41.jpeg
 
Last edited:

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,166
Location
Southeastern Pa
Since I first replied to this thread I’ve been assisting a friend change some brake calipers. The pipe unions were “well on”. He tried an open ender - no luck, and rounded it a bit.

Next plan - borrow a flare nut wrench. When you borrow a tool you risk getting one from the “loan box”, which we did. Older Taiwan made, decent enough, but still wouldn’t shift it, and rounded it a bit more.

In the end we did what I should have done at the start and drove to mine to use my Snap On. Took it off straight away…!

As far as current production flare nut wrenches go, it’s pretty much got to be Snap On. There may be some as good (Hazet?) but I don’t believe there are better, and there are certainly many worse.

One observation - a couple of folks have suggested it’s not worth it as a “weekend warrior” - you don’t use them enough. Given the price of labour at the moment, I reckon you only need to do one job that you couldn’t otherwise, and the tool’s paid for!

Where you can save is by just buying the size(s) you need for your own vehicle. Probably only the pro, or industrial fitter, needs full sets(s) - but to confirm my GJ credentials I have Metric Snap On, a couple of Metric Hazet, American size Snap On, older Britool BS sizes, and the older Blue Point (pre Snap On) single enders in BS - probably the most under rated of all, although those vintage Snap On’s above are exquisite!
3/8", 7/16" 10mm, 12mm, 13mm, mostly for brake lines, you seldom see larger sizes used for Power Steering and A/C lines give you issues the smaller sizes do.
 

WWheeler

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
4,105
Location
Middleofnowhere USA
I've had my old Snap-On's for over 40 years. Never a need to buy new ones.

These look interesting, though:



****, you had to go posting that. I'd never heard of them before, but now I'd really like to have a metric set of those line wrenches and their O2 sensor wrenches too. It'll have to wait though as I'm pretty much spent out at the moment. Hopefully in the meantime someone (@Torque Test Channel ?) will include them in a round of testing to see how they stack up comparatively to Snap-ons and others.
 

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,166
Location
Southeastern Pa
I've had my old Snap-On's for over 40 years. Never a need to buy new ones.

These look interesting, though:


They work well on diesel fuel injection lines, but I've never used a line wrench on that application normally.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

WWheeler

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
4,105
Location
Middleofnowhere USA
Flare nut wrenches are like tightrope walkers. Just because you're not a professional tightrope walker, would you get a "prosumer" tightrope? You only really get one go at it.

-Ryan
Yep. I used to scoff at the cost of Snap-on line wrenches until the first and last time I had to make up a new brake line after I mangled one so terribly with my old USA Craftsmans. It was a family member's car, not mine, so it wasn't like I could just vise grip it off & on and call it good for now. I also got a stern reminder in how much I **** at fabricating anything more than a single bend in a brake line. I realized then and there that Snap-on flare nut wrenches aren't overpriced at all. Worth. Every. Penny.
 

WWheeler

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2015
Messages
4,105
Location
Middleofnowhere USA
I've had my old Snap-On's for over 40 years. Never a need to buy new ones.

These look interesting, though:



****, you had to go posting that. I'd never heard of them before, but now I'd really like to have a metric set of those line wrenches and their O2 sensor wrenches too. It'll have to wait though as I'm pretty much spent out at the moment. Hopefully in the meantime someone (@Torque Test Channel ?) will include them in a round of testing to see how they stack up comparatively to Snap-ons and others.
I take it back. I'm not interested in these any more. Looked like a great idea but... (WARNING, the following video is FULL of F-Bombs. ****!)

THE REAL TRIBUS TOOLS REVIEW THEY DON'T WANT YOU TO KNOW ABOUT (BAD LANGUAGE ****!)​

 

Re-Tired

Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2022
Messages
20
Wow. So much for the "Made in America" mantra.

Thanks for showing that video. It's much appreciated.
 

70staged

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 8, 2013
Messages
200
I have husky, s&k and 2 sets of snap on. Husky and SK are in one box at one shop and the Snap On sets are at the other shop. I prefer the Snap on ones as the seem to fit better and feel better in the hand. Reason for 2 sets is because one set is flare on one side and open end on the other side and I really like that style. Break it loose flip wrench over and get the line off faster.

