To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Dear Sears (5 years from now)

Status
Not open for further replies.

cburnscrx

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2013
Messages
1,751
Location
Indianapolis
Re: Dear Sears(5 years from now)

I doubt sears will be gone in 5 years. They will restructure their operation and be better. don't think the US Govt want to see 140,000 people loose their job. Shoot they did not want to see a cash bleeding company like GM go under, they will not want to see a retailer that employs 100K+ people go under.

And the bailout is why I won't buy any GM product made after 2008.Must be nice to run a company into the ground through years of ineptitude and idocracy and get money from the US taxpayers. :dunno:

*for the record I won't buy any Chrysler product, but that's a whole different reason. Haha. :eyecrazy:
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

ctb

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
1,121
Location
Central Europe
Re: Dear Sears(5 years from now)

Yeah,eventually Chinese labour costs will rise enough to make uneconomic the making of cheap products. Quality will have to improve in their remaining operations as the price will be higher, and the price spread between their product and a quality US made simular product will be much less.

So, will Craftsman then still continue to produce their tools in China? Hell no!
They're a corporation out to make the biggest profit they can. They'll set up shop in a much cheaper third world country. What's left, Eastern Europe? No, wages are higher than in China. Middle East, too unstable. North Korea, now that would be something. :lol_hitti

Only place left is Africa. Imagine picking up a Craftsman ratchet and seeing "made in Nigeria" :eyecrazy:

Fact of the matter is most of you guys are microwaving the wrong cat (sorry Willis!) All the other big US companies that set up shop in China have strict quality controls over their products, and they are made to the precise specifications laid out by the company. The fact that Craftsman manufactures poor quality tools in China is by choice, not an accident of manufacture. They probably looked ahead and saw that in the foreseeable future car repair will be totally out of the range of the home mechanic, so why continue to produce quality tools just to bolt shelves together. Their reputation was made in the late 50's, 60's and 70's when it was still possible for most people to work on their own vehicles, and their tools were actually used hard for that purpose. Fast forward 40 years to vehicles manufactured for a life span of 10 years and its not hard to see that not many people will be fixing their own cars anymore. :sad:

We can moan all we want, but like they said in 1971 or so when smog controls were introduced, "the good times are over".
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
ctb there is some logic there with the tools, craftsman departure form their professional line is really a prime example of that. While it was never a money making line. They uses to have buyers for it. But I can see that buyers of that line drying out as not to many people really have the time or capability to work on newer cars.

But I do not think that the craftsman tools are poor quality. They are way nicer then anything HF sells. And their cordless c3 and nextec line are actually decent consumer grade power tools that is not really a one time uses tool like most the HF stuff. Most craftsman tools were bash on even back in the 70's, 80's and 90's as they were not pro level and were joke on as being not as good. But they work and were backed by a great warranty.

Jump to 2013, the warranty is still there. While allot of tools are made overseas. They are still good quality tools. As a home owner that will turn a wrench every now and then, for what you get with craftsman is still a tool that is made well for that market buyer.

All this craftsman bashing if just members wanting to feel good about buying a consumer grade too. Craftsmans are not snap on, matco, wright, proto, or cornwall, that the industrial buyer and pros buy. Members want a USA made tool, pay the price for a USA made tool. Because I never saw member consider craftsman USA made industrial or professional until they were super discounted. They are tool cheap to go buy a 150 dollar 13 pc USA made craftsman professional. But at 70 dollars they are all over it.

Craftsman RP are their base model. They go for about 40 dollars for a 12 pc set when not on sale, 25-35 dollars when on sale. There is nothing special about them when they were made in the USA, they were short, uncomfortable, but they worked. Same with their RP ratchet. And I doubt anyone here can show data that they fail at any high rate then the US made ones that uses to get criticized all the time.
 

Fixnfly

Banned
Joined
Jan 26, 2013
Messages
784
Location
S.W. PA
I don't know where the craftsman ratchets come from but when they break I just put in the scrap pile. I have a few with the metal direction switch but the ones with the plastic switch are not worth replacing.

Last week I bought a Napa gold air filter for my truck. I usually pay attention to the country of origin and this filter came from Poland of all places.
 
Last edited:

ctb

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
1,121
Location
Central Europe
But I do not think that the craftsman tools are poor quality. They are way nicer then anything HF sells. And their cordless c3 and nextec line are actually decent consumer grade power tools that is not really a one time uses tool like most the HF stuff. Most craftsman tools were bash on even back in the 70's, 80's and 90's as they were not pro level and were joke on as being not as good. But they work and were backed by a great warranty.

By poor quality I meant poorer quality than when they were produced in their heyday. But back then they weren't so great either. I remember Craftsman sockets slipping and rounding off bolts on suspensions. That's when I got smart and got Snap Ons and Grays for 1/2" and 3/8" drive. Much better sockets. The Craftsman ratchets were tough though.

Never cared for their screwdrivers, I bought a set of Snap On and there was a big difference in grip. Now having tried Wiha I wish I had bought those over the Snap On! Live and learn I guess.

For me the crunch came in the early 80's when I bought a set of flare nut wrenches and the first time I tried one it opened up on the end and rounded the nut. That was when Sears Canada started to sell imported (Chinese made) Craftmans. I haven't bought another Craftsman tool since.

But yeah, getting back to where I started, people are starting to look back on the made in USA craftsmans with a reverence they don't really deserve.
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
That is the part I do not get this reverence for a consumer grade tool, just because it had this made in the USA stamp on it. But they would not go buy the higher price and quality line of the same brand.
 

ctb

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
1,121
Location
Central Europe
That is the part I do not get this reverence for a consumer grade tool, just because it had this made in the USA stamp on it. But they would not go buy the higher price and quality line of the same brand.

The Craftsman mechanics tools were only one line (until recently, I guess), with no higher or lower grades. The craftsman woodworking tools had varying grades, ranging from terrible, to just being usable (compared to others like Delta or Porter Cable.)
 

shoturtle

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
4,395
Location
Frankfurt AM
They had their pro lines back in the 80's, they were nicer then the RP wrenches. I brought the pro adjustables with the black over the gold sleeve, and their black screwdrives. And they had the pro full polish metric and sae combo wrenches and flare wrenches. Never made a pro sockets and ratchets though.
 
Last edited:

ctb

Well-known member
Joined
May 8, 2011
Messages
1,121
Location
Central Europe
They had their pro lines back in the 80's, they were nicer then the RP wrenches. I brought the pro adjustables with the black over the gold sleeve, and their black screwdrives. And they had the pro full polish metric and sae combo wrenches and flare wrenches. Never made a pro sockets and wrenches though.

Can't remember seeing those on offer in Canada. By then all we were getting was chinese made. The Canadian Craftsmans went to **** 20 years before yours did.
 
Last edited:

terry603

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 17, 2011
Messages
377
sears knows how much tools they sell each year and you can bet they make their business decisions by the results,not by letters to them that get written

they also know if changing coo has helped or hurt their sales. we can only guess at our end

remember tools in the big picture are a part of the pie in their total sales,not the lifeblood
 

garthg

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 8, 2012
Messages
535
Location
Winchester MA
Sears Used to Sell Really Good Stuff

Here's proof:

IMG_0015_zps4846f767.jpg


Made in Germany. Hardened stainless steel.

The closest I could find currently are Mitutoyo, for $91.

(I paid $40 for a Kennedy box that had these, a Snap-on F723, some machinist gauge blocks, good quality U.S. SAE open end and Allen wrenches, etc.)

If you want good tools these days, it's pawn shops, estate sales, ebay and Craigslist.
 

camino01

Member
Joined
Feb 12, 2014
Messages
5
Yo solo compro herramientas hechas en Mexico y en USA, ya que me ofrecen calidad y garantia, y nos dan trabajo en sus fabricas, No soporto la mala calidad de las herramientas Chinas.
 

MackMan

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 25, 2012
Messages
648
Location
Lexington, NC
So so true. As long as the tools works and is of decent quality and it is simple for them to warranty. The sears customer will continue buying their tools. And for the value thing, compare to other economical tool options, they really can not be beat when comparing their tool set options. They are a better deal then kolbalt or husky. While HF is cheaper, their tools are not as good quality as Craftsman, Husky or Kobalt.

There is just way to many sears basher on GJ.

I have actually found the opposite. The new Kobalt I have seen as well as the "Pittsburgh Pro" line from HF are both far nicer than Craftsman, and HF is much cheaper. Actually the HF stuff is generally made in Taiwan vs China for Craftsman. When Craftsman turned into a more expensive lower quality version of HF I decided to go elsewhere... i.e. Snap-On, or if I need cheap, then HF.
 

ozyborn

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2011
Messages
685
I buy what I like. If you are selling foreign made tools then I will not shop there. I do not need the professional grade made from solid gold by the price lines. A lot of my Craftsman is 40 years old and still in great shape. Toss in a tron of Williams super wrenches and I am fine. Snap-On? Way to pricey. HF? Junk is junk.
 

rweaver

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 1, 2012
Messages
75
Location
SW MI. wine country by the lake
I can not believe the amount of people that don't care where things are made. I will not get into all the politics of this discussion but only to say that you will someday care and its coming fast!!!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

brownbagg

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2006
Messages
5,208
i bought a craftsman roll bottom box , monday, cardboard said, made in U.S.A. the toolbox itself said, made in china
 

d.mcfarland

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 18, 2012
Messages
6,566
Location
Western PA
The warranty and ease of warranty is a big selling point. But let's not forget how many sales Sears gets from people gifting!!
 

blaynefossati

Member
Joined
Sep 7, 2013
Messages
12
lolol,ok im gonna get flamed for this.Many of the craftsman tools my dad passed down to me that were made in the us got broken in the first couple of months of me putting them through everyday use.Now that they switched the manufacturing plant the tooling has gotten better,I know its chinese which is dissapointing but the overall quality of the new Craftsman stuff is BETTER.Another thing,have you guys ever looked at the price of cman tools?leafspring juice rediculous!might as well by my stuff off of the so truck.

Blayne
 

volaredon

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 7, 2012
Messages
1,617
Location
IL
I have read thru (so far) 8 pages of this thread. and it brings out a ton of different thoughts and feelings that have developed over 40-some years of life, starting out from being dragged to Sears by my parents from the time I could walk (I don't remember anything from my youngest days in a stroller LOL) for everything from tools to lawn mowers to clothes and paint, car parts, and even food... remember when they had restaurants within the stores and candy counters, too?
Then a couple years after high school (late 80s) I got a job in the Auto center and spent 13 years working for Sears between 2 different locations (I got married and moved)
heck I even met the woman that turned out to be my wife for the past 20+ years (and counting) in that little restaurant within the store, she also worked there (albeit in another department) and like me was "on break"...
I don't shop there anymore either but for different reason. Between my wife and I we put up a combined 25 years working there.... the refusal of Sears to allow either of us full time employment even back then (meaning 2 jobs was absolutely required to get by) the cutting of benefits throughout our employment, low wages (even for 80s standards) and their way of scheduling the hours we did get, to maximize "coverage" for their store without regard to convenience and/or "costs of having that job" for their employees...
like in my wife's case... when our son came she was bringing home $100/week.... she had to work 5 days, anywhere from 3 to 6 hours per day, about 25 hours a week. You had to have been there since the 70s to have hope of being a full timer even back then... my wife started in 84 and I started there in 87
We both went to her boss and asked if she could have those 20-some hours a week in 3, 8 hour days so that we could spend less on babysitting and gas so she COULD be there, and was told "no, sorry... store needs come 1st". Her check was $100, we spent $60 on a babysitter (if she could have done the 20-some hours in 3 days worked that would have been like $35) and $20 on gas so that meant she worked 25 hours for a net payday of $20.... not worth having the job.
and in my case I got fired (only place in my life that ever happened) because I wanted to take a couple of used tires for my own personal use... tires that they never sold to anyone anyone anyways, and in fact PAID a firm for each semi load that was hauled away... yet if a customer wanted their own used tires back they had to give them back... I took them outside and wound up leaving them behind and still got fired, screw them while others did the same and more, with quite the blind eye....rules only applied to a select few

have not spent a dime there since late in 2001.... I cancelled my Sears card and when asked "why" I told them it was because if this was how they treated employees who'd given them so much for so many years, I could get anything I needed in life elsewhere. (the actual statement I made at the time was way more colorful)
but also I could see the demise coming way back then. By that, I mean the difference in the quality of stuff they sold when I started definitely declined over the years I worked there... something I saw 1st hand, daily, as I passed thru the stockrooms. and yes even though I worked there and (at the time) got a pretty deep discount on tools I needed for my job (beyond the regular 10% employee discount) I got tired of having to go back to th sales floor to exchange busted sockets and 1/2" "impact" universals that would break all too often while I was doing an alignment on YOUR car... and yes it definitely became a much more frequent occurrence later in my days of working there than it had been years earlier. We always had a Mac and a Snap on truck come by and it was there and then that I discovered 1st hand that "there is a difference" was much more than just a marketing slogan for Snap on. As the years went by I found myself dumping my Crapsman for Snap on much more often
Yes it was easier for me than most to go exchange a busted tool (I just had to walk from the auto shop to the tool department) it was happening all too often. I remember a time in the 80s when a lot of the box/open end/combination wrenches sold as Craftsman were made in Japan. and I didn't buy any though my Dad did to replace an errant one here and there that went missing at home.... after my firing I'd just throw busted Craftsman in the trash and replace it at garage sales and flea markets with more Craftsman... just don't buy it at the store any more. Craftsman has been great for "home use" but day to day making my living with, some of it just has never held up "for me". brand new sockets that would slip and round where a Snap on would grip and turn, that sort of thing.
I have still walked thru and browsed over the years since my employment came to an end... and have to say this for Sears "quality" as a whole (not just tools)
Somewhere on GJ there was a graph showing how fast inflation doubled prices... (I think it was in a thread that had to do with the cost of building a garage now vs 5 years)
take that graph and turn it upside down, and that's basically how their quality has gone
and the years shown at a given inflation point pretty much matches the rate of downturn in quality.
I remember when Kmart (before they and Sears were one) and other retailers were thought to have "cheap ****" as compared to what Sears sold... back in the 70s when I was a kid. but nowadays, even that "cheap ****" from those days, is better than mainstream products available today, at higher cost than then.
I remember even in the last 5 maybe 10 years of the old Sears Catalog where they'd list 2 versions of a product and in the description of each they'd tell whether the product was USA or "Imported" I think that was even 20 years ago. You had so much more choice back then of what you could buy than now a days. and hold both in your hands and the difference was obvious. Take something new today vs something from 30-40 years ago and its the same thing. the older stuff being well made and the newer stuff being worthless ****

Id rather buy a 30 yo power tool from a garage sale than most anything built today. Cheaper for me to buy and will still be working when that product that my neighbor bought brand new last week, is in the landfill.

also back then when a switch on Dad's drill went bad (from being dropped too many times or what ever) I could go to Sears and order that switch and fix it. Now a days if that switch is even available, they charge $50 for it when a whole nother drill is what, $55? but now a days things are made so that if a simple component breaks you gotta destroy the rest of it to get at that simple component... used to be, a switch for that $55 drill might be like $5.00

Lastly... for the 1st time since 2001, instead of throwing away broken Craftsman tools that I had "accumulated", I went to my local store to try and get some old tools warrantied. Things like extensions that the sockets fell off of, wallowed sockets, worn out screwdrivers, etc. most of what I took in was US made but OLD and well worn, that I'd gotten a whole lotta use out of. some was stuff my Dad had bought in the 60s and 70s. Mostly all they had to offer to replace them with was China made and just looking at it you could tell a difference... and unlike back then over 1/2 of what I brought in had to be ordered. Their claim was that it would be shipped directly to my home. Well that was like last April and there are things I still have not seen show up here... that is no way to retain or regain an old customer...they just do not give a **** any more
 
Last edited:

Threadkiller

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
165
Location
Dutchess County, NY
Good Thread/prediction OP. I stopped going to Sears for my tools once they outsourced their stuff overseas. If I am getting lower quality Chinese **** I might as well pay less for it at Harbor Freight. I feel like now Harbor is getting better and their prices are still low and craftsman stuff is still higher priced even though sears is basically out. That being said, I still have all their American made sockets and a couple ratchets and wrenches that have served me well for about fifteen years now.
 

Thirdyfivepickup

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 15, 2016
Messages
1,940
Location
Portage, Indiana
Dear Sears:
As you now know you made a mistake in the past that could have been avoided if you listened to your customers who bought your tools for many years instead of the bean counters wanting profit. The reason we bought your tools was they were made in the U.S.A. and were priced fairly. They were not Cadillac tools from a truck but just good quality everyday tools that worked great, were dependable and put Americans to work in your factory. We didnt buy cheap import tools from overseas because we were supporting jobs here with the purchase of yours. Seems to me that if you would have increased the price and cut some overhead and told the bean counters to leave well enough alone the tool division would be a prime example of supporting american workers. The price would still be less expensive than the truck brands and be good quality.
So I am sorry that after so many years you have to liquidate the tools manufacturing and sell out to the Overseas concern.
Maybe its time to go back in time to 2013 and re-evaluate whats is more important to Craftsman and return to the "MADE IN AMERICA" labeling that built the company and impacted so many lives, young and old. There are lots of citizens needing work and this would be a great oppurtunity for YOUR future.
Heres hoping I wont have to look you up in history books instead of on the shelves.
I am available for in person opinions. Just look me up at the nearest mechanic,air conditioning,plumbing,carpentry, home garage anywhere in America.


PS If you listen to this you might survive another 100 years... or you may only last until the end of 2018...
 

Smoker

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 4, 2009
Messages
167
Location
San Antonio
Interesting read. Sear did indeed sell off Craftsman and is in its death throes as a viable company.

I have a mix of tools, seems most brands now have lifetime warranty so i find myself buying from Lowes or Home Depot unless its a specialty tool. China is making quality and the likes of Walmart and Amazon have trained people that 'price is king'.

Let's look in another 5 years.
 

brownbagg

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2006
Messages
5,208
but you cant warranty things forever, a business need return customers to survive
 

openwheelracing88

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 10, 2015
Messages
266
Dear Sears:

If you listen to OP then you will definitely close the doors. Those are the guys still hoping they can buy "quality USA made" tools at bargain prices. They are not realistic.
 

drwheels

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 12, 2011
Messages
1,999
Location
okla. city ok
Dear Sears:
As you now know you made a mistake in the past that could have been avoided if you listened to your customers who bought your tools for many years instead of the bean counters wanting profit. The reason we bought your tools was they were made in the U.S.A. and were priced fairly. They were not Cadillac tools from a truck but just good quality everyday tools that worked great, were dependable and put Americans to work in your factory. We didnt buy cheap import tools from overseas because we were supporting jobs here with the purchase of yours. Seems to me that if you would have increased the price and cut some overhead and told the bean counters to leave well enough alone the tool division would be a prime example of supporting american workers. The price would still be less expensive than the truck brands and be good quality.
So I am sorry that after so many years you have to liquidate the tools manufacturