To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

2 Ton Engine Hoist Recommendations

danyo492

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
52
Location
Atlanta, GA
Can anyone recommend a good 2 ton engine hoist? Need it to pull the motor out of my C10 project. Harbor Freight is phasing out the older grey ones and putting out the new red 2 ton for $369.00 but there are no reviews since it’s so new. Looking to spend $300-$400. Thanks in advance!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
D

danyo492

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
52
Location
Atlanta, GA
^I’ve heard of people going the FB market place or CL route. Guess I should look and test before I buy
 

TailGunner3000

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 5, 2019
Messages
362
Location
New Jersey
Can anyone recommend a good 2 ton engine hoist? Need it to pull the motor out of my C10 project. Harbor Freight is phasing out the older grey ones and putting out the new red 2 ton for $369.00 but there are no reviews since it’s so new. Looking to spend $300-$400. Thanks in advance!
Looks to be the same as the previous model with only 2 changes I can see : The overarm support is now boxed in and handles have been added to the legs to aid in folding or storage. The first change makes me wonder if they had problems with being able to actually handle the stated load limit

I have the gray model and it's been able to handle whatever I've asked of it. But that's generally been lifting machines much lower in weight than 2 tons.
 

Dust

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
649
Location
Santa Ana, CA
If you only need it once or twice just rent one from a local equipment place. Some places will even rent by the hour. My local place charged $24 for four hours or $80 for the day way back when I last needed one.

The counter guy was amazed when I returned it three hours after picking it up.

You could even put an ad on Craigslist, Facebook, or Next Door asking to borrow or rent one from a local person.
 

finn

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
16,203
Location
The UP, God's country
If you only need it once or twice just rent one from a local equipment place. Some places will even rent by the hour. My local place charged $24 for four hours or $80 for the day way back when I last needed one.

The counter guy was amazed when I returned it three hours after picking it up.

You could even put an ad on Craigslist, Facebook, or Next Door asking to borrow or rent one from a local person.
Yup. Rent one if it’s a one time job.

They’re space hogs.
 

housewolf

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 3, 2021
Messages
1,144
Location
East Texas
Yup. Rent one if it’s a one time job.

They’re space hogs.
They are if you don’t use it much. I bought a used one ~15 years ago for $75 with the intent of selling it when I was done. I don’t think a week has gone by I haven’t used it for something. They‘re handy if you don’t have strong backs nearby at your disposal to assist with heavy lifting.

Lifting my generator into the back of my truck is probably the most common/often use I get out of it.
 

finn

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
16,203
Location
The UP, God's country
They are if you don’t use it much. I bought a used one ~15 years ago for $75 with the intent of selling it when I was done. I don’t think a week has gone by I haven’t used it for something. They‘re handy if you don’t have strong backs nearby at your disposal to assist with heavy lifting.

Lifting my generator into the back of my truck is probably the most common/often use I get out of it.
I agree, to some extent. i own two. The first is a non folding, relatively heavy duty lift that, while it can be disassembled, is a pain to store. It sits in the enclosed lean to at my shop, along the wall.

The second is the red version of the folding Harbor Freight lift that I bought when the larger orange lift was 450 miles away. I off loaded this one to my son. Although smaller, it still takes up a lot of space in his suburban garage.

Previously I rented engine hoists when I was removing and installing engines, and even now that’s my recommendation for first time users. If you find yourself renting frequently, then consider purchasing, as long as you don’t mind losing the floor space.
 

Oldsmobile

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 24, 2011
Messages
248
Location
Harrisburg PA
My local Ace rents an engine hoist: 4 hours for $20, 1 day for $30, and $100 for the week. At those prices, it's definitely worth pondering whether the cost & storage space is worth it.

disclaimer: I own the folding orange hoist from HF that I got when a buddy moved away. I haven't used it in years but since I have the space, I keep it. I'd happily lend it if it were needed, though.
 
OP
D

danyo492

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
52
Location
Atlanta, GA
If you only need it once or twice just rent one from a local equipment place. Some places will even rent by the hour. My local place charged $24 for four hours or $80 for the day way back when I last needed one.

The counter guy was amazed when I returned it three hours after picking it up.

You could even put an ad on Craigslist, Facebook, or Next Door asking to borrow or rent one from a local person.

I would rent one, but I'm doing a frame off restoration, so the motor will probably be going in and out over the course of the project. So I don't think renting would be the right move for me. Definitely worth considering though for sure!
 

cgrutt

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 4, 2016
Messages
8,200
I bought the gray HF worked fine. I replaced the chain and clevis hook that came with it with a better/shorter one from Tractor Supply. Where are you located been considering selling it and the HF engine stand as I really don't expect to need it in the foreseeable future.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
D

danyo492

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 16, 2017
Messages
52
Location
Atlanta, GA
I bought the gray HF worked fine. I replaced the chain and clevis hook that came with it with a better/shorter one from Tractor Supply. Where are you located been considering selling it and the HF engine stand as I really don't expect to need it in the foreseeable future.

I'm in metro Atlanta area, more Northwest though in the Canton/Holly Springs area. I got super excited because I saw a store display model for sale for $250 at my local store. I tested it and the pump was shot and it wouldn't raise the arm. I went back the other day and it's gone now.
 

RaisedByWolves

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 4, 2023
Messages
3,629
Location
SE PA.
They are if you don’t use it much. I bought a used one ~15 years ago for $75 with the intent of selling it when I was done. I don’t think a week has gone by I haven’t used it for something. They‘re handy if you don’t have strong backs nearby at your disposal to assist with heavy lifting.

Lifting my generator into the back of my truck is probably the most common/often use I get out of it.
As to weight handling I have exceeded the rated capacity of mine by 50% but only lifting my lathe an inch to move it, no I’ll effects years later.

As to the above mine spends most of its time as a makeshift parts hanger for painting parts too heavy or bulky to hold by hand.
 

speed bump

Well-known member
Joined
May 28, 2008
Messages
6,317
Location
Butte Montana
I've got a HF gray one. I've only pulled 2-3 engines with it but I've moved a hell of a lot of other stuff.

I welded a piece of round stock onto the bleed valve but other than that it's been solid.
 

Jwallace1

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 25, 2018
Messages
141
Location
spokane wa
i had a grey folding harbor freight version and hated it, flops around so much because of the folding legs and the casters were horrible, sold it and bought a 20-30 year old non folding version on craigslist for $75 replaced the ram with the double pump faster lifting style and it works 100 times better than the other one ever did. should have bought air over hydraulic style ram instead. plus its the style that has the legs that extend widthwise and lengthwise so its more stable and about twice the weight. the front legs are narrower pulled all the way in and the boom is longer and lifts higher, i would go this rough if you have the room for the non folding style.
 

whateg01

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 13, 2006
Messages
11,214
Location
doo dah, kansas, usa
TL;DR - For what you are doing, I would buy one on FB or CL and then resell it for the same or more when done. I find that people often don't clean stuff up before listing it and it brings less money than something that was cleaned up. Although there are differences, for a short time use, I would look for one that is capable of going high enough to get the motor in and out without fighting it.

I've owned several over the years, folding, fixed, and removable legs. The folding ones tend to lack height. The mast is usually only about 4' high, which may be fine for you, but if you have to lift something high, it can be a limitation. The reach when fully extended is another consideration. The fixed ones usually have the tallest and longest reach. I doubt you will actually need 2T of lifting power, but extended you only get about 1/4 of that, so if you have to reach a ways, it's good to start high.

Also, note that the 2T rating is a bit misleading. If you put 4000# on one, it is likely to fail. Either the boom will bend, a caster will break, causing the whole thing to tip and drop and bend a leg, or some other combination of catastrophic events. My fixed one died when one of the casters broke. I had made them fixed so that it would steer decent. But when loaded with about 2500#, even not extended, one of the casters broke and the whole load came down. I was smart and was moving it only a couple inches off the ground, but it still made a mess of the leg with the broken caster. It became scrap for other projects at that point.

The casters are typically a thin web casting. Compare these, which ideally would have 4k distributed evenly, so 1k per caster, to legit casters on real caster supply sites and you'll see they are sorely over-rated.

The truss over the top often has the post forward of where the ram is pushing on the bottom of the boom. Poor design as the idea is to keep the thing from buckling.

My engine hoist with removable legs did not have the truss but was still rated for 2T. While lifting a 3500# lathe at the 2T position, it bent the boom. The other area to look for if buying is the thickness of the tubing. My Harbor Freight folding engine hoist has much thinner tubing than the one with the removable legs. The orange one that broke with the caster also had relatively thin tubing. Fixed vs swivel casters is another difference. As stated, I like the fixed casters because they go the direction they are pointed. When loaded, swivel casters often will go whichever way you least want them to go. OTOH, if you need to be able to move the load laterally, the swivels can be rotated by hand to point the right direction before pushing.

If you can find one with a double acting pump on the ram, that will make lifting twice as fast, but I'd guess most you find on FB or CL won't have that.

Somebody will say you should not move the engine hoist with a load on it. I guess those people alternate between lifting the engine/****** a little, pushing the car rearward, lifting, pushing, lifting... I'm not sure how they do it when they have the front suspension out of the car.
 

Junkman

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2006
Messages
6,623
Location
Northeastern CT
My biggest complaint about my engine lift (Walker) is that sometimes it doesn't have enough weight on the back end when you are lifting a heavy object. When this happens, I just stand on the back end while someone else moves the lift. Mine has steel wheels that will stop abruptly if they run over anything larger than a grain of sand. When it was manufactured, the poly wheels hadn't been invented yet.
 

ItsNemo

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 5, 2016
Messages
4,805
Location
Canada
I got mine used off kijiji for $120, was dirty but otherwise in perfect shape. I can't imagine renting one when buying one used can be that cheap and what a pain in the *** that would be to pickup and dropoff. I've used mine for unloading and placing my in floor scissor lift, have parted out a couple vehicles with it, have lent it to the neighbour to put on the runways of his 4 post, used it for taking my lathe and mill off the trailer and getting them up on their stands, used it to get my compressor off its pallet, and I'm sure there's a few other uses I can't remember but it's been handy.
 

DrinkMan

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 13, 2020
Messages
1,237
Location
Georgia, USA
I like the CL/FB route of buy used, sell when project over. However, if you think you may need it for future projects and have the room, look at the Northern Tool option as well. When I was looking for a hoist and stand, I found the NT to be better built than the HF (not sure if still true). Here is the hoist I got for my occasional use: https://www.northerntool.com/produc...-2-ton-capacity-1in-82-5-8in-lift-range-46219

I got the corresponding NT stand because it had more reinforcement at the base and since I may have to have it hold a long 6 cylinder Mercedes engine, it would be better than the HF one (based on the unfortunate experience of a friend that restores Mercedes who no longer uses the HF engine stand). The stand works great; however, I wish I had spent the extra money for a geared style that I could turn the crank to rotate the engine. I just didn't realize how often I would be rotating the engine to different positions (the locking head wasn't too big a problem but I'm lazy).

Edit - just looked at the new red HF hoist. Looks a lot like the NT one I bought 5 years ago. If you can't find a decent hoist on CL/FB, look at the NT and HF and see how they compare. I'm interested in hearing your your thoughts. And go look at Summit Racing - they have combination hoist & stand. Interesting. Summit delivers or you can just drive down to McDonough and pick it up there (although that can get expensive because you end up buying so many other things).
 
Last edited:

bb29510

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 27, 2022
Messages
1,216
got to be careful with the fold up model, mine was a POS for about three years till I relise, the middle wheels are a different size and I had them installed wrong, whoops
 

finn

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2005
Messages
16,203
Location
The UP, God's country
i had a grey folding harbor freight version and hated it, flops around so much because of the folding legs and the casters were horrible, sold it and bought a 20-30 year old non folding version on craigslist for $75 replaced the ram with the double pump faster lifting style and it works 100 times better than the other one ever did. should have bought air over hydraulic style ram instead. plus its the style that has the legs that extend widthwise and lengthwise so its more stable and about twice the weight. the front legs are narrower pulled all the way in and the boom is longer and lifts higher, i would go this rough if you have the room for the non folding style.
That’s my experience. I ended up with both the floppy HF folding leg model and an older non folding hoist.

Despite the storage issues, it was an easy decision to give the floppy one to my son and keep the storage hog Ridgid hoist. Plus, he has more storage issues than I do.

There’s nothing really unsafe with the floppy one. It’s just a little unnerving.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom