To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Rust Electrolysis Tank Setup, Ver. 2.0

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Not trying to re-invent the wheel, but a better mouse trap here. In my case, an electrolysis tank that suites my needs, knock downs easily, quick cleanup and either upgradable or down gradable.

DSC_6923.jpg



I won't get into what is an electrolysis tank and how it works. Many of you know what it does and some of the science behind it. However, for those that want additional reading as to what and how, here are two sites I found interesting:

This site gives you what is an electrolysis tank and basic how it works. The author basically uses a five gallon bucket with some metal as anodes. Nothing fancy, like many here who use what ever is around.
http://www.djkwoodcrafts.com/2009/07/15/rust-electrolysis/

The second link is a bit more detailed and technical, but interesting. The author gives you step by step on how to construct one and the supplies needed for cleaning the parts afterwards.
http://www.rickswoodshopcreations.com/Miscellaneous/Rust_Removal.htm

My method is just anodes that hooks/hangs onto the side of the container. Easily pulls out for maintenance, cleaning and storage.

1- THE CONTAINER:
You will see a 5 gallon bucket on the center with markings for each gallon of water. This was my first electrolysis tank using some old 3/4" diameter steel stakes I had laying around. The stakes were twice as tall as the bucket and no means of keeping them from moving around. Well, you could use spring clamps, but I didn't. I now use this smaller bucket to measure the water going into the larger one and that way I know how much baking soda to add per gallon.

DSC_6911.jpg



The current setup uses a 20 gallon commercial grade trash container. The one to the left is a similar larger 32 gallon one. These can be purchased at any home improvement big box store. Depending what your needs are and what size parts you are putting in, you can use what ever size container you want. The rebar anodes will be cut to match the height of the container being used. More on that later. Try not to use regular storage containers or household plastic trash cans. These have thin plastic walls and can blow out on you if you fill it to capacity. The above gray containers are heavy duty with thicker walls. Plastic 55 gallon drums work perfectly and easily available used. I have one of these and will make another setup for much larger parts, like with my 1942 Delta Unisaw cabinet saw.

2- ANODES:
I my case I purchased a 10' piece of 5/8" diameter(#5) rebar. The 20 gallon container is roughly 24" tall so I cut the rebar into five equal parts, 24" each. I had a 2' length of 3/4" steel stake around that was used as the cross piece to hang the parts from in the water. If you don't have something thick and strong for this cross piece you can purchase more rebar.

If using a large container like here, cut five rebar's. This will give more surface area for the electrolysis to work and more "line of sight" coverage for the rust to travel to. This way you won't have to rotate the part that is being clean.

DSC_6914.jpg



The Hook was made from some 1/4 steel stock also laying around. You want the anodes to stay at least a 1/2" above the bottom of the container, this way they're hanging freely on the edge of the container. Mark the point on the rebar where it meets the top edge of the container. This is were you will weld the L shaped hook.

Weld one L shape hook on each of the anodes. Then weld a 1-1/2" long bolt to the vertical part of the L shape hook. This bolt is where the positive lead wire and positive clamp from the battery charger will go.

DSC_6913.jpg


DSC_6912.jpg



Next, install a nut tight up against the head of the bolt, followed by two washers, and another nut. In between the washers is were the positive lead wire will be tighten to.


3-POSITIVE LEAD WIRE:
At first, the 5 gallon and 20 gallon setup both used a 14ga copper wire. When I decided to post this build and rebuild it for the photos I decided to switch to 10ga copper wire for two reasons. First, thicker wire for more conductivity and second, it's stiffer and more manageable than the thinner 14ga. Because of this it will hold it shape around the container and keep the anodes from moving.

For this setup, I cut an 80" piece of 10ga wire. Measure the circumference/perimeter of the container and add about 20-24" to that measurement for the wire. This will give you more room for the loop bends around each anode. My suggestions is to use insulated wire, not bare. If bare, you may accidentally come in contact with it while positioning the Negative battery charger clamp.

What ever measurement you come up with divide it by the number of anodes made. In my case 5 anodes divided by 80" = 16" spacing along the wire. At each mark, remove a 2" section of insulation and also at each end. Bend the wire into a circle.

DSC_6916.jpg



Next is making the u-shape loop at each stripped point on the wire. You can either use the bolt on the anode as a guide or a pair of needle-nose pliers. Don't crimp the wire together. You want to able, with 1-2 turns of the outside nut, just lift the wire for any maintenance, cleanup or storage.

DSC_6917.jpg


DSC_6918.jpg



Make sure the loops are all facing up. It should look like this when done.

DSC_6919.jpg




4-ASSEMBLY:
Install the anodes spaced evenly around the inside of the container. Then carefully drop the positive lead wire onto the anode hooks. Then one by one install the stripped copper loop in between the washers and tighten the outside nut. The good thing about the heavier gauge wire is that it will evenly space the anodes. No need for clamps, since the hooks and wire will hold it in its place.

DSC_6920.jpg


DSC_6922.jpg



Finally, another rebar going across the top to hang your parts from and to clamp the Negative from the battery charger at either end. Since I used up the 10' length of rebar to make the anodes, I did have a 2' by 3/4" diameter stake at hand for this purpose.

UPDATE: Per suggestions of others with the cross member possibly coming in contact with the anodes, I installed heat shrink tube at each end. Roughly 6" of heat shrink tube and left a 1" area uninsulated on one end to attach the Negative feed clamp. I also wire wheeled the piece on the bench grinder and applied PB Blaster Penetrating Oil to keep it free from corrosion. This should help with the electrical conductivity.

DSC_6982.jpg



Remember the Positive(red) clamp goes to the anodes and the Negative(black) goes to the parts being cleaned.

Now just fill up the container with clean water to what ever level you need depending on the length of part(s) being cleaned. I use the bucket with the gallons marked out so I know how much water I'm putting in. As far as Baking Soda, I followed the rule in the above links, one tablespoon Baking Soda per one gallon of water. This formula has worked fine for me so far. Some guys just pour the baking soda in with no set measurements.

You can use old copper bare wire or steel wire to hang the parts from the center support (Negative lead). I use copper since I have plenty of scraps around and just double or triple the wire for heavier parts.

As stated earlier, my method here is more for convenience than anything else. By hanging the anodes, instead of clamping or bolting, it makes it easier to remove the anodes for cleanup or storage. This setup took me about 2-3 hours to fabricate.

DSC_6910.jpg



Read the two links mentioned at the beginning. They will give you more details as to what and how for an electrolysis tank. It will give you a better understanding as you build yours. By no means am I an expert on this subject. Within the last month I found out what an electrolysis set up is and how it works. I just devised a way to better suite my needs as far as the construction and use of the tank itself.

Hope this helps any one who is new to this, referencing or just wants to change or improve their setup. Any suggestions, ideas or comments, please post.

By all means, please post your own electrolysis setup.

Thanks-David
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

luvit

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 11, 2011
Messages
1,580
pupuhd, you just saved me a load of planning. -- thanks for this information.
i have that same battery charger.. what settings do you choose to operate this?
 

MBfreak

MEMBER EMERITUS
Joined
Dec 10, 2010
Messages
2,301
Location
Linkoping , Sweden
Great thread, will start overhauling my 1945 bench grinder, and rust removal is prio 1!
I guess I am missing something obvious, but why not use a iron bucket for the anode and :bowdown:electrolytic container, and thus get a really large anode area and no rebar mfr needed?

Please tell me what I am missing.

Ola
 

north

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 16, 2009
Messages
1,502
Location
Norway
Thanks for sharing. Your build should provide useful for those wanting to build a permanent setup. I just delved into electrolysis myself, using a small bucket and a piece of exhaust pipe for an anode. So far I've saved an old small adjustable wrench that was rusted stuck.
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Very nice setup, any video of it in action?:)

Thanks, next time I put something in there to clean up, I'll try a remember a before and after video of the part(s). With the half dozen restoration I have on my list I'm pretty sure it'll be soon-David
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
pupuhd, you just saved me a load of planning. -- thanks for this information.
i have that same battery charger.. what settings do you choose to operate this?

Thanks, I forgot to mention that point in the build. At first with the 5 gallon setup I had it at 12 amps, Regular Battery. For the last cleanup I did in the newer setup it was setup at 12 amps, Deep Cycle Battery. I didn't purposely put it in the Deep Battery mode, I just found it that way now when I went to check it now. I'll have to do some research as far if this matters with the current going through the vat mixture. The charger also has a 75 amp setting, don't know as of yet if this will improve the process or not. -David
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Great thread, will start overhauling my 1945 bench grinder, and rust removal is prio 1!
I guess I am missing something obvious, but why not use a iron bucket for the anode and :bowdown:electrolytic container, and thus get a really large anode area and no rebar mfr needed?

Please tell me what I am missing.

Ola

Yes in therory I guess that would work. However if you use a cross rebar to hold/hang your parts, the rebar will come in contact with the iron bucket and I guess thus short it out or something to that effect.

Also rebar is cheap and easy to work with. Plus you'll have to scrub the hell out of the iron bucket to remove the sludge and rust build for the next cleaning.

The anode or rebar in this case is sacrifitial. It will over a long period of use corrode to nothing. I guess you don't want your iron bucket getting rust through holes and spilling out your vat in time.

The iron bucket would also have to be insulated on the floor you put in on. If not it might get grounded to earth. Kind've standing in a puddle of water and touching the hot side of a 110v circuit. Only this will only be 12v.

So far the five rebars I've used have worked fine as more anode surface exposure. Go over to the current restoration I am doing on a Prentiss Vise CO. 6" Monarch vise: http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=118774

There you will see before and after photos of the dynamic and static jaws and lead screw using the above setup. No problems with just 5 anodes.

Thanks-David
 

BuddyC01

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 28, 2011
Messages
331
Location
N.W. Arkansas
Good info. Just learning about it myself. I waffled on a battery charger at an estate sale this morning and passed it up. See them all the time so my time is coming.

Thanks
Buddy
 

Stuart in MN

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 8, 2005
Messages
22,983
Location
Minneapolis
Nice setup. One thing I'd recommend is slipping a couple sections of garden hose or something similar over the ends of the rebar you lay across the top of the container, so it won't accidentally short against the anodes.
 

SweetD

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2010
Messages
3,262
Location
Rhode Island
Great setup and nice job posting. I've been using electrolysis on a few vise projects for a couple months now with great results.

One thing I would ad (and I'm sure others have seen posted before) is that if you can use washing soda rather than baking soda, it works better due to its detergent properties. I found Arm & Hammer washing soda in the laundry aisle at WalMart, and it's cheap.

My battery charger has 2amp and 10amp setting. I've had good luck with both. The 10amp seems to get the process going faster, which may not be better necessarily.

I've found that starting at 10amp and then switching to 2amp works pretty well - kind of like a crock pot starting on high and switching to low. I'm sure others can chime in on the science behind it all.

Just thought of one more thing - on your cross-piece stake, you may still want to take some preventative measure to stop if from rolling on you when under load. Either clamp it, or maybe a couple of notches in the top of your barrel to keep it in place...

Thanks for those links too - good info all around.

Dave
 
Last edited:

Outlawmws

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
39,089
Location
The Badlands
I'll 3rd or 4th the do something to keep the cathode hanging bar from contacting the anodes. I know you are aware of the shorting issue, but all it takes is a dog or kid to knock it into short condition.

I'd also like to suggest you get a another short piece of rebar (Lowes sells short sections), and tie tow of the anodes together so you have one piece across the bottom. Electrolysis is at least partly a line of sight process, so getting one across the bottom can help.

Assuming you take the ground loop off got anode "maintenance, some wing nuts would speed the process.

Very clean setup and description!
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
I'll 3rd or 4th the do something to keep the cathode hanging bar from contacting the anodes. I know you are aware of the shorting issue, but all it takes is a dog or kid to knock it into short condition.

I'd also like to suggest you get a another short piece of rebar (Lowes sells short sections), and tie tow of the anodes together so you have one piece across the bottom. Electrolysis is at least partly a line of sight process, so getting one across the bottom can help.

Assuming you take the ground loop off got anode "maintenance, some wing nuts would speed the process.

Very clean setup and description!

Great idea from all about insulating the cross member, the only thing at hand for me is black electrical tape. I'll remember that for the next cleaning, will post photo and edit original post. Thank you

An anode across the bottom would improve the 'line of sight' issue, but for me complicates cleaning the vertical anodes. So far I've had good luck with the way this setup works and has cleaned it well. Only issues have been some century old paint stuck on certain spots, but the rust no issues.

I thought of the wing nuts, would make is easier. But all I had were the nylon-lock nuts you see. When I get to the surplus-steel house I will purchase wing nuts, they sell fastners at $1.69 per lb.
 

Outlawmws

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
39,089
Location
The Badlands
An anode across the bottom would improve the 'line of sight' issue, but for me complicates cleaning the vertical anodes. So far I've had good luck with the way this setup works and has cleaned it well. Only issues have been some century old paint stuck on certain spots, but the rust no issues.
.

Tape works for the insulation simple and effective! :thumbup:

For the cross anode, you can weld a large washer on the bottom of two of the bars, and simply have the rebar go through them. All straight pieces. You may need to hit the cross piece ends and washers with a wire wheel when cleaning, but it should work.
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
OK, the clear concise writing and pics are confusing me !!


Nice write up !

Brian L.

Is this less confusing?

Here's my Electrolysis setup.....good luck figuring it out. Thanks-David:lol_hitti

DSC_6923.jpg


To be honest I've come across threads this simple and I'm like "Huh!, What?!"
 

jtbinvalrico

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 2, 2010
Messages
1,375
Location
Tampa FL
This electrolysis process has me pondering another project I'm working on. I've got a 6' x 4' piece of 1/2 steel plate that's destined to become a welding table top. Its got a good bit of rust on it. I used a 2' x 4' section of it to make a work bench top, and it was a royal PIA to clean up....grinding, chemicals...it was horrible, but it finally came out nice. I'd like to skip some of that grief and try this process on that large piece.

Of course, I don't have the means to grab 600lbs of steel and dip it into a giant vat.....Tell me what you think about this idea, and if it could work at all. I'm thinking of laying the piece of steel on the floor, then building a small wall around it, maybe four inches high. I could use wood, brace it out, and use some kind of caulk or sealer to stop water from leaking out. This would be on my garage floor near the door, so some leakage wouldn't be a big deal.

I could then fill this "tub" with the water/baking soda solution, then suspend the electrodes in it, causing the rust to magically disappear!

Questions: I'm sure I can keep the water in.......but as far as the process of electrolysis, is this feasible? Would there be an issue with the size or mass of the steel plate? And how would that relate to the size and placement of electrodes, and the amount of electricity or amps required? :beer:
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Outlawmws

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
39,089
Location
The Badlands
SNIP

Of course, I don't have the means to grab 600lbs of steel and dip it into a giant vat.....Tell me what you think about this idea, and if it could work at all. I'm thinking of laying the piece of steel on the floor, then building a small wall around it, maybe four inches high. I could use wood, brace it out, and use some kind of caulk or sealer to stop water from leaking out. This would be on my garage floor near the door, so some leakage wouldn't be a big deal.

I could then fill this "tub" with the water/baking soda solution, then suspend the electrodes in it, causing the rust to magically disappear!

Questions: I'm sure I can keep the water in.......but as far as the process of electrolysis, is this feasible? Would there be an issue with the size or mass of the steel plate? And how would that relate to the size and placement of electrodes, and the amount of electricity or amps required? :beer:

It's not quite as simple as that, and electrolysis is not a magic wand.

To do this you would need a grid above and below the plate. So a rebar grid below, some bricks to support the plate, another grid on top, both grids connected above water in steel/iron, not copper (in the soup)...

Power is a factor of area, and with a plate that size you are going to need either more time, or a larger power supply. I know a guy on line showed where he built a wood frame, lined it with plastic, and did an entire truck frame. His power supply was an AC/DC arc welder...

He set it up like I mentioned above. of course you have to make sure you don't puncture the plastic...

Do you have an over head crane to lift the plate out? Then there is the after de-rusting cleanup. That is messy too. If you don't have a lot of rust it might be less hassle to just wire wheel it or sand blast in your case.
 
Last edited:
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Well then.....that's the insight I was lookin' for. Guess I'll be breaking out the belt sander again. :beer:

I have to agree with Outlaw, I was going along the same idea he was. That's a monster of a plate to me messing with water and elcetricity. My first option, if it's available, media blast it. You'll get a more even finish with media blasting.

I have a 30"x60" metal mechanics metal table, it was a lot easier to sandbalst the whole thing in the yard. Painted the legs and shelf. Left the steel top unfinished and applied Bostik Top Coat to it, use it as my welding and parts table now. Good luck- David
 

MBfreak

MEMBER EMERITUS
Joined
Dec 10, 2010
Messages
2,301
Location
Linkoping , Sweden
Sorry for no pictures. :lol_hitti

I today took a 2 liter icecream tub, cylindrical, and bent a piece of sheet steel to fit as a cylinder inside . Filled up with 1,5 liter water and 1 tbsp of drain cleaner.

Took the 75 cm long rotor shaft for my disassembled bench grinder. The threaded parts are rusty, the rest is perfect. Fixed the shaft so 10 cm were sticking down in the liquid. 12 V 15 A battery charger, positive to the sheet steel and negative to the shaft.
Bubbling , drawing about 10 A. After 15 minutes I took the shaft up and wirebrushed off a lot of residue. Another 30 minutes and the thread was spotlessly clean. There was no surface change on the noncorroded machined shaft parts and tolerances were unchanged .

GREAT thread, I have never tried any better way to derust machine parts!

Will try to reverse the process with a copper anoded to copper plate steel parts.

Best regards

Ola
 

Simple Sam

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
122
Very nice write up; I wish I had seen it before my first attempt at electrolysis. The only thing I can add is I found it difficult to find washing soda. I checked Walmart, Target, and my local grocery store and never found it. I ended up using pool chemicals; PH up which is sodium carbonate just like washing soda. It was about $4-5 for about a quart at our high priced grocery store. I'm sure you could get a much larger container at Walmart for less.
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Will try to reverse the process with a copper anoded to copper plate steel parts.

Best regards

Ola

Great job. Ever since I discovered this process, I kept thinking of all the parts I either threw away or didn't bother with because of the rust. This sytem works so great, I'm thinking of making a 55 gallon version and putting myself into it :D, to remove some of the rusty years off me.

I would be interested if you got back with the reverse process to copper plate steel parts. Thanks-David
 

ert01

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 26, 2011
Messages
151
What are you guys using to protect the steel after it comes out?

I ask because I have my 120lb anvil in the tank right now and I want to prevent future rust once it comes out.
 

Outlawmws

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2011
Messages
39,089
Location
The Badlands
It depends on what you plan to do to finish it. bare steel? paint the non hammering surfaces?

I like to dry the part as best I can with rag/paper towel, then hit it with a little heat to completely dry the water out of the pores in the steel. (Its there almost always...)

Then you can paste wax the hammering surfaces, and paint the rest, or oil it, or any other rust protectant method that floats your boat.

But do get it dry first with some heat. (a Bernz-O-Matic with a spreader tip works great)
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
Very nice write up; I wish I had seen it before my first attempt at electrolysis. The only thing I can add is I found it difficult to find washing soda. I checked Walmart, Target, and my local grocery store and never found it. I ended up using pool chemicals; PH up which is sodium carbonate just like washing soda. It was about $4-5 for about a quart at our high priced grocery store. I'm sure you could get a much larger container at Walmart for less.

As far as the Washing Soda, many here have said that's the way to go. However, I read Baking Soda can be used as an alternative if the first is not available. I have only used Baking Soda because it's cheap and available. So far it's worked perfect for me, removes the rust and paint just fine.
 
OP
P

Pupuhd

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2011
Messages
346
Location
New Jersey
....what I'm really hearing here is that I have an excuse to buy some media blasting gear......? :bounce: Groovy!

I prefer to media blast when possible. It just happens to be that I haven't yet begun building the media blast cabinet, even though the media blast pressure pot is 99% done. Looking for a suitable gun for it.

I decided to do my vise with the electrolysis tank since it was only a few parts and not complicated. However I will soon be blasting it any way because of some 100 year old oil residue in the inside channels that didn't come out in the tank.

I heard some one say once, "I bought a $200 table saw to make a $10 spice rack"...............go for it!!! you'll love it.

David
 

phy6

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2007
Messages
275
Location
Maryland, It's a Wet Heat.
This is a much appreciated write up. So far I've read a few other things that seem really important, mostly from here:
http://bbs.homeshopmachinist.net/showthread.php?t=54891

Tips and Warnings:
  • Don't use any chrome or stainless pieces in your vat, the poisonous chromium may be relased.
  • Your sludge may contain lead paint, so don't just dump it out on the grass unless you're sure.
  • Using a lead anode can be very bad if your PH is too high
  • Better to do this in a well ventilated place/outside because of explosive gasses that can develop
  • Turn off the power before touching or adjusting anything!!
  • Wear a full face shield
  • clean off the electrodes when they get dirty, to speed up the process (otherwise amperage can drop)

Other ingredients that can be used besides Washing Soda (aka Soda Ash):
  • Anything that will raise PH, make the water alkaline (some pool supplies)
  • DrainO cleaner with Lye
  • Lye at 1 teaspoon per gallon (but too dangerous given the cheaper alternatives)
  • Baking Soda (Sodium Bicarbonate)
  • Trisodium Phosphate (TSP) --supposedly anodizes as it removes rust?
  • 'Washing Soda' may now be labeled as 'Activated Baking Soda' -- it's been reformulated and may foam due to detergents. Contents:
    • Alcohol Ethoxysulfate Salt 3-10% 68585-34-2 Not Established
    • Ethoxylated Alcohol 1-5% 68131-39-5 Not Established
    • Sodium Carbonate 70-85% 497-19-8 10 mg/m3 inh. (ACGIH-PNOC) 3 mg/m3 resp.
    • Sodium Tripolyphosphate <2% 7758-29-4 Not Established
    • Enzyme Preparation < 1% 9014-01-1 0.00395 mg/m3 (calculated) (as 100% pure protease) 0.00006 mg/m3 (ACGIH)
    • Bentonite Clay 2-6% Mixture 10 mg/m3 inh. (ACGIH-PNOC) (fabric softener formula only) 3 mg/m3 resp. [Bentonite clay may contain up to 7% naturally occurring crystalline silica]
  • 1 part feed grade molasses (farm supply, sulphated, not the kitchen kind)($8/gal) to 9 parts water. May take weeks, and will smell like sewage if kept covered--let it air out. See http://www.hotrodders.com/forum/rust-removal-miracle-molasses-204391.html

Other:
  • Washing soda or lye will need less voltage than baking soda
  • Convert Baking Soda to Washing Soda: Sodium bicarbonate is CHNaO3 while sodium carbonate is Na2CO3. Simply heat baking soda or sodium bicarbonate in a 200°F oven for about an hour. Carbon dioxide and water will be given off. Dry sodium carbonate will remain.
  • Graphite electrodes won't turn the bath red like steel electrodes
  • Carbon steel electrodes also work better than regular steel

Alternative power supplies:
  • Old PC power supply (2-3A at 12v or 5v), see
    http://lumberjocks.com/ajosephg/blog/24290
  • Old wall wart power supply from your old broken printer/electronic device
  • Old laptop power supply
  • A welder, if you pay close attention to the duty cycle.

Alternative techniques for rust or paint:
  • Wire wheel (may really damage the look of lettering on vises, etc)
  • media blasting (walnut shells, plastic beads, glass beads, aluminum oxide (black diamond from farm supply)
  • Chelation, see http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?t=69793
  • For small areas of rust, dribble coke on it and rub with aluminum foil
 
Last edited:

tim1957d

Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Messages
7
I built A five Gallon Electrolysis tank last year, scrounged an old upright Battery Charger from A bone yard and it worked great for almost A year (almost 24/7) and the 70 Amp charger just got old.

So, I went back to my favorite Bone yard and found another olde one, and she was only putting out 28 Amps. I could barely get the water molecules to move, and very little spark at either the anode or Cathode.

So, tonight I borrowed Another tall upright (on wheels and A handle) that is A 6, 12 or 24 volt! Mike tells me that they were sending gout 200 Amps at 24 Volts on Semis! So, I rush home (have some 1920 Snap On's to do) and all I have is about 12 volts and NO amperes at all. Minimal spark.

My good tools are not touching the positive lines, I am still using the same bucket, I have changed the water several times (and added baking soda). I used up all my small sheets of Stainless, so I have ground out the Zinc off of some 16 gauge, and have them anchored on 1 side of bucket and my good parts on the other side, held in place by A welding clamp, which holds my negative line. What am I doing wrong? It is winter up here in Iowa and I though that big Beast of A charger would get the water almost to A boil!

I am confused.


body guy Tim
 

phy6

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2007
Messages
275
Location
Maryland, It's a Wet Heat.
I built A five Gallon Electrolysis tank last year, scrounged an old upright Battery Charger from A bone yard and it worked great for almost A year (almost 24/7) and the 70 Amp charger just got old.

So, I went back to my favorite Bone yard and found another olde one, and she was only putting out 28 Amps. I could barely get the water molecules to move, and very little spark at either the anode or Cathode.

So, tonight I borrowed Another tall upright (on wheels and A handle) that is A 6, 12 or 24 volt! Mike tells me that they were sending gout 200 Amps at 24 Volts on Semis! So, I rush home (have some 1920 Snap On's to do) and all I have is about 12 volts and NO amperes at all. Minimal spark.

My good tools are not touching the positive lines, I am still using the same bucket, I have changed the water several times (and added baking soda). I used up all my small sheets of Stainless, so I have ground out the Zinc off of some 16 gauge, and have them anchored on 1 side of bucket and my good parts on the other side, held in place by A welding clamp, which holds my negative line. What am I doing wrong? It is winter up here in Iowa and I though that big Beast of A charger would get the water almost to A boil!

I am confused.


body guy Tim

First, you don't need so many amps, just a few will do at 12v. Otherwise your just being wasteful. I used a cheap Harbor Freight 6/12V battery charger. A power adaptor from an old piece of electronic junk (think thrift shop printer/laptop/music keyboard) would work too.

Also you should NOT use stainless as electrodes or your parts, since the chrome in stainless steel leaches out to create Chromium Hexavalent, which is very toxic depending on how it gets in you (stomach tumors, skin rashes, asthma, lung cancer, nasal cancer, liver and kidney failure, birth defects)

http://www.arb.ca.gov/coatings/thermal/factsheets/factsheethexchrome.pdf


You could poison your lawn and drinking water supply if you dump that on the ground.

As far as no amperage in your current set up, have you used a voltmeter to determine if there is a short somewhere?
 

tim1957d

Member
Joined
Aug 9, 2012
Messages
7
Hi, thank you for your comments;

In my five gallon bucket, I have the good tools immersed in A 1 gallon Steel Lacquer thinner can (Rectangle), with holes in it. This works best for my sockets and small tools. It is mounted to the bucket wall via a vise grip welding clamp and sitting on A brick to keep it out of the muck at the bottom of the bucket.

On the opposite side are my tall, narrow sheets of Sheet metal (thanks for the info on the stainless), with the bottom edge touching the bucket bottom. the brick is between the two...Is this maybe A problem?

I position my sheets so as to not "roll" into the thinner can. Just like it's been for almost A year! And, hook up the Positive cable to this, and the negative to my good stuff. I can usually tell how active the transfer will be by the color and intensity of the spark (in A well Ventilated olde shop)...

And all I have now is just some sparkles?

In regards to the Amps, would I be correct to understand that my tools will transfer more of the rust back into Iron faster with 100 amps as opposed to 20 or 30? Obviously, there is going to be some friction loss, and water media to factor in, buy this is only a bucket.

Please let me know your thoughts. I am puzzled by this, as it worked great for A long time.

Also, do the newer battery chargers go into A " de-sulfide mode" (safety issue)? Is that A factor here?
 

phy6

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 18, 2007
Messages
275
Location
Maryland, It's a Wet Heat.
Hey Tim, you know a while back I meant to come back to this thread and redeem myself for being an internet nanny. I apologize if I came off as someone who knows it all--you know the type--the kind that acts condescending because he can regurgitate a fact or two about why something is dangerous or 'bad'. I don't ever want to be that person. I'd rather be sincere and try and educate with what little I think I know, without being pretentious.

So yes, Chromium Hexavalent is dangerous IMO, but I didn't mean to sound like a ***** about it.


WRT your last post:

As for your amperage, I suppose if you needed to get the job done ASAP, then more amps are better. However, just more amps may not be the optimal consideration when there are other parts to the puzzle. For instance you may want to find out what the ideal water to electrolyte balance is, use clean water, use graphite electrodes, use more electrodes for better line of sight etc. I'm not sure.

Re: brick
I think the brick could bridge the two if there is a layer of sediment.

The lack of spark could mean an electrolyte imbalance.

I think the desulfide mode would be something that is a more expensive feature, so it would be advertised on the charger. It would be close to a trickle charge in amperage (I have one of those desulfiding chargers). I'm guessing your charger has an ammeter, and I'm guessing the desulfiding pulses are not high in amperage.

What is the duty cycle on your charger? Have you tried it on some other piece of equipment? It may have burned itself out running high amperage for a long time.

FWIW I've been happy with my cheapy HF 6/12 battery charger.

I hope this helps.
 

Dave455

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 19, 2013
Messages
5,796
Location
Sussex, England
Why bother with all the electrolysis malarkey? Mix up a solution of boric acid, chuck whatever you've got in, take it out looking as new a few days later!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom