oldschoolcraft
Well-known member
What tools, if any, make sense to have corded versions of in 2024 instead of cordless versions? I think this is worth revisiting every few years as technology changes. Eventually, I believe it will almost never make sense to have any corded tools.
It's my understanding that AC power in the USA is capped to 110V / 15 to 20 amps. Whereas battery technology can keep advancing and will be able to deliver more power to the tool than is possible from AC power. Also while it might be possible to increase capacitor technology so the tool can **** up the same 110V/15A and pump it out in more bursts, the market for corded tools is diminishing so there's less market forces to drive research in that field.
For me, I currently have the following tools in corded:
The rest are tools I rarely use, and for my cordless, I have currently standardized on the M12 battery platform. These are tools that dont work too well on M12. I am thinking of adding in M18, which as a home gamer might be overkill. I do think a current generation fuel M18 sawzall has more power than my 10 year old corded sawzall.
The main reason I went with these tools in corded when I bought them between 5 and 10 years ago, is that because I use them so rarely, I was worried they'd become useless when the battery designed changed. I remember back in the 90s and early 2000s, if you had a tool that used a certain battery, a few years later, that might be it for that style of battery and you need new tools.
But where we are now, I am going to guess that M12 and M18 tools with have batteries supporting them available for 20+ years. They're running industry standard cells 18650s and 21700s. If Milwaukee changes their battery shapes and doesnt make them backwards compatible with today's tools, then someone is going to be making retrofit kits, either adapters to use new batteries in old tools or easy ways to put in new cells to old batteries.
I just can't imagine milwaukee ever changing M12 and M18 batteries. There's so many tools on the market now, if they changed today, there would be riots. And if they wait 10 years, there will be even more legacy tools on the market. I think they just keep them the same and come out with backwards compatible batteries with "high output" or other improvements that new tools can take advantage of, but legacy tools can use too, just not to the same benefit of the new tools.
Imagine new battery tech improves and Milwaukee releases the M18 Ultra battery. You can use it in legacy tools just fine, and will even get more run time with the old tools. But the new tools will be 50% more powerful, and will require the M18 Ultras. The new tools will be so good that many people will want to change, and the backwards compatible battery means old users aren't pissed off.
Went off on a tangent there, but at this point, I no longer think M12/M18 will go away in my lifetime, and switching to full battery operated tools seems reasonable even for casual use tools. Unless the tool becomes a "home workshop tool" like an angle grinder you have plugged in to one spot on your bench.
What are your thoughts? What's the use case for corded tools in 2024 and will you ever shift to battery only?
It's my understanding that AC power in the USA is capped to 110V / 15 to 20 amps. Whereas battery technology can keep advancing and will be able to deliver more power to the tool than is possible from AC power. Also while it might be possible to increase capacitor technology so the tool can **** up the same 110V/15A and pump it out in more bursts, the market for corded tools is diminishing so there's less market forces to drive research in that field.
For me, I currently have the following tools in corded:
- Angle Grinder
- Rotary Hammer SDS Plus
- Foredom Rotary Tool
- Reciprocating Saw
The rest are tools I rarely use, and for my cordless, I have currently standardized on the M12 battery platform. These are tools that dont work too well on M12. I am thinking of adding in M18, which as a home gamer might be overkill. I do think a current generation fuel M18 sawzall has more power than my 10 year old corded sawzall.
The main reason I went with these tools in corded when I bought them between 5 and 10 years ago, is that because I use them so rarely, I was worried they'd become useless when the battery designed changed. I remember back in the 90s and early 2000s, if you had a tool that used a certain battery, a few years later, that might be it for that style of battery and you need new tools.
But where we are now, I am going to guess that M12 and M18 tools with have batteries supporting them available for 20+ years. They're running industry standard cells 18650s and 21700s. If Milwaukee changes their battery shapes and doesnt make them backwards compatible with today's tools, then someone is going to be making retrofit kits, either adapters to use new batteries in old tools or easy ways to put in new cells to old batteries.
I just can't imagine milwaukee ever changing M12 and M18 batteries. There's so many tools on the market now, if they changed today, there would be riots. And if they wait 10 years, there will be even more legacy tools on the market. I think they just keep them the same and come out with backwards compatible batteries with "high output" or other improvements that new tools can take advantage of, but legacy tools can use too, just not to the same benefit of the new tools.
Imagine new battery tech improves and Milwaukee releases the M18 Ultra battery. You can use it in legacy tools just fine, and will even get more run time with the old tools. But the new tools will be 50% more powerful, and will require the M18 Ultras. The new tools will be so good that many people will want to change, and the backwards compatible battery means old users aren't pissed off.
Went off on a tangent there, but at this point, I no longer think M12/M18 will go away in my lifetime, and switching to full battery operated tools seems reasonable even for casual use tools. Unless the tool becomes a "home workshop tool" like an angle grinder you have plugged in to one spot on your bench.
What are your thoughts? What's the use case for corded tools in 2024 and will you ever shift to battery only?
