#Grip-on 111 10” curved jaw vise grips & Elora 502-180 8” combination jaw vise grips
Please consider this more of an ”unboxing” than a use based review, I will get to that at some point but not right now.
Now as I wrote before (Please check posts
#288,
#295 &
#296 for the full picture.) when I got the Elora 502-180 I wasn’t exactly pleased with them - besides the whole incompatibility saga - in essence my “grievance” with them was, and kind of still is, I don’t think they are worthy of the “Made in Germany” stamp.
Now don’t get me wrong, I’m NOT implying that those weren’t made in Germany, I’m sure they were and they therefore technically/formally are absolutely allowed to be stamped “Made in Germany” there is no questioning about that.
I was ready & willing to return them but got told I could keep them. Because of the incompatibility issue, the only way to use the table holder would have been with much larger vise grips which is not what I wanted.
Somewhere along the way I found out that Grip-on actually makes another table holder, able to accommodate multiple sizes of vise grips in one holder:
https://shop.grip-on.com/collections/productos-ordenados/products/soporte-mordaza-grip-1075 but the overall situation hasn’t changed, they do not communicate with me/ never replied to my initial inquiry.
But I was actually able to purchase Grip-on 111 10” curved jaw vise grips locally. And I am somewhat impressed. They are made in Spain.
So just we are on the same picture:
Price for the Elora 502-180 (8”) was (would have been) 20.03 Euro/ 23.09 USD. (The 10” model would have been 21.45 Euro/ 24.73 USD)
Price for the Grip-on 111 (10”) was 14.70 Euro/ 16.95 USD.
Those prices are “Joe Average”/anybody prices before taxes/VAT and without shipping. No discount, no dynamic pricing, no account.
Here’s what I received:
Compared to the Elora 502-180
- Both vise grips came locked. The jaws would not open with the lever/handle released, the handle would only drop down, and the sliding part to adjust jaw width would actually drop out the upper handle. Had to put it back on both vise grips and then use two hands to force the jaws open. After a few turns of exercising them with a fresh drop of oil it became a non-issue. (None of my Irwin or Milwaukee vise grips would ever do/ or require that “out of the box”.)
- Both vise grips adjusting bolts threads needed cleaning as well as the threads inside the handle. They run incredibly rough and it was worse when you tried to just lightly snug up the closed/locked vise grips jaws to something. With all threads cleaned and a minimal amount of oil that got significantly better, but is still rather rough/coarse. (None of my Irwin or Milwaukee vise grips required these additional steps “out of the box”.)
- The Elora 502-180 vise grips came with quite a few marks/ scars. The worst right above the pivot/axle and is probably from tooling used in production. (Last picture above.) I hadn’t even seen that when I unpacked them at first, but after they didn’t feel right, I started to look closer. …The issue with the threading and this basically sums up my feeling that there was no care involved when this particular pair of Elora vise grips was made.
- The Grip-on vise grips have a much higher quality fit, finish & feel to them. To a large extent that obviously might be because of the epoxy coated handles which are extremely smooth - and that coating was already scarred by me by just inserting the vise grips into the table holder.
- From all vise grips I own, the Elora 502-180 have the worst alignment, when closing/locking the lower handle wants to move out to one side and when unlocked there is a significant ”wobble” in that lower handle. Milwaukee is the second worst, the Grip-On is what I would consider acceptable/ not noteworthy and the best are my Irwin vise grips. (And because that question will come up, all my Irwins have been purchased from I think starting 2016 and onward, so (highly likely) all imports.)
Within the realm of all things considering vise grips, these are beater tools - they get exposed to heat, welding spatter, and will all sooner or later touch a grinding or cut-off disc - so none of this actually matters beyond the simple fact that some manufacturers take more care of the products they make than others.
And I put this here, because I actually only looked deeper into all of this because the Elora 502-180 vise grips just felt off in some way to me.
Along my way, I also found out that Knipex seems to offer vise grips identical to the Elora 502-250 (10”) with their 41 14 250 model. I didn’t feel playful enough - and overall it also isn’t important enough to me - to try and find out if they would actually deliver the universal/combined jaw profile as pictured.
https://www.knipex-tools.com/products/grip-pliers/grip-pliers/grip-pliers-round-jaws/4114250
Also, I found them for 14.24 Euro/ 16.41 USD before tax/VAT, no shipping. Same rules as set out above. So that had me expecting to receive the same overall quality I had gotten from Elora. Wether Elora makes them, or if there is still another 3rd party involved. On the other hand, it could as well be the case that the Knipex are going through additional production/ quality procedures and checks. I actually don’t know, and I won’t be wasting more time on this as I have already.
Last but not least, probably what everyone has been waiting for who is still “with me” on this at this stage, picture of the Grip-On 10” in the table holder.
Personally I will say this, the 111 models are Grip-on’s lowest-tier vise grips as far as my understanding goes - and they are cheap. Still, they are made in Spain which is good and they really do have a quality fit, finish & feel out of box.
I will now place them and the holder into my personal toolbox to further evaluate and test them.
Kind regards,
Olli