 
OP
P

Persimmons1123

Active member
Joined
Jun 15, 2021
Messages
42
Just a little update I originally purchased the matco metric flare but set and they are just way to bulky and the fit on the fastner is a little loose ended up getting snap on metric set and man its deffently a massive diffrence the fit on fastners is very noticeable and the overall shape and size of the head is much less bulky and the finish is almost perfect not that it matters highly recommend the snap on flare wrenches after using them thoroughly compared to my matco and sunex sets
 

neophyte

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 23, 2012
Messages
9,802
Location
Pennsylvannia
Wow. So much for the "Made in America" mantra.

Thanks for showing that video. It's much appreciated.
Like most things, you need to be very knowledgable about numerous aspects of engineering and material science in order to get a product “right”, or at least not screw it up,
Or you need to be lucky.
Tribus presumably screwed up their heat treat, or their manufacturing process, resulting in brittle steel.
It doesn’t mean all US made tools ****, or all don’t.
Plenty of import tools ****. The tools are just cheap enough that people toss the bad tools in the garbage and move on with their life.
 
OP
P

Persimmons1123

Active member
Joined
Jun 15, 2021
Messages
42
Like most things, you need to be very knowledgable about numerous aspects of engineering and material science in order to get a product “right”, or at least not screw it up,
Or you need to be lucky.
Tribus presumably screwed up their heat treat, or their manufacturing process, resulting in brittle steel.
It doesn’t mean all US made tools ****, or all don’t.
Plenty of import tools ****. The tools are just cheap enough that people toss the bad tools in the garbage and move on with their life.
The ratcheting flare nut wrench idea is cool but I've never had an issue with flare nut wrenches they all do the same thing some just have a tighter fit I would never pay that much for tools tho just because they are made in usa dont get me wrong I love a good made in the states tools but if they are all made with materials from other country's is it really made in usa?¿ when thoose tribus's came out I just laughed way to much for a problem that wasn't really a problem
 

JWC86

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2021
Messages
270
Sometimes I hate this site. I’ve had a set of flare nut wrenches on the back of my mind for a couple years and then today I started researching it again and ended up here. 1 hr later I have a 7 piece set of SO line wrenches on the way from eBay.

I always just assumed flare nuts stripped all the time. Hopefully now this will become less common.

FYI, I’m a home DIY user.
 
Last edited:

threewood

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 9, 2014
Messages
419
Location
Yuma, AZ
Snap On. I bought mine used on Ebay. I had been using a set of older Craftsman flare nut wrenches but was not happy with them. The SO are much better fit wise.
 

peejay75

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
312
(I've posted this elsewhere, promise this'll be the last one!)

Clutch m/c fitting:

SK 10mm flare, nope
Duralast 10mm open, nope
Duralast 4" crescent, nope
Irwin 4LW, waiting on delivery
 

bonneyman

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
8,857
Location
Desert SW
Sometimes I hate this site. I’ve had a set of flare nut wrenches on the back of my mind for a couple years and then today I started researching it again and ended up here. 1 hr later I have a 7 piece set of SO line wrenches on the way from eBay.

I always just assumed flare nuts stripped all the time. Hopefully now this will become less common.

FYI, I’m a home DIY user.
Yeah, it's like with hot chicks - you hate 'em because you know they're gonna cost you. Yet before you know it you're calling them! :LOL:
 

F-22

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 23, 2022
Messages
1,830
What I really wonder is how the Facom (and USAG) flare nut wrenches compare. Their shoulder design seems unique on the market. However the retainer surely must help bolster them.

USAG:
1.jpg

Facom:

43-12X14_1.jpgY2358044-01?pgw=1.jpg


Adding extra material on the "inner" side of the hex like this seems like it should exponentially reinforce them. From the design standpoint I think this is the strongest flare nut wrench. The only way for Snap On to be stronger is if their steel is just that much better or if they are "more fat".
 

peejay75

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
312
I was hoping that would work, but nope, 3/8" was too small! I did semi-measure the fitting, it's approx 10.13mm~10.19mm...then measured the SK wrench, approx 10.21mm...none of that is too scientific, but ball-park.
 

peejay75

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2017
Messages
312
See the “tiny pipe wrench” thread…

IMG_4331.jpeg
Considered those, but trying to not "mar" the fitting any more than I already have, if possible. (Also trying to stay away from heat because there's alot of plastic and wiring in the area...worst case, i'll cut the line, remove the fitting and gulp, fabricate a new one!)
 

Jeff

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
2,706
Location
Sonova Beach
As a DIYer, I couldn't justify the cost for something I rarely use. Kind of like a basin wrench.

I pieced together a USA made Craftsman set for about $41.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom