To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Another Air compressor thread

silverdot1211

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 2, 2013
Messages
45
I have been looking at buying a budget friendly 60 gallon air compressor for my garage. So far I am going between the Kobalt (CH rebadge $399) and the Puma at Northern Tool ($539). My worry is on the kobalt it says "up to 5000 hour bearing life but it has a 3 year warranty. The Puma advertises 20,000 hour bearing life but only 1yr warranty. I like the feeling of knowing parts should be plentiful on the CH but for 40 more dollars the Puma is would appear to have a better pump. Noise is also a large concern. I have not heard either pump but people keep saying he puma is quiet. Just looking for input, should I be concerned with the pump life numbers or not, are the noise level's the going to be the same?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

jbontke

Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2014
Messages
6
Location
Abilene, TX
Where are the pumps made? USA, China? My experience has been bearings form china use a lower quality steel and don't last as long. And how long do you think that it would take you to reach 5000 HRS in your home garage? It would take me a long time and by then, replacing some hearings would not be much of hassle.

As for noise, I have never seen single stage compressors really marketed for noise. I would think that they would all be close in dB level.
 

Durka

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2014
Messages
341
Location
Howell, MI
As for noise, I have never seen single stage compressors really marketed for noise. I would think that they would all be close in dB level.

Not sure what that first sentence means...

The second, -Not really, the oil less SS compressors can be 4X's as loud as a lubricated unit.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
S

silverdot1211

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 2, 2013
Messages
45
either compressor would take me a while to "burn up or wear out" But 5000 vs 20000 that's a big difference and it makes me worry a little.
 

jbontke

Member
Joined
Apr 19, 2014
Messages
6
Location
Abilene, TX
Not sure what that first sentence means...

The second, -Not really, the oil less SS compressors can be 4X's as loud as a lubricated unit.

What the first sentence means I that you normally don't see 'super quiet' pasted on the box of a single stage compressor. I expect them to all make similar noise. And you are right, the oil-less compressors are the most noisy. But I ruled them out because the OP was referring to a 60 gal tank, which I have never seen an oil-less compressor in that size.

So 5,000 hours compared to 20,000 hours is a big difference. For me, just a weekend garage user, here is how I do the math. I spend on average 1.5 days a week in the garage or 12 hours a week. Multiply that by 52 weeks a year and I get 624 hours of garage time a year. I will just round this up to 700 hours a year. Now the compressor won't be running that whole time. I have a blast cabinet as the heavy air user amongst other air tools. I will say that the air compressor will run 30% of the time I am in the garage (that seems like enough). So 30% of 700 is 210 hours of use a year. If we take the 5,000 hr life cycle and divide it by 210, I will get 23 years of use. At that point I would be more concerned about being able to find parts for the compressor after that many years. So I would look at who makes the pump and look at their record for long term support of products. If I were running a shop, I would look at the 20,000 life span.

Besides bearings, I see most people replacing reed valves. You may want to look at the pump design and make a determination on that. It may have great bearings but if the reed valves or piston rings are being replaced every 2 or so years, that can get expensive. I don't know much about the pump, but I think the cobalt uses a Campbell Hausfeld pump.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom