I could not get the discounts to stack either. The manager I originally spoke to was about to manually take 10% off and give me the Craftsman Club pricing, but could not guarantee that the order would go through when it was sent to the local store for pick-up.
So, I called back and spoke to another manager and she processed the order with the VIP 10% discount and advised that I should show my Craftsman Club card at the time of pick up and have them credit me the difference. If that doesn't work, I just want the Craftsman Club pricing, it's still less than what I'm currently charged - stupid Sears.
I'll follow up when I go to pick up the items - I'm not that optimistic.
FWIW, I was trying to buy the following:
1. 59614/5 Craftsman 11 Drawer Ball Bearing Combo with Griplatch
1a. Member Price: $499.98
1b. With an additional 10% off = $449.98
1c. What I got charged: ($299.99-$30.00) + ($249.99-$25.00) =
$494.98
Result: $45.50 over 1b, $5.00 less than Club straight price 1a
2. 59126 Craftsman Professional Floor Cabinet, Full Shelves
2a. Member Price: $239.99
2b. With an additional 10% off = $215.99
2c. What I got charged: ($299.99-$30.00) =
$269.99
Result: $55.00 over 2b, $30 more than Club straight price 2a
Actual Items Total: $764.97 (1c + 2c)
Craftsman Club Total: $739.97 (1a + 2a) <-- I would have been better off with this price
Ideal Total: $739.97 - $73.99 =
$665.97 (CCTotal - 10%)
Hung