To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Craftsman 3pc Pry Bar Set FAIL

mayhemman

Banned
Joined
May 26, 2011
Messages
310
my dad has that same set bought a couple years ago now. i think the steel has changed because his aren't like that and i know he has used them without care to what happens.

ive used wilde bars and the c man ones that i think are wilde without any issue. i personally bought mayhew and can't be happier with the dominator bars.

i also have a no name bar with a cracked handle, tip on it still fair unless i beat on it with a hammer then it deforms. but better to deform then to break off.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Jim C.

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 8, 2010
Messages
2,598
What's with the huge spider in picture #2? Is that thing real? Did that come with the pry bar set?

Jim C.
 

NC-Fordguy

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 10, 2012
Messages
1,391
I just don't believe that the OP should have his balls busted (not saying you are, but others are) for posting a review of any kind. Whether a member produces something excellent, mediocre or terrible if it's done in good faith then there is no reason to give them grief about it. Disagree, debate sure.

If there are balls being busted, It is a by-product of poor presentation. Quite frankly the OPs presentation isn't what I would call a review. Terms like cheap and **** doesn't set a tone of a review, it comes across of as a bash. Two different things.

A small measure of journalistic tact creates a good review. Unbiased facts that comprise an experience presented in a manner that lets the reader make their own determinations are best.

Say for instance I broke a snappy pry bar. I came on here telling all what an over-priced piece of junk it is and posting pictures of said junk, how well do you think that would be received here?
 

John in OH

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 2, 2007
Messages
2,444
Location
SE Ohio & Eastern Virginia
So, is there any way to identify the actual manufacturer of these C-man pry bars? Were they made by Wilde or someone else? I don't own any Wilde pry bars, but I've always heard that their pry bars were pretty good tools.

I think it would be interesting to find out if these bars were made in USA by Wilde or are they being sold at a discount because Sears changed their supplier to some el-cheapo USA forging company. Just because it says "Made in USA" doesn't mean we don't have some crappy tool manufacturers here.
 

Bull

Super Moderator
Joined
Dec 12, 2005
Messages
16,189
Location
MA
If there are balls being busted, It is a by-product of poor presentation. Quite frankly the OPs presentation isn't what I would call a review. Terms like cheap and **** doesn't set a tone of a review, it comes across of as a bash. Two different things.

A small measure of journalistic tact creates a good review. Unbiased facts that comprise an experience presented in a manner that lets the reader make their own determinations are best.

Say for instance I broke a snappy pry bar. I came on here telling all what an over-priced piece of junk it is and posting pictures of said junk, how well do you think that would be received here?

Maybe I'm too lenient, but I don't hold any member here to any journalistic standards. I see the members here as regular dudes (and a few gals) who spend their free time generating content of varying degrees of usefulness, polish, and accuracy. It's up to me to evaluate it as I would anything else. But first and foremost I respect the common passion of tools, projects, and the eagerness to share.

If a guy thinks something is a cheap *************, that's his business. It's my business to decide whether I agree with him or not. :)
 

cheechi

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
4,384
Location
Triad, NC
I picked up that cman pro set from a few weeks back at the recommendation of several people here. Are they the same bars as this with different handles?

My experience with pry bars is more on the home construction/demo type ones than these. I can beat on a pry bar with a sledge all day and not have the ends look like that. My expectation is that 'a pry bar should be intact after you beat on it' and so from that perspective, if OP was expecting the same thing, maybe its just a matter of experience?
 

bluebolt

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 28, 2008
Messages
5,435
Location
Benton LA
I picked up that cman pro set from a few weeks back at the recommendation of several people here. Are they the same bars as this with different handles?

My experience with pry bars is more on the home construction/demo type ones than these. I can beat on a pry bar with a sledge all day and not have the ends look like that. My expectation is that 'a pry bar should be intact after you beat on it' and so from that perspective, if OP was expecting the same thing, maybe its just a matter of experience?

No, the pro's are mayhews, the regular ones are Wilde.
 

Pumpman1968

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 21, 2012
Messages
1,520
Location
Upstate, NY
C'mon guys.............give the OP a break! All he tried to do was show how the set didn't live up to his expectations....and his expectations are high. He is/was disappointed in the performance of a tool that is supposedly "Hardened and tempered for maximum strength, pry bar claws give you the brute force during a demolition" (from craftsman.com). He believes in the brand of tools he buys (Craftsman stuff all over the pics) and was not happy that they performed poorly.
 

lowbucktruck

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 9, 2010
Messages
1,323
Location
Foothills, Northern California
So, is there any way to identify the actual manufacturer of these C-man pry bars? Were they made by Wilde or someone else? I don't own any Wilde pry bars, but I've always heard that their pry bars were pretty good tools.

I think it would be interesting to find out if these bars were made in USA by Wilde or are they being sold at a discount because Sears changed their supplier to some el-cheapo USA forging company. Just because it says "Made in USA" doesn't mean we don't have some crappy tool manufacturers here.
^^What John said^^... wasn't there news recently about Sears dropping Wilde as a tool supplier/manufacturer? My guess is that the OP has a set of CMan prybars not made by Wilde. I know I would be interested if someone did a test comparison of prybars for durability.
 
Last edited:

d.mcfarland

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
6,566
Location
Western PA
I would guess these bars were Wilde produced units. I have the Wilde branded bar, but haven't used it yet. Maybe someone with very little use on a Wilde branded bar can take a picture and we can compare!
 

Canoe50

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 8, 2012
Messages
234
Location
Rochester, NY
Interesting thread. From what I gather after reading 3 pages, bottom line is no one knows whether these were heat treated improperly or if this what you can expect from this $20 set.
To the OP, I'd take them back for another set & see if the second set holds up any better. That way you'll have a better idea of knowing the answer to that. Then come back with a follow-up review. Just my $.02.
 

MN Falcon

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
252
Location
Minneapolis MN
Thanks for the thread. I just bought a set of 5 Wilde bars from HJE. These will be my first official pry bars. I was a little concerned about the purchase but after seeing how these were used not so much. I think I would have used a chisel to do that job myself because I would have assumed the Wilde bars were not really meant for striking. From all of the comments I would assume these bars will likely hold up fine for some use, but I will definitely think twice about using them like a chisel because they don't look like they will hold up well to this use.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

AmericanPreferred

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2013
Messages
159
I would have no reservations with returning those bars. Any metal pry bar should be stronger than any rubber, or neoprene bushing. I got a set yesterday for $12 after syw points that may go back, the steel is rolling over where they ground the point. Probably just dress them before first use and keep them though. Thanks for the review.
 

MN Falcon

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 31, 2010
Messages
252
Location
Minneapolis MN
I don't think rockchucker used them like a chisel. At least he implied he didn't. I may be wrong.

Sorry, went through everything again and you are right, I didn't pay enough attention to his second picture post and I thought that was what he was really after in the end. That does make a difference then :-( Hope mine hold up a bit better than that.
 

mattamd_xp

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 24, 2008
Messages
161
Location
Springfield Mass
Exchange them for a 2nd set. I've got several sets of Wilde/Craftsman pry bars and none of them have deformed that easily. I'd say a bad set came through. If you get another set and come to the same conclusion, then it is what it is, but I'd definitely give them a 2nd shot based on my experience with them...
 

rasman57

Active member
Joined
Dec 29, 2009
Messages
30
Good job of showing the project and the less than expected perfomance of the pry bars. I think a freaking PRY BAR should be able to do that job without tip failure. It is not like you were putting that tool anywhere near a failure probable situation. Thats the key here.

Remember though, there are lots of different users here......just look at the vise threads and how pretty some of those are. My torch, hammer, grinder, saw, carb cleaner, axle grease and cigar ashes would wreck that pretty vise paint in one week. But thats me. Like to have one of them pretty ones too. Prybars.... They are like drill bits to me, no point in buying cheap unless you KNOW you are well below a damage use situation and you were not abusing IMO. YMMV
 

turdferguson13

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 1, 2013
Messages
195
I know this doesn't have anything to do with the review but using prybars on that job was a waste of time. You already said you have an air hammer. Chisel bit into the rubber and that job would have been done quick.
 

PAPERMAKER

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
73
Location
ALABAMA
Looks like it wasn't hardened correctly to me, here are mine .

20130706_190127_zps7d8ef30d.jpg


20130706_190223_zps50693750.jpg


20130706_190307_zpsf7a5cb48.jpg


20130706_190318_zps2a89cceb.jpg
 
OP
R

rockchucker

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 27, 2010
Messages
1,764
Location
Seattle WA
Pretty tough crowd here. Never in a million years would I have thought this would be the outcome of a review thread. This is a review thread and my experience. I think some that have commented may want to actually READ the ENTIRE post and thread itself.

For the record...I did NOT use the Pry Bars with a Hammer for cutting the Sleeves out of the Subframe. I used the Pry Bars to pry out the Inner Sleeve AFTER releasing the Inner Sleeve from the Rubber by cutting from the top and bottom with a Hole Saw. The larger Rubber part right about the center of the Sleeve is larger than even the holes I cut with the Hole Saw. The Pry Bars were used ONLY to coax and PRY the Inner Sleeve out of the rest of the Bushing itself.

I stated that I have an Air Hammer but I chose not to use it as the COLD CHISEL that I was using to CUT the OUTER SLEEVES out was doing just fine with a regular Hammer and with little effort I may add due to the softness of the Outer Sleeves. I did not use the Pry Bar to try and cut through the Outer Sleeves as that is not what the Pry Bar is designed for. I used the Pry Bars for PRYING not for cutting. The reason for not using an Air Hammer for cutting the Sleeves is due to there being a Shelf or Ledge at the bottom of the Subframe that lets the Bushing bottom out to tell when it is pressed in all the way from the factory. This Shelf or Ledge is not supposed to be damaged and kept in tact for the New Bushings to sit properly. With an Air Hammer you can not feel when you hit this Shelf or Ledge. By Hand Hammering you can feel when you are at the bottom and you can feel when you need to stop as to not damage the Shelf or Ledge at the bottom of the Cup. This is why you can not use a Press in any manner to remove the old Bushings. The Shelf or Ledge on the bottom of the Cup does not allow you to even get at the Sleeves to have something to press against to remove the Bushing as a whole. You must cut them out piece by piece. The first order of business is to remove the Inner Sleeve. You can not remove the Inner Sleeve without first releasing it from the Grease Filled, Sealed Bushing by first using a Hole Saw to release the Inner Sleeve from the rest of the Bushing. After releasing the Bushing you can PRY it out. This is what I used the Pry Bars for. NOT TO CUT THE OUTER SLEEVES!!!!!!!!!!!!!


I would post a link to the ENTIRE project but I don't think that will help as people commenting (or some) are not even attempting to read what I posted in the first place here. Most have lacked even giving me the benefit of doubt that I am not a complete and total *****. That is fine with me. Do not be so quick to judge though as I have never even met anyone in person on this Forum except for my neighbor a few doors down.

Please take the time to re-read the thread if you are going to comment in a negative way about my practices in removing the Outer Sleeves with a Cold Chisel. You can not get at the bottom of the Sleeves due to the Shelf or Ledge obstructing the bottom of the Sleeve. The only way to remove the Outer Sleeves is to cut them from the top until you hit the Shelf and stop. The Cold Chisels I showed were SOLELY to provide the PROOF that I was NOT using the damn Pry Bar as a Cutting Tool. The Cold Chisel that I posted doing the cutting of the Outer Sleeves was merely to show that there was not even a hint of damage to the Cutting Tool that has been in use for MANY years cutting through MANY different Metals. After merely prying out 4 Inner Sleeves mostly coated in Rubber the Tools that I made this thread about were damaged pretty badly considering coming from brand new.


I KNOW that I can redress the Tips of the Pry Bars as this is not my first Rodeo. Come on guys. I am not saying that they are useless. I am not saying they are not worth $20. I am questioning the quality of an American Made Tool advertised doing a more than exemplary job and not cutting the mustard. Am I going to have to do this after every single (what I consider) light duty use? I might and that is where my complaint about the quality of the Tools come into play. Of course they are not going to stand up to my Snap-On Pry Bars. I am not saying they should. I am saying that this seems to be pretty premature wear for the first time use of a product that is held so highly from most of the comments about these particular Pry Bars on this Forum.

On this Forum these Pry Bars have been the "**** of the walk" as far as price to product ratio. I am saying I am displeased with the outcome of the first use. I call them **** because the Steel used IS ****. If it were quality Steel and hardened as advertised then the outcome would have been different. MUCH different.

If ANY that commented saying that I am just using the Pry Bar wrong or whatever I hope that when you go to actually use this same set of Pry Bars they do not hold up to your standards. Then you will see where I am standing. Not that I wish crappy Tools on anyone but it seems to be hard to open closed eyes.

This set of Pry Bars IS going back to Sears. I will swap them out and try again. One reason why I buy (or used to buy) Sears Tools. If I am not satisfied they can be returned for new or refunded. Who knows...Maybe this set just did not make it through the hardening process. The purpose of this thread was to warn/inform people of my experience with the Tool. If I get another set I will use them also. If the outcome is the same then my thread will be validated in my own eyes and you are free to have your opinion on your particular set of Pry Bars. On THIS particular set of Pry Bars the Steel is sub par to say the least.


Jhhhheeeeeeeeeeesh....:sad:
 

thesilverone

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 25, 2008
Messages
3,805
Location
Taxachusetts
how many 3 piece sets have been purchased from the people of this forum? Lets say 1000 sets have sold from GJ. This is the 1st "failure" I can remember reading on here. So 1 out of 1000 is 0.1% equals 99.9% yield rate. Pretty damn good if you ask me.
 

cheechi

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 29, 2012
Messages
4,384
Location
Triad, NC
Since this isn't your first rodeo, I think it's fair to point out that someone who already owns Snap On pry bars would only get Craftsman pry bars (USA or not) to beat on.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom