To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Legit tool reviews

Joined
Mar 8, 2026
Messages
12
What are some reputable tool reviewers that aren't just shilling anything and everything?

Seems like more and more channels are slanging whatever they get paid for regardless if it's useful or decent quality.

Catus Maximus on YouTube is one that isn't obviously sponsored. On the other hand, guys like Mr. Subaru are just promoting anything they get sent. There are a few Japanese youtubers that are pretty unbiased as well.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Callelle

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 3, 2022
Messages
637
Location
Depew NY
Project Farm, Torque Test Channel, and Tools Tested are the only ones I actually use for hard info. Everything else I take as just an opinion.

CatusMaximus I like, though he seems to dock anything that costs more than a few dollars. His cat appears on screen every now and then so I give him points for that.
Last Best Tool is both a shill, and his opinion *****. He pretty clearly never actually uses anything, and seems to take sponsors for content left and right. Small props for giving Catus some more stuff to review though.
Mr.Subaru makes me want to puke.
 

YesIHaveAHammer

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2025
Messages
811
To add to the above;

Tinker with Tools, mainly (only?) power tools.

Lone Star Mopars, it's unboxings but in long form so he talks about his work and how different tools do/will fit in.

German Tool Reviews, but hasn't been active in many years.

Many of the others I appreciate but only for discovery of what tools exist, close up views, or what people say in the comments.
 

CHI_Tool&Die

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 20, 2021
Messages
1,383
Location
Chicago, IL
To add to the above;

Tinker with Tools, mainly (only?) power tools.

Lone Star Mopars, it's unboxings but in long form so he talks about his work and how different tools do/will fit in.

German Tool Reviews, but hasn't been active in many years.

Many of the others I appreciate but only for discovery of what tools exist, close up views, or what people say in the comments.
Lone Star Mopar is super underrated. He does lots of side by side comparisons and really dives into the tools. Yes, it’s mostly first impression right out of the box stuff but it’s still really good. BZeug is another dude that follows that content form but I do believe he has affiliate links.

I miss German Tool Reviews. Awesome channel with some pretty detailed stuff.

Personally, I avoid Project Farm, TTC and others like them because those tests are completely above any kind of abuse I could inflict on a tool.

Last Best Tool seems to be a wealthy retiree that decided to focus on buying lots of tools. It’s was decent content some time ago, especially if you wanted to build an overlanding bag but now he seems to just jam to Snappy/HF comparisons and boutique brands.

I’ve noticed a ton of content creators have moved over to heavy, heavy HF videos. Not sure if HF just gets the clicks, if they realized professional brands are too expensive, or if they worked out some kind of deal with them. But it’s getting annoying seeing so many people put out similar content. Same thing with Knipex and Koken…there is only so much that can be said before it just gets repetitive. It even has had the opposite effect on my purchases to where I’m avoiding all three brands. 😂
 

YesIHaveAHammer

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2025
Messages
811
Lone Star Mopar is super underrated
The other thing he does is in the video descriptions, includes a full list of tools shown, together with timestamp, and link to the product page where he bought it. So you can always search and find older stuff or find things you watched before.

Probably the biggest spender I can think of. Regularly making consistently high value orders, duplicates, trying the same thing from different brands etc.

Last Best Tool seems to be a wealthy retiree that decided to focus on buying lots of tools. It’s was decent content some time ago, especially if you wanted to build an overlanding bag but now he seems to just jam to Snappy/HF comparisons and boutique brands.
From various small remarks and terminology heard in his videos, I believe "doc" is in fact a retired medical doctor. I did laugh when he once said he bought some tool for a project he'd been working on, only for the project to be the curation of tools to put together a kit.

I look at his page every month or two for anything new that catches my eye amongst the daily random things.
 

CoThG

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2022
Messages
638
Location
Ohio
Lone Star Mopar is super underrated. He does lots of side by side comparisons and really dives into the tools. Yes, it’s mostly first impression right out of the box stuff but it’s still really good. BZeug is another dude that follows that content form but I do believe he has affiliate links.

I miss German Tool Reviews. Awesome channel with some pretty detailed stuff.

Personally, I avoid Project Farm, TTC and others like them because those tests are completely above any kind of abuse I could inflict on a tool.

Last Best Tool seems to be a wealthy retiree that decided to focus on buying lots of tools. It’s was decent content some time ago, especially if you wanted to build an overlanding bag but now he seems to just jam to Snappy/HF comparisons and boutique brands.

I’ve noticed a ton of content creators have moved over to heavy, heavy HF videos. Not sure if HF just gets the clicks, if they realized professional brands are too expensive, or if they worked out some kind of deal with them. But it’s getting annoying seeing so many people put out similar content. Same thing with Knipex and Koken…there is only so much that can be said before it just gets repetitive. It even has had the opposite effect on my purchases to where I’m avoiding all three brands. 😂
Just those companies paying the shills with free tools. And then you have videos with guys proclaiming "breaking news" where they just discovered that certain Cat tools are re-branded Snap-on.
 

Hakeem

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 22, 2024
Messages
1,247
Location
Chicago
Best (re)view is your own. Buy tool, use it over a couple of projects and decide on it’s fate.

YT = entertainment.

Kind regards,
Olli

Pretty much. The people that actually put tools through their paces tend to be too busy to make video reviews. I really like Catus Maximus and Lone Star Mopar too, but their videos are essentially unboxing/first impressions.

The best reviews can be found asking members here, and to a lesser extent on Reddit.
 

Fedwrench

ALLIANCE MEMBER
Joined
Dec 9, 2007
Messages
14,952
Location
Valley of the sun
I think too many tool videos become infomercials.
I like watching Eric O at south main auto beat the snot out of tools fixing vehicles in the people's republic of New York. He doesn't do tool reviews per se but, he had a recent series "tool of the day" where he talked about a particular tool, he used to complete a job. He'll also praise a tool while using it too.
I also like watching the Tool Box tours guy. Some of the stuff doesn't apply to what I do but, there's usually a ooh, i want one of those moments in some of the videos.
 

Professor Gascan

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 26, 2024
Messages
178
Most if not all tool review channels are more or less unboxing videos. Very few do follow up vids after actually using the tool(s).

The majority of these glorified unboxing videos are also way longer than they need to be while leaving out useful information like measured dimensions. You've got tools of all kinds worth thousands of dollars... why not cough up a few bucks for a tape measure and a set of calipers.

A lot of these "reviewers" seem like guys that like to collect tools and hear themselves speak.

I will add the Tools Tested does useful reviews, especially if you're looking for torque wrench testing.
 

Steve_P

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 15, 2010
Messages
5,182
Lone Star Mopar is super underrated. He does lots of side by side comparisons and really dives into the tools. Yes, it’s mostly first impression right out of the box stuff but it’s still really good. BZeug is another dude that follows that content form but I do believe he has affiliate links.

I miss German Tool Reviews. Awesome channel with some pretty detailed stuff.

Personally, I avoid Project Farm, TTC and others like them because those tests are completely above any kind of abuse I could inflict on a tool.

I haven't heard of Lone Star, so I'll have to check it out.

PF and TTC have some good data on things like dimensions and backdrag, even if you aren't interested in "how much does it take to break this". PF's screwdriver tests do have value for the wear comparisons IMO. Even though I've only broken a few tools in many decades, I still find the ultimate strength tests interesting- sure, not a deciding factor in almost all cases. However, I also realize that statistically there's no difference between +/-10% variances in ultimate strength, which is usually most of the better names, unless you're going to do a statistical analysis over months and hundreds of items.
 

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,812
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
What are some reputable tool reviewers that aren't just shilling anything and everything?

Seems like more and more channels are slanging whatever they get paid for regardless if it's useful or decent quality.

Catus Maximus on YouTube is one that isn't obviously sponsored. On the other hand, guys like Mr. Subaru are just promoting anything they get sent. There are a few Japanese youtubers that are pretty unbiased as well.

I think that most Tool discussion on YouTube is more of a "show and tell" type of entertainment rather than real World reviews, ranging from genuine collectors and enthusiasts to out and out sales pitches. I suspect most of these channels start with fairly good intentions and then end up as something more sinister as the subscription numbers attract the "free stuff" to make more content and become monetized.

I personally prefer good quality repair videos, you can see what tools are being used and how they work!!!
 

Jbear

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 2, 2025
Messages
81
Reviews can really only do so much. I like having an idea of specs, weak mechanisms, pitfalls and things that might get in the way, but mostly when I buy a tool, I want it to feel good and balanced in my hands and nobody can really evaluate that but me. Even durability short of a known issue, is down to how I am going to use/treat it. Still...I find some of them amusing and even occasionally useful. I too prefer how-to vids.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Ohio Andy

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2024
Messages
2,267
Location
Columbus, Ohio
What about the Den of Tools guy? Is he legit?
I often like to hear what he has to say, then he'll often say things like this is okay if you're a home gamer.... But I am always a little skeptical. As an example, he recommended a set of EMS medical shears as a suitable replacement and every bit as good as the Leatherman EMS shears not a fraction of the cost. For the price I gave them a try, and they are not even remotely near the quality or usability as the Leatherman product.

On the other hand, he recommended a set of earbuds for people that have a specific issue wearing earbuds, and I have that issue, so I gave them a try and he was right on the money.

Sometimes it's just a question of personal preference. As an example, I like my Williams ratcheting screwdrivers, they're nice, but I'm really used to having the knurling on the snap-on. So for me I'll pay extra and buy a snap-on ratcheting screwdriver just for the knurling because I use it to Great advantage for a lot of what I do.
 

CoThG

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2022
Messages
638
Location
Ohio
I often like to hear what he has to say, then he'll often say things like this is okay if you're a home gamer.... But I am always a little skeptical. As an example, he recommended a set of EMS medical shears as a suitable replacement and every bit as good as the Leatherman EMS shears not a fraction of the cost. For the price I gave them a try, and they are not even remotely near the quality or usability as the Leatherman product.

On the other hand, he recommended a set of earbuds for people that have a specific issue wearing earbuds, and I have that issue, so I gave them a try and he was right on the money.

Sometimes it's just a question of personal preference. As an example, I like my Williams ratcheting screwdrivers, they're nice, but I'm really used to having the knurling on the snap-on. So for me I'll pay extra and buy a snap-on ratcheting screwdriver just for the knurling because I use it to Great advantage for a lot of what I do.
I have both and I do miss the knurling on the Williams. I took a strip of Emery cloth and glued it to the shaft. It now has more grip than the SO.
 

dscheidt

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2017
Messages
2,888
I think too many tool videos become infomercials.
I like watching Eric O at south main auto beat the snot out of tools fixing vehicles in the people's republic of New York. He doesn't do tool reviews per se but, he had a recent series "tool of the day" where he talked about a particular tool, he used to complete a job. He'll also praise a tool while using it too.
I also like watching the Tool Box tours guy. Some of the stuff doesn't apply to what I do but, there's usually a ooh, i want one of those moments in some of the videos.
the only youtube tool opinions I take at all seriously are ones from people who don't review tools, they just use them. The reviewers are all shills, they know who is buttering their bread, and it ain't the viewer.
 

zendriver

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2014
Messages
29,833
Location
Indiana
They cannot be biased if they purchase their own test products? :rolleyes2

Who decides what it "legit"?

A "review" shows a particular Harbor Freight product to perform as well, (maybe even a tad bit better, whatever the test) than the similar Snap On On product, or the reviewer states opinion to that effect.

The Snap On fanboy, will call the review bogus, while the Harbor Freight fanboy will feel like they just won the Powerball.
Consumer Reports could do the test and the feelings would be the same. "flip the script" - no different

Everyone likes being spoon fed.
 

logical

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 31, 2005
Messages
2,449
Location
Northern fringe of the Motor City Suburbs
You could ask a specific question here...but the answers would be almost as predictable.

What's the best floor jack?

-That's what your skid steer is for.

-I have a 60 year old one that is the best, no idea who made them and they are long discontinued. I rebuild it in my kitchen with my eyes closed. Everything else is China junk.

- Buy a lift, and don't bother if it isn't a 2 post and made in the USA.

- Three things...cribbing and the local HS football team and a large pizza.
 

dnschmidt

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 3, 2014
Messages
7,271
Location
Phoenix, AZ
I like TTC and Project Farm. Well, actually I like PF for his great catchphrase "VERY IMPRESSIVE." i think Todd does his best but at times I question his methodology. TTC is to me the gold standard as he is a professional tool designer. The testing apparatus he designs are VERY IMPRESSIVE and he seldom tests to failure but tests to the Eric O level of caveman usage which is real world.
 

woody 73

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 14, 2009
Messages
11,542
Location
The Great State Up North
The one I respect is the torque test channel, but again I am not using that much power and strength to break my tools...sigh ok I will admit,cough,cough,cough lately I have broken my share of taps and drill bits.:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes::eek:

The project farm guy is ok, but I wish he would cut to the chase a little faster for my pea size brain to take it all in.

Dang it another broken tap on the floor.
 

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,738
Location
SE PA
What are some reputable tool reviewers that aren't just shilling anything and everything?

Seems like more and more channels are slanging whatever they get paid for regardless if it's useful or decent quality

Agree. There are none I know of. I like greasy fingers and the humble mechanic, neither of whom do tool reviews.
.

Catus Maximus on YouTube is one that isn't obviously sponsored. On the other hand, guys like Mr. Subaru are just promoting anything they get sent. There are a few Japanese youtubers that are pretty unbiased as well.
I don’t think sponsorship alone is the problem. I think the root problem is, they want to create content to make money. They aren’t motivated to help someone else avoid a mistake they made etc. Its all just one big unboxing video. All of it.

Torque test channel is pretty good. Cant stand project farm.
 

American Locomotive

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2017
Messages
10,947
Location
Rhode Island
Most of my recent tool purchases have been from recommendations on GJ. Wright Wrenches, Vessel Screwdrivers, Koken Sockets, Astro Pneumatic lights, etc... I find these discussions to be better than most tool review videos.

Of the channels, I do find Torque Test Channel to be the most "factual", with the most solid methodology.
 

MichaelP

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
929
Location
IL/WI border
The thread is VERY IMPRESSIVE. And the post #X sounds better than the post #Y. And the post #Z is more truthful than the post #X.
 
Last edited:

Prospecter

Well-known member
Joined
May 16, 2015
Messages
2,401
Location
Maine
I often like to hear what he has to say, then he'll often say things like this is okay if you're a home gamer.... But I am always a little skeptical. As an example, he recommended a set of EMS medical shears as a suitable replacement and every bit as good as the Leatherman EMS shears not a fraction of the cost. For the price I gave them a try, and they are not even remotely near the quality or usability as the Leatherman product.

On the other hand, he recommended a set of earbuds for people that have a specific issue wearing earbuds, and I have that issue, so I gave them a try and he was right on the money.

Sometimes it's just a question of personal preference. As an example, I like my Williams ratcheting screwdrivers, they're nice, but I'm really used to having the knurling on the snap-on. So for me I'll pay extra and buy a snap-on ratcheting screwdriver just for the knurling because I use it to Great advantage for a lot of what I do.
I miss the cigar smoking bear.
 

zendriver

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2014
Messages
29,833
Location
Indiana
The thread is VERY IMPRESSIVE. And the post #X sounds better than the post #Y. And the post #Z is more truthful than the post #X.

Don’t know about anybody else, but back in the day when my dad needed tools he went to one of the auto parts stores and purchased some.

If by chance some of the chrome chipped off, he used them anyway, and as far as “broach depth” “tooth count”most people probably didn’t even know or care what that even meant. If something broke, he bought a replacement. That’s probably what most people did.

Nowadays, people (including me,)are probably paralyzed to make decisions like that
 

Aaron_W

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 6, 2018
Messages
2,898
Location
Northern California
I don't follow any tool review channels. I'll watch some when I'm searching for reviews of a tool but more often I find a channel with another focus that occasionally highlights a tool they like or one they expected to like and didn't.

There are tons of issues with channels that just review stuff. The paid reviews and assumed bias are frequently brought up, but even when they seem to be honest they rarely have much time with the tool and it may not even be a tool type they have much experience with.

I'm much more interested in tool review from a guy running a specialty channel (wood working, machining, 3D printing etc) channel who has been using the tool for 6 months and decides to do a review of it, rather than some random "tool guy" who just reviews a broad range of tools and who knows what tool experience most of those guys have.



Anyway the TLDR version, I google reviews of the tool in question, and I may watch several different videos to get an idea of the general opinion. If the same high / low points are common then I feel they are probably valid. If some hate the tool and others think it is better than sliced bread then further down the rabbit hole I go.


Sometimes it's just a question of personal preference.

I'd up the sometimes to often. So many variables, past experience, needs, use case etc.

Tool sites would lose a lot of traffic if there was truly one "best" whatever. ;)
 

MichaelP

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 27, 2009
Messages
929
Location
IL/WI border
Don’t know about anybody else, but back in the day when my dad needed tools he went to one of the auto parts stores and purchased some.

If by chance some of the chrome chipped off, he used them anyway, and as far as “broach depth” “tooth count”most people probably didn’t even know or care what that even meant. If something broke, he bought a replacement. That’s probably what most people did.

Nowadays, people (including me,)are probably paralyzed to make decisions like that
I cannot agree more. A variety of different choices, although a positive thing, can cause endless procrastination.
 

AEAdam

Well-known member
Joined
May 27, 2023
Messages
2,738
Location
SE PA
Don’t know about anybody else, but back in the day when my dad needed tools he went to one of the auto parts stores and purchased some.

If by chance some of the chrome chipped off, he used them anyway, and as far as “broach depth” “tooth count”most people probably didn’t even know or care what that even meant. If something broke, he bought a replacement. That’s probably what most people did.

Nowadays, people (including me,)are probably paralyzed to make decisions like that
Our Dads had no choice. The tools they bought and the cars they drove were largely ****. But it was all they had access to. Engines didn’t run for 100,000 miles. If you pulled on a ratchet too hard, you’d strip it. I remember when imported tools became available. They were as terrible as imported cars were. I had Taiwan tools (the worst) and a Japanese car (awful). Now those are both among the best!

People in the UK have an expression: ”spoiled for choice”, meaning they have many, possibly TOO MANY choices. They long for days when they could ask for a coffee and there would be no further discussion. Life was simpler without so many options.

Maybe related, UK has another common expression, “value for money”, that I think drives a lot of us to compare tools. I think everyone here knows who the best toolmakers are. But they seek the best “value for money”, which is fair. If not THE BEST, can they buy 90% as good for 50% of the cost?
 

zendriver

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 10, 2014
Messages
29,833
Location
Indiana
Our Dads had no choice. The tools they bought and the cars they drove were largely ****. But it was all they had access to. Engines didn’t run for 100,000 miles. If you pulled on a ratchet too hard, you’d strip it. I remember when imported tools became available. They were as terrible as imported cars were. I had Taiwan tools (the worst) and a Japanese car (awful). Now those are both among the best!

People in the UK have an expression: ”spoiled for choice”, meaning they have many, possibly TOO MANY choices. They long for days when they could ask for a coffee and there would be no further discussion. Life was simpler without so many options.

Maybe related, UK has another common expression, “value for money”, that I think drives a lot of us to compare tools. I think everyone here knows who the best toolmakers are. But they seek the best “value for money”, which is fair. If not THE BEST, can they buy 90% as good for 50% of the cost?

Those poor, unfortunate souls, literally “built America” (and the rest of the world with those **** tools.

They somehow found the time to do something different other than obsess about and arguing endlessly over what is the best” high tooth count” ratchet

Somehow, they were worse off. :headscrat:
 

neophyte

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 23, 2012
Messages
9,590
Location
Pennsylvannia
Those poor, unfortunate souls, literally “built America” (and the rest of the world with those **** tools.

They somehow found the time to do something different other than obsess about and arguing endlessly over what is the best” high tooth count” ratchet

Somehow, they were worse off. :headscrat:
Arguing about what “tools were best” likely goes back at least 200 years or more in the USA, and way further back in Europe.
There was a sword maker in viking age Scandinavia that marked his swords “+VLFBERH+T “, and the swords were notable for bring made from crucible steel, or at least most were, but there are examples not made from the same steel, so either the same maker could not get the right steel, or other blacksmiths were “forging/counterfeiting” the makers work.
Skokloster Castle in Sweden is notable for an unfinished wing of the castle, since the owner commissioning the castle died, and the work was apparently immediately stopped, and then never resumed on the wing, and all the tools, (or maybe most of the tools), were simply laid down and left, with the scaffolding left in place etc.
the planes were imported from the Netherlands and made by an Amsterdam toolmaker in a number of cases.
During the US colonial period, the Eastern states routinely imported tools from England, and later on, there was standardized shipping from some British cities to some US cities, with ships regularly leaving each week to transport goods and mail, etc., and there were “standardized” catalogs of goods that could be purchased and shipped over from England, including from Sheffield.
I would presume the German immigrants in Pennsylvania arranged to buy German tools somehow by preference.
Once toolmaking started on a large industrial scale in the USA, there were lots of competing toolmakers trying to make “the best” tool, or at least advertising such, with a ridiculous number of tool patents issued, and advances in metallurgy for steel and iron advertised.
Yes, the average person just needing a certain type of tool, probably just went in to the local hardware store, and then looked over what was in stock, or asked the clerk, and then bought what was available, but plenty of people probably went to multiple retailers to check competing stock and quality levels.

Most people don’t want to waste their money on ****, especially if they’ll be using that “**** tool” for decades, getting annoyed every time they use the tool.
With some tools, differences can be mild, and might have to do with subtle differences like ergonomics, which varies by person.
With other aspects, like tool design, the variations likely have to do with usage.
With other aspects, the variations are the result of quality of materials or design.
There are plenty of tool brands that are close enough in quality and design that it doesn’t matter much which one you use, but sometimes there are subtly differences that come into play for individual users.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom