I have been offered $ 200. For this tool chest and the top chest including contents Bottom chest is a 50's craftsman and the top is a Dayton year unknown. Contents are some Craftsman, some Snap-on, Stanley and others.
Is this a fair offer?
The Craftsman roller is the object of desire here. Many people are after them and the one in the picture does look in good enough shape for a full restore. I would pay 100 bucks for it alone if I wanted it.
The Dayton is a good box too. My old man has a complete stack and I have always liked the quality. Not many people are after a Dayton box though.
$200 is a fair offer for the boxes if empty, in my opinion. No idea what the contents look like, so it's impossible to make a reasonable assessment from a couple of blurry photos. Can you take better pictures?
Sounds like a good deal to me, I'd probably pay $200 for just the boxes. The Dayton box looks to be in great shape and I've always been a fan of the curvy chrome handled boxes. And the Craftsman is definitely a cool piece.