To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Changing wiring in Kitchen..12-2 or 12-3?

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
I have a 1956 built house. The circuits in the kitchen are all on one circuit, the stuff on this 20 amp circuit is:
  1. Kitchen lights and 2 other outlets in the kitchen
  2. 2 outlets on the N wall of the kitchen above the countertop on each side of the sink.
  3. Outlet which the refrigerator is on.
  4. range hood

I saw this statement on this site http://www.buildmyowncabin.com/electrical/wiring-code.html and now I am wondering if I should be using 12-3 and a 20 amp double pole breaker to change the wire in the kitchen. I am putting in a new circuit for #2, the 2 outlets on the N wall.

"Outlets above the kitchen counter (for countertop appliances) should be fed by both circuits, not wired to just one circuit. The circuits for these outlets should not supply any other lights or outlets in the house. - See more at: http://www.buildmyowncabin.com/electrical/wiring-code.html#sthash.6HY5hLrr.dpuf"
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Zeke

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 13, 2009
Messages
17,176
Location
Long Beach CA, the sewer by the sea.
You need about 6 120v circuits in a kitchen nowadays. You can get there with 3) 12/3 cables. Code says on outlet for every length of counter over 2 feet, every 4 feet and within 2' of the sink, all GFCI. 2 different convenience circuits. 2 more for DW and GD. One more for a microwave/hood and the last for the refer. This is all besides lighting.

I'm sure I missed a bunch, like outlets on islands and peninsulas and any walls with no cabinets over 2' in length.

But you wanted to know about 12 ga. Yes, 12/3 will work on double pole breakers that are tied. And the main reason I post on threads like this is to either reinforce what I know or be corrected.
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
You need about 6 120v circuits in a kitchen nowadays. You can get there with 3) 12/3 cables. Code says on outlet for every length of counter over 2 feet, every 4 feet and within 2' of the sink, all GFCI. 2 different convenience circuits. 2 more for DW and GD. One more for a microwave/hood and the last for the refer. This is all besides lighting.

I'm sure I missed a bunch, like outlets on islands and peninsulas and any walls with no cabinets over 2' in length.

But you wanted to know about 12 ga. Yes, 12/3 will work on double pole breakers that are tied. And the main reason I post on threads like this is to either reinforce what I know or be corrected.

So Zeke is this what you are saying:
This is the configuration of my kitchen: There are 4 outlets in this kitchen: 2 on N wall above counter on each side of the sink, one on the E wall at floor level & one on S wall above a small counter that the fridge plugs into.

1a. a 20 amp circuit for every outlet? or a 20 amp circuit for every outlet above the counter? w 1 GFCI?
1b. Or could I put the 2 outlets on N wall that are above the counter on the same 20 amp circuit (w 1 GFCI)?

2.The outlet on the W wall at floor level would stay on the circuit it is on?

3. Outlet on the S wall above the counter would go on a new circuit?

4. No DW or disposal right now but put in a new circuit for DW & separate new circuit for disposal?

5. And leave the rest of the kitchen on the circuits they are on.

Is that what you mean?

thanks!
 

Zeke

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 13, 2009
Messages
17,176
Location
Long Beach CA, the sewer by the sea.
Ideally, you would split the outlets on the same counter so that whatever you are using on the counter, slow cooker, electric frying pan, toaster oven, togehter would be on separate circuits. By not having the fridge on one of those, they can take more watts from your heating type of appliances. Sure, if you are using watt drawing appliances simultaneously, you could put one on one counter and the other across and still have room for some more draw on each side. But people tend to work on one side of the kitchen.

If you have a counter top microwave and only one circuit to that side of the kitchen, you may find out what I mean if you try to use toaster oven at the same time on the same counter.

You don't need and the code doesn't tell you to have a new circuit for every outlet on the counters (1a). (1b would have you distribute the duties of the circuits around the kitchen to prevent overload at one work station.

Edit: Why isn't this in electrical? More and better answers.
 

Cougar

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 22, 2011
Messages
3,338
Location
Wisconsin A little south of the Frozen Tundra
You need about 6 120v circuits in a kitchen nowadays. You can get there with 3) 12/3 cables. Code says on outlet for every length of counter over 2 feet, every 4 feet and within 2' of the sink, all GFCI. 2 different convenience circuits. 2 more for DW and GD. One more for a microwave/hood and the last for the refer. This is all besides lighting.

I'm sure I missed a bunch, like outlets on islands and peninsulas and any walls with no cabinets over 2' in length.

But you wanted to know about 12 ga. Yes, 12/3 will work on double pole breakers that are tied. And the main reason I post on threads like this is to either reinforce what I know or be corrected.

One breaker will carry two circuits?
Our kitchen has 4 or 5 circuits, each one is on it's own 20 amp breaker.
 

december45

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Messages
1,580
I am talking 2 circuits, just for recepticals in the kitchen, when I was planning out my kitchen wiring, I was going to go with 12/3, I mentioned this to the electical inspector before I started and he urged me to use 12/2 running two completely separate circuits for the recepticals. I dont remember why he would rather see two complete circuits but thats how i did it. Maybe it was something to do with the capacity of the receptical boxes, I cant remember for sure.
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
I am talking 2 circuits, just for recepticals in the kitchen, when I was planning out my kitchen wiring, I was going to go with 12/3, I mentioned this to the electical inspector before I started and he urged me to use 12/2 running two completely separate circuits for the recepticals. I dont remember why he would rather see two complete circuits but thats how i did it. Maybe it was something to do with the capacity of the receptical boxes, I cant remember for sure.

I can do that.....means about 145 ft of wire total. I can see why he said to do that. Also would mean 2 GFCI's because the 2 outlets on the N wall are on either side of the sink.
He said that way because then it would be 2 sep circuits and you could do heavy use on both.
 

zcar751

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 15, 2013
Messages
831
Location
Knoxville, TN
When you say 12/2 it is one black wire, one white wire and one copper ground correct? You will use 12/2 for outlets and lights with only one switch. If you use two or more light switches for a light that's were 12/3 would be used.

When you run a circuit you need to determine the load so that the breaker will not be overloaded. The average large micro wave is 1100 watts which should be on its own circuit or you will make many trips to the breaker box.:shocking: As you figure you circuit load keep in mind that you will realistically only run one maybe two counter top appliance at a time. Say a coffee maker and toaster but if you add a pancake griddle then the outlet is going to pop again. Start by drawing out your lay out and set your outlet up so that you daisy chain them along the counter top with two circuits leap froging them over each other.
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
When you say 12/2 it is one black wire, one white wire and one copper ground correct? You will use 12/2 for outlets and lights with only one switch. If you use two or more light switches for a light that's were 12/3 would be used.

When you run a circuit you need to determine the load so that the breaker will not be overloaded. The average large micro wave is 1100 watts which should be on its own circuit or you will make many trips to the breaker box.:shocking: As you figure you circuit load keep in mind that you will realistically only run one maybe two counter top appliance at a time. Say a coffee maker and toaster but if you add a pancake griddle then the outlet is going to pop again. Start by drawing out your lay out and set your outlet up so that you daisy chain them along the counter top with two circuits leap froging them over each other.

Thanks, I understand where you are comming from.
There are only 2 circuits over the counter top that I want to rewire, the counter top is not that long and not really that much room to put a bunch of **** (appliances) on the counter. It will be hard enough to get the wire to the outlets anyway, that wall is cantilevered out about 18-24" anyway, I'll have to crawl up into the bay almost...LOL

Speaking of microwave, I have it plugged into the outlet on my 40" stove( Not sure what year it is from but it is cool, has push buttons and 2 ovens). The microwave is circa 1988 (yep had it new since then....no kids) and is only 700 watts
 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
I have a 1956 built house. The circuits in the kitchen are all on one circuit, the stuff on this 20 amp circuit is:
  1. Kitchen lights and 2 other outlets in the kitchen
  2. 2 outlets on the N wall of the kitchen above the countertop on each side of the sink.
  3. Outlet which the refrigerator is on.
  4. range hood

I saw this statement on this site http://www.buildmyowncabin.com/electrical/wiring-code.html and now I am wondering if I should be using 12-3 and a 20 amp double pole breaker to change the wire in the kitchen. I am putting in a new circuit for #2, the 2 outlets on the N wall.

"Outlets above the kitchen counter (for countertop appliances) should be fed by both circuits, not wired to just one circuit. The circuits for these outlets should not supply any other lights or outlets in the house. - See more at: http://www.buildmyowncabin.com/electrical/wiring-code.html#sthash.6HY5hLrr.dpuf"

First, I am NOT a fan of using **/3 cabling to feed multiple 120V circuits, especially in situations where those circuits could wind up being heavily loaded. Each circuit should be fed via its own **/2 cable of appropriate AWG. I'll further explain the "why" below.

Next, with respect to "splitting" the duplex outlets and feeding each socket from a different circuit, note that they say "should", not "must". Whether or not it's a good idea for your particular Kitchen will depend in part on exactly how you intend to use those outlets. The idea behind the recommendation is the fact that many folks tend to "cluster" their watt-hungry countertop appliances -- toaster, coffee pot, blender, etc. -- in one general area, which means they wind up all getting plugged into the same duplex outlet (or at least just the two or three closest ones). If you have, say, a toaster and a coffee pot fed from the same circuit, and you're making breakfast... You can easily exceed the capacity of that circuit. But if the Duplex is split and fed from separate circuits, that potential problem is eliminated.

OTOH, if you split your duplexes, then (as is typical) feed all the top outlets from one circuit and all the bottom ones from a second circuit, you could just as easily have a problem if you scatter your appliances around the room, but wind up plugging both the toaster and the coffee pot (plus perhaps a countertop griddle for pancakes, and maybe a few other things) into (for example) the bottom socket of those various duplexes.

Best practice is that EVERY single outlet (i.e., each half of each duplex outlet) which is located where an appliance might conceivably be plugged into it (i,e, those serving countertops) is fed directly from it's own dedicated breaker, with nothing else whatsoever on that circuit. But this is rarely done in real life, partly because it makes for a LOT of breakers (and a lot of wire) by the time you put in enough outlets to satisfy the inspector.

Beyond this issue, your current setup would not meet code for several other reasons. Depending on how much of it you replace, you MAY be required to bring the whole room up to current code. Something to think about before you start tearing into things.


You need about 6 120v circuits in a kitchen nowadays. You can get there with 3) 12/3 cables.

You can. But I wouldn't. See below.


So Zeke is this what you are saying:
This is the configuration of my kitchen: There are 4 outlets in this kitchen: 2 on N wall above counter on each side of the sink, one on the E wall at floor level & one on S wall above a small counter that the fridge plugs into.

1a. a 20 amp circuit for every outlet? or a 20 amp circuit for every outlet above the counter? w 1 GFCI?

You can probably get away with feeding the outlet that is low on the East wall from one of your common lighting circuits, as the odds are against a kitchen appliance being plugged in there. It would still be "better" on its own circuit, but it's not a major issue.

All outlets in potentially "wet" locations MUST be protected by a GFCI device. That device can either be built into the outlet itself, or into the breaker feeding that circuit from the panel. IF you are running more than one (duplex) outlet off a given breaker (i.e., "daisy-chaining"), then you can also GFCI-protect them all by putting a GFCI outlet in the "first" location (i.e., the one to which the wire from the breaker panel connects directly), then feeding the other outlet(s) from the GFCI outlet (they have terminals on the back for just this purpose). Still, it's neater and cleaner to do this at the breaker panel, which also guards against any faults which may lie/develop in the line feeding that first outlet from the panel.

1b. Or could I put the 2 outlets on N wall that are above the counter on the same 20 amp circuit (w 1 GFCI)?

I wouldn't. Think of all those countertop appliances.

2.The outlet on the W wall at floor level would stay on the circuit it is on?

Probably.

3. Outlet on the S wall above the counter would go on a new circuit?

Probably. While you're at it, get an "old work" box, and give the refrigerator AT LEAST its own outlet, located directly behind the 'fridge, where it won't show. Better yet, make it a dedicated circuit (not so much because the load is large -- most refers don't draw all THAT much; but because if you pop a breaker because of whatever else might be on that circuit, your food starts going bad.

4. No DW or disposal right now but put in a new circuit for DW & separate new circuit for disposal?

That would be prudent.

5. And leave the rest of the kitchen on the circuits they are on.

The microwave, if any, MUST have its own dedicated circuit.

The lighting can probably all be on one circuit, unless you've gone way over the top on that. Still, it is always a good idea to split the lighting load in any one room between at least two different circuits, even if those circuits also handle some of the lighting in another room. This way, if/when you pop a breaker, you won't be left totally in the dark.


I am talking 2 circuits, just for recepticals in the kitchen, when I was planning out my kitchen wiring, I was going to go with 12/3, I mentioned this to the electical inspector before I started and he urged me to use 12/2 running two completely separate circuits for the recepticals. I dont remember why he would rather see two complete circuits but thats how i did it.

Your Inspector did you a big favor with that "urging", even if it wasn't absolutely required by code.

The reason for this is that, when you "siamese" two 120V circuits onto an "**/3" cable, both circuits must share the single Neutral conductor. This effectively cuts the REAL current-carrying capacity of those two circuits in half, if there is any possibility of their being used simultaneously. It might meet code (at least in some places); but I would NEVER do it if given the choice. IMCO, the ONLY proper places to use "**/3" cable is for the "Traveler" lines between two "3-Way" wall switches, and for a 220/240V outlet/device which does NOT require a Neutral (and that might not even meet code any more -- I'm not sure).


When you say 12/2 it is one black wire, one white wire and one copper ground correct?

Correct.

You will use 12/2 for outlets and lights with only one switch. If you use two or more light switches for a light that's were 12/3 would be used.

Well... That's an oversimplification, at best. When wiring "3-Way" switches, **/3 cable gets used between the two switches in order to provide the extra "Traveller" line. But **/2 still gets used to feed power to the first switch, and to feed the load(s) from the second switch.

When you run a circuit you need to determine the load so that the breaker will not be overloaded. The average large micro wave is 1100 watts which should be on its own circuit or you will make many trips to the breaker box.:shocking: As you figure you circuit load keep in mind that you will realistically only run one maybe two counter top appliance at a time. Say a coffee maker and toaster but if you add a pancake griddle then the outlet is going to pop again. Start by drawing out your lay out and set your outlet up so that you daisy chain them along the counter top with two circuits leap froging them over each other.

As I said above, while some would consider it overkill, the BEST way to avoid such issues, now or in the future, is daisy-chain NOTHING; instead, give each individual outlet its own run of (at least) 12/2 (10/2 if it's a long run), fed from its own breaker.


Thanks, I understand where you are comming from.
There are only 2 circuits over the counter top that I want to rewire, the counter top is not that long and not really that much room to put a bunch of **** (appliances) on the counter. It will be hard enough to get the wire to the outlets anyway, that wall is cantilevered out about 18-24" anyway, I'll have to crawl up into the bay almost...LOL

The difficulty and inconvenience of the job might inspire you to take shortcuts and/or make compromises you otherwise wouldn't. Don't fall into that trap. Do the job right, and do it ONCE.

Speaking of microwave, I have it plugged into the outlet on my 40" stove( Not sure what year it is from but it is cool, has push buttons and 2 ovens). The microwave is circa 1988 (yep had it new since then....no kids) and is only 700 watts

That is a VERY bad idea. Fix this while you're doing everything else.

 

landyacht

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 26, 2011
Messages
71
Location
Langley BC
2Many, I agree with everything you've said except :

"The reason for this is that, when you "siamese" two 120V circuits onto an "**/3" cable, both circuits must share the single Neutral conductor. This effectively cuts the REAL current-carrying capacity of those two circuits in half, if there is any possibility of their being used simultaneously. It might meet code (at least in some places); but I would NEVER do it if given the choice. IMCO, the ONLY proper places to use "**/3" cable is for the "Traveler" lines between two "3-Way" wall switches, and for a 220/240V outlet/device which does NOT require a Neutral (and that might not even meet code any more -- I'm not sure)."

Now it may be different here than in your jurisdiction, but in BC if you run a split feed cct, the 2 hot lines must be fed from different phases of the panel using a 2 pole breaker, thus if you load both lines, the neutral will in essence be a reference only, and carry almost no current. If you feed both from the same phase however, you are absolutely right, and you just overloaded your neutral.

That being said, if you're going to run GFI protected outlets near water sources, then split feeds require GFI breakers (because they are on separate phases and you cant split a GFI outlet to my knowledge), and that is far more expensive than using GFI outlets, which is why you pretty much never see split feeds anymore in kitchen plugs as any gain in the cost of wire gets more than eaten up by breaker costs.
 

RickP

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,549
Location
Annapolis, MD
2ManyProjects said:
The reason for this is that, when you "siamese" two 120V circuits onto an "**/3" cable, both circuits must share the single Neutral conductor. This effectively cuts the REAL current-carrying capacity of those two circuits in half, if there is any possibility of their being used simultaneously. It might meet code (at least in some places); but I would NEVER do it if given the choice. IMCO, the ONLY proper places to use "**/3" cable is for the "Traveler" lines between two "3-Way" wall switches...

Really? You're preaching this again? Dude, you really need to understand electricity a little better before constantly throwing up these long a$$ posts.

You're wrong about **/3 cable, because it can be used in multi wire branch circuits. (Google MWBC and start reading.) Not only do they meet code, but they are perfectly safe as well, when they are installed correctly. My entire house is wired with them, installed by licensed electricians, and believe me -- if they weren't safe I would have re-done them all by now.

You've actually got it completely backwards, because the neutral is actually safer in a MWBC than it is in a regular circuit. The neutral in a MWBC actually carries almost ZERO electricity when the loads are balanced between the two circuits, because the opposite electrical phases of the circuits cancel each other out.


Posted from Garagejournal.com App for Android
 

RickP

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,549
Location
Annapolis, MD
pitterpat said:
Thanks for all the info and replies.

Good luck with your project - I think you've got it figured out. And I hope you don't encounter any multi wire circuits - if you see any red wires in any of the boxes, please ask!


Posted from Garagejournal.com App for Android
 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
2Many, I agree with everything you've said except :

"The reason for this is that, when you "siamese" two 120V circuits onto an "**/3" cable, both circuits must share the single Neutral conductor. This effectively cuts the REAL current-carrying capacity of those two circuits in half, if there is any possibility of their being used simultaneously. It might meet code (at least in some places); but I would NEVER do it if given the choice. IMCO, the ONLY proper places to use "**/3" cable is for the "Traveler" lines between two "3-Way" wall switches, and for a 220/240V outlet/device which does NOT require a Neutral (and that might not even meet code any more -- I'm not sure)."

Now it may be different here than in your jurisdiction, but in BC if you run a split feed cct, the 2 hot lines must be fed from different phases of the panel using a 2 pole breaker, thus if you load both lines, the neutral will in essence be a reference only, and carry almost no current. If you feed both from the same phase however, you are absolutely right, and you just overloaded your neutral.

Really? You're preaching this again? Dude, you really need to understand electricity a little better before constantly throwing up these long a$$ posts.

You're wrong about **/3 cable, because it can be used in multi wire branch circuits. (Google MWBC and start reading.) Not only do they meet code, but they are perfectly safe as well, when they are installed correctly. My entire house is wired with them, installed by licensed electricians, and believe me -- if they weren't safe I would have re-done them all by now.

You've actually got it completely backwards, because the neutral is actually safer in a MWBC than it is in a regular circuit. The neutral in a MWBC actually carries almost ZERO electricity when the loads are balanced between the two circuits, because the opposite electrical phases of the circuits cancel each other out.

In both cases, you guys are overlooking a critical (if perhaps subtle) distinction: In a 220/240V application, the main "current loop" is comprised of the two hot legs, as the load forms a direct path between them. Hence, the Neutral carries only the residual currents imposed by any (usually trivial) imbalance which may exist between the two legs. But in the "split duplexes" scenario, there is NO path for current to flow from one hot leg to the other (at least we certainly hope not! :shocking: ), so the shared Neutral MUST carry all the "return" currents from both hot legs.

Now, in a perfect world, with purely resistive loads, we could still get away with this as long as the two hot legs were on opposite phases because, as you both noted, the opposite-flowing currents would effectively cancel each other out. But the real world is not a perfect world. And in the context of Kitchen appliances (or, quite notably in the context of this board, power tools) in particular, reactive (i.e., inductive and/or capacitive) loads are not only common, but actually quite the norm. Hence, current flow does NOT stay neatly in sync with the line voltage, and therefore we can no longer count on that cancellation process. Depending on the particular devices plugged into each "side" (which is of course a ****-shoot), some very significant real-world currents can (and will!) flow in the Neutral. Will these out-of-sync currents happen to stack up in a way which will make the total exceed the rating for that one conductor? I don't know; as noted, it's a load-dependent ****-shoot. But I for one would prefer to not take the chance.

Bottom Line: As I said before, using **/3 cable to feed split duplexes may indeed meet code; but it is NOT "best practice".

 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
Good luck with your project - I think you've got it figured out. And I hope you don't encounter any multi wire circuits - if you see any red wires in any of the boxes, please ask!


Posted from Garagejournal.com App for Android

There are some but they are in circuits that I am not going to touch. Thanks!
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
So..............

Speaking of the MWBC: This is for the wall with only 2 outlets on the wall on either side of the sink. If (BIG if), just asking to learn not saying I will do, I run 12-3 to the 1st outlet that will have a GFCI, and then pigtail it, then from the pigtail use 12-2 is that OK. These will be the only 2 outlets on this circuit.

Then in one of the boxes add a circuit for the disposal, different circuit @ 20 amp.
Would this be ok?

Meaning I will have a single gang box (1st box w/ GFCI) in the wall and a double gang box in the wall.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

RickP

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,549
Location
Annapolis, MD
So..............

Speaking of the MWBC: This is for the wall with only 2 outlets on the wall on either side of the sink. If (BIG if), just asking to learn not saying I will do, I run 12-3 to the 1st outlet that will have a GFCI, and then pigtail it, then from the pigtail use 12-2 is that OK. These will be the only 2 outlets on this circuit.

Then in one of the boxes add a circuit for the disposal, different circuit @ 20 amp.
Would this be ok?

Meaning I will have a single gang box (1st box w/ GFCI) in the wall and a double gang box in the wall.

I'm not sure I understand what you're asking... Many people a lot smarter than me have recommended that if you can't draw it, don't try to install it. Maybe a drawing or a picture would help.

IF you do decide to do this, make sure to follow the code for hooking it up correctly. If your main panel is nearly full, it can sometimes be hard to find two adjacent breaker slots. Even the electricians who wired my whole house put two MWBC breakers on the same phase by mistake.

If you run a 12-3 cable to the 1st box, you can just split the two circuits there - with the black wire feeding one circuit and the red wire feeding the 2nd circuit. Make sure all the white neutral wires are continuous. You'll also need to check the box fill tables, because a 12-3 cable splitting into two circuits will overfill a standard single gang box.

When you run the 12-3 cable to the panel make sure you connect the black and red wires to adjacent 120v breakers connected with a handle tie (which forces both circuits to trip simultaneously). If you have major questions about any of this, it's probably best to steer clear of it.
 

Speedy Petey

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
1,430
Location
NY State
Now, in a perfect world, with purely resistive loads, we could still get away with this as long as the two hot legs were on opposite phases because, as you both noted, the opposite-flowing currents would effectively cancel each other out. But the real world is not a perfect world. And in the context of Kitchen appliances (or, quite notably in the context of this board, power tools) in particular, reactive (i.e., inductive and/or capacitive) loads are not only common, but actually quite the norm. Hence, current flow does NOT stay neatly in sync with the line voltage, and therefore we can no longer count on that cancellation process. Depending on the particular devices plugged into each "side" (which is of course a ****-shoot), some very significant real-world currents can (and will!) flow in the Neutral. Will these out-of-sync currents happen to stack up in a way which will make the total exceed the rating for that one conductor? I don't know; as noted, it's a load-dependent ****-shoot. But I for one would prefer to not take the chance.
Wow!! You are SO wrong it's not even funny.

The main service in your home IS one big multi-wire circuit...SHARING the neutral. Are you aware of this?
Using 12/3 on a MWBC, sharing a neutral, properly installed using a 20pole breaker, is the SAME thing.
 

zmaxmotorsports

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 11, 2013
Messages
11,948
Location
South of omaha
Really? You're preaching this again? Dude, you really need to understand electricity a little better before constantly throwing up these long a$$ posts.

You're wrong about **/3 cable, because it can be used in multi wire branch circuits. (Google MWBC and start reading.) Not only do they meet code, but they are perfectly safe as well, when they are installed correctly. My entire house is wired with them, installed by licensed electricians, and believe me -- if they weren't safe I would have re-done them all by now.

You've actually got it completely backwards, because the neutral is actually safer in a MWBC than it is in a regular circuit. The neutral in a MWBC actually carries almost ZERO electricity when the loads are balanced between the two circuits, because the opposite electrical phases of the circuits cancel each other out.


Posted from Garagejournal.com App for Android

Im retired pretty much from the trades but still do little jobs,We are not allowed to use 3 conductor wire with a common neutral for mwbc anymore(last time I checked anyway):dunno:
 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
So..............

Speaking of the MWBC: This is for the wall with only 2 outlets on the wall on either side of the sink. If (BIG if), just asking to learn not saying I will do, I run 12-3 to the 1st outlet that will have a GFCI, and then pigtail it, then from the pigtail use 12-2 is that OK. These will be the only 2 outlets on this circuit.

It has been several months since I looked at the back of a GFCI-equipped duplex outlet; but IIRC, they don't offer any capability for "splitting" the two sockets onto separate circuits like "normal" duplex fixtures do. Hence, your question is very likely moot. If such an outlet is available, it would necessarily contain TWO complete GFCI circuits/mechanisms, presumably with separate test & reset buttons for each. I have never seen such.

Then in one of the boxes add a circuit for the disposal, different circuit @ 20 amp.
Would this be ok?

Typically (and ideally; and, I think, required by code these days), the disposal will get its own dedicated circuit, the outlet for which is conveniently located low enough on the wall to be accessible from under the sink (i.e., mounted through the back of the sink-base cabinet, if any). This would be completely separate and distinct from whatever outlets/boxes/circuits serve your countertop appliances. The SWITCH for said disposal (if required) can of course be run up inside the wall from there, and occupy a box adjacent to one of your countertop outlets.

Meaning I will have a single gang box (1st box w/ GFCI) in the wall and a double gang box in the wall.

I'm not entirely certain that I'm following you here; but this seems to imply that you're planning to plug the disposal in ABOVE the counter. That won't work..

 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
Wow!! You are SO wrong it's not even funny.

The main service in your home IS one big multi-wire circuit...SHARING the neutral. Are you aware of this?

Quite.

First, by the time you get a whole house-worth of "typical" loads averaged out across both phases, the reactive "oddities" also tend to average out. It would be essentially impossible to have one side effectively consist of a single huge inductive load, and the other to be a similarly extreme capacitive load.

Besides, the main service-entrance cable is subject to a separate set of ampacity requirements applicable to each individual conductor anyway. You are comparing apples and bananas.

Using 12/3 on a MWBC, sharing a neutral, properly installed using a 20pole breaker, is the SAME thing.

Not really.

But like I said.... Using **/3 cable is common. Most of the time, you can do it without problems. It might even meet code. But that STILL doesn't mean it's the best way. If using 12/3 to feed split duplexes is "good enough" for you, fine. Be happy. But, to slightly misquote Voltaire... "'Better' is the enemy of 'good enough'."

 

Speedy Petey

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2012
Messages
1,430
Location
NY State
First, by the time you get a whole house-worth of "typical" loads averaged out across both phases, the reactive "oddities" also tend to average out. It would be essentially impossible to have one side effectively consist of a single huge inductive load, and the other to be a similarly extreme capacitive load.
Agree.



Besides, the main service-entrance cable is subject to a separate set of ampacity requirements applicable to each individual conductor anyway.
HUH???


You are comparing apples and bananas.
No, not really. It's basically the SAME thing.




But like I said.... Using **/3 cable is common. Most of the time, you can do it without problems. It might even meet code.
"Might even"?? How about absolutely does meet code.



But that STILL doesn't mean it's the best way. If using 12/3 to feed split duplexes is "good enough" for you, fine.
It's not necessarily the best way, but that does not mean it's a bad way. It's a damn sight better than "good enough".


BTW, what kind of engineer are you? Electrical or mechanical I'd bet, right? And you've never worked in the trades, right?
 

landyacht

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 26, 2011
Messages
71
Location
Langley BC
I just want to clarify something. I didn't mean to open a can of worms with my comments. I also want to say that for power to flow from one hot leg to the other in a 3 wire feed, the common point of connection is the neutral, which is where the 2 phases will effectively cancel out their common current draw leaving the remainder to flow down the neutral. For inductive loads to become an issue, you would have to have power factors far worse than 90 from the motors. Unless you're using 1930's vintage industrial appliances in your kitchen, you are most certainly never going to see this happen in a residential setting. Theoretically anything you're buying these days should be tested by UL, or some other equivalent too, but hey never say never. I do remember the large amount of equipment we needed in the lab at school to replicate the potential issue you're discussing, and I would volunteer that unless you're actually trying to cause a fault, it is practically impossible.

That all being said, I still personally would use separate 12/2 feeds as in the long run, it will probably save money.
 

James_B

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 24, 2013
Messages
674
Location
Nova Scotia, Canada (started in Brisbane, Australi
I redid the kitchen in our 1983 built house about 2 years ago. It went from having just 2 dedicated circuits that fed all the bench outlets, the dishwasher, and refrigerator, plus a tapped feed from another room for the vent hood, and another feed from a different room for a single wall outlet.

The dishwasher, refrigerator, and every bench outlet except for 1 were on one circuit, which was always popping. The solitary bench outlet on the second circuit had a plug in switch and a lead that disappeared into the wall and ended up feeding a ceiling mounted light above the sink ... plus that same circuit also fed every light and outlet in the basement.

By the time I'd finished, there were 3 dedicated circuits for the bench outlets, 3 more dedicated circuits for the dishwasher, refrigerator, and microwave/range hood, and 2 low wall outlets for things like the vacuum cleaner that shared circuits with another room.

Everything was run in 12/2+E, and it took close to a roll and a half of cable and 4 extra breakers to add the new kitchen circuits and re-run a lot of the questionable wiring that had been "worked on" by "less than competent handymen" over the previous few decades. I found lots of taped up joints that were not in junction boxes hidden in the basement, and a lot of security lighting circuits had been added after a break-in a few years before we bought the house, and they'd been run in red sheathed 14/2 red/black heater cable. In 4 years, I never did find the switch for one external security light.

The basement got it's own dedicated circuits, and by the time I'd finished, the 40 breaker panel in the garage was completely filled (I even had to sacrifice the 220V/50A welding outlet in the garage to free up 2 breaker positions). A 64 breaker panel had been bought to replace the 40 breaker panel, but we sold the house before I'd had that installed, so the purchasers got the new panel uninstalled.
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
What I may just do is put in 4 12/2 circuits:
  1. 1/outlet above sink
  2. DW
  3. Disposal

The that takes care of everything; about 350' of wire.
 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
What I may just do is put in 4 12/2 circuits:
  1. 1/outlet above sink
  2. DW
  3. Disposal

The that takes care of everything; about 350' of wire.

That's a good start; but you're forgetting a couple of things...

-- The microwave oven; this MUST have it's own circuit.

-- The countertop duplex on the South Wall.

-- The separate box/outlet (even if not separate circuit, which would still be preferable) for the refrigerator.

For the reasons described previously, you might also want to make sure that the lighting in that room is split between at least two different circuits, even if those circuits also feed various other minor loads (such as a light or two in other rooms).

If you're running out of available slots in your breaker panel, the first place to "economize" on the circuit count would be to let the refer outlet share a circuit with some light-duty load such as, maybe, a rarely used duplex outlet in another nearby room.

The next place would be to defer those "future use" circuits for the dishwasher and disposal, unless you're pretty sure you ARE going to install those devices in the relatively near future. Cross those bridges if/when you get to them (which MAY mean replacing the breaker panel at some point).

If absolutely necessary, you CAN get away with just two 20A circuits to feed all of your countertop outlets, even though this would be far from ideal. Whether you do this by running alternate duplexes off different circuits, or by "splitting" the duplexes, is up to you; and as explained earlier, which approach would be preferable will depend on the anticipated usage (most folks would want to go with the split-duplex approach). Still, a separate circuit & breaker for each outlet (while also splitting the duplexes) is still best.

FWIW, if/when I ever build my "Last House" (I'm currently 27 years into my "Five Year House"; so "if" is a bigger worry than "when" right now), each and every outlet, appliance, light fixture, wall switch, & etc. will be "home run" to a master patch panel adjacent to the main service panel in the utility area, using oversize wiring (to minimize impedance losses and obviate the longer wire runs). This will allow circuit assignments to be made -- and CHANGED -- as needed through the life of the house, as well as easing the implementation of a whole-house home automation system. Obviously, retrofitting something like this into an existing home is a much more difficult and expensive job, to the point that it is rarely (if ever) worth doing; and I am NOT recommending you do so. But the point is, the more you split things up, the more flexibility you maintain and the more you "future-proof" yourself.

 

Norcal

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 16, 2008
Messages
13,754
If a microwave is not built in, it may be plugged into the SABC.
 
OP
P

pitterpat

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 30, 2011
Messages
686
Location
Indianapolis
That's a good start; but you're forgetting a couple of things...

-- The microwave oven; this MUST have it's own circuit.It will stay plugged into the stove for the time being

-- The countertop duplex on the South Wall.No counter top duplex on S wall; only one outlet on the S wall.

-- The separate box/outlet (even if not separate circuit, which would still be preferable) for the refrigerator.Same fridge the other owner had.....outlet is fine, which is the only outlet on the S wall.

For the reasons described previously, you might also want to make sure that the lighting in that room is split between at least two different circuits, even if those circuits also feed various other minor loads (such as a light or two in other rooms).

If you're running out of available slots in your breaker panel, the first place to "economize" on the circuit count would be to let the refer outlet share a circuit with some light-duty load such as, maybe, a rarely used duplex outlet in another nearby room.

The next place would be to defer those "future use" circuits for the dishwasher and disposal, unless you're pretty sure you ARE going to install those devices in the relatively near future. Cross those bridges if/when you get to them (which MAY mean replacing the breaker panel at some point).Will do at the same time I do the other 2, I have to take out 4 pieces of bead board and 2 pieces of trim to run the wire, snake it down the wall through about 12 joists in the basement so I might as well do it all at once. Tape it all together to get it all snaked down the stud bay.

If absolutely necessary, you CAN get away with just two 20A circuits to feed all of your countertop outlets, even though this would be far from ideal. I have only 2 counter top outlets on the N wall and one on the S wall that has the fridge plugged into it. Whether you do this by running alternate duplexes off different circuits, or by "splitting" the duplexes, is up to you; and as explained earlier, which approach would be preferable will depend on the anticipated usage (most folks would want to go with the split-duplex approach). Still, a separate circuit & breaker for each outlet (while also splitting the duplexes) is still best.

FWIW, if/when I ever build my "Last House" (I'm currently 27 years into my "Five Year House"; so "if" is a bigger worry than "when" right now), each and every outlet, appliance, light fixture, wall switch, & etc. will be "home run" to a master patch panel adjacent to the main service panel in the utility area, using oversize wiring (to minimize impedance losses and obviate the longer wire runs). This will allow circuit assignments to be made -- and CHANGED -- as needed through the life of the house, as well as easing the implementation of a whole-house home automation system. Obviously, retrofitting something like this into an existing home is a much more difficult and expensive job, to the point that it is rarely (if ever) worth doing; and I am NOT recommending you do so. But the point is, the more you split things up, the more flexibility you maintain and the more you "future-proof" yourself.


2ManyProjects:
FWIW, I'm not going to be PC....throughout all of this you have suggested basically that everything have it's own separate circuit. That is not going to happen here. I'm not going to create 6-8 circuits when they are not needed. Just not going to happen. I rarely use the circuits on the counter top so they are not being over loaded now and when I put in the new circuits they will not be overloaded then. I just want to put them in so they are the grounded 3 prong outlets and for esthetics. There is a ground wire but they did not use it in 1956 when they wired the outlets. I have not popped a breaker in living in this house 18 months and I know I have more electronic than the original owner did and more stuff.

The microwave I own is 700 watts, circa 1988, it is plugged into the stove outlet and is staying there for the time being. Had no problems.

So, I will add my 4 circuits and be ok I'm sure.
Thanks for your opinion.
 

2ManyProjects

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 18, 2013
Messages
757
What is a SABC?

"Small Appliance Branch Circuit" -- i.e., those outlets serving the countertops we've been discussing throughout this thread.

Microwave is plugged into the outlet on the stove, it is only 700 watts (circa 1988) and for now that is where it is staying.

I cannot condone that; and I STRONGLY urge you to reconsider. Quite beyond any question of electrical loading, having the cord itself in such close proximity to an intense heat source is a HUGELY risky proposition. TTBOMK, electric ranges are not even supplied with convenience outlets any more, in part for this very reason. Their original intent was to have some handy place to temporarily plug in such items as a small hand-held electric mixer; they were NEVER intended to power a major appliance like a microwave oven (and yes, even your old "700 Watt" model -- which probably actually draws significantly more than that -- would fall into the "major appliance" category, by at least some yardsticks; and what happens when you buy a new microwave?).

2ManyProjects:
FWIW, I'm not going to be PC....throughout all of this you have suggested basically that everything have it's own separate circuit. That is not going to happen here. I'm not going to create 6-8 circuits when they are not needed. Just not going to happen.

I am not saying you must add 6-8 circuits. But if you're going to go to the work of rewiring your Kitchen, why not do it right? If the scope of the job is getting beyond what you feel comfortable with, then defer those "future use" circuits until you actually need them; but DON'T leave major existing problems in place.

Also, WRT your comment that there is "No counter top duplex on S wall; only one outlet on the S wall.": Given your earlier mention that this outlet is located above a small countertop, said countertop really should be served by (and I think code requires) AT LEAST one outlet (preferably a duplex split between two circuits), not counting whatever the refrigerator plugs into. Putting the refer outlet behind the fridge is just simple neatness; plus it makes it less likely for the fridge to be inadvertently unplugged. It's not absolutely required; but it's so easy to do, why not?

So, I will add my 4 circuits and be ok I'm sure.
Thanks for your opinion.

For now, four "new" circuits is more than enough. In fact, you could get away with three, if you put them to the right uses:

-- Two new 20A circuits for the countertop outlets on the North wall (not really "new" circuits, since they replace at least one existing circuit, but still...)

-- One new 20A circuit for the microwave oven, wherever it may be.

-- Extend the first two 20A circuits to ALSO feed a split duplex to serve that "small counter" on the South wall.

-- Repurpose the old South-wall circuit to feed the fridge, moving its outlet box to a hidden/protected location.


 

MrMark

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 25, 2010
Messages
4,626
Location
Southern Cal.
The DW and disp can share one 12/2-20A circuit.

I didn't know that. Thanks for the info. Saves a circuit. Is it prudent?

I am certainly not opposed to the mwbc if done correctly, and from what I've seen every circuit pulled on a typical tract home is a mwbc, but they are often screwed up, mostly by the lower tier electricians doing this for a living. There, obviously, was tremendous lack of understanding in this thread regarding the cancellation of the return current waveforms until you corrected that. So, Petey, do you like mwbc for the kitchen countertop outlets?

How do you set up your 2 circuits for the countertop outlets? Not sure, I have ever seen any really great ideas on that.

I would like to see your kitchen list - circuits and wiring methods for those circuits.
 
Last edited:
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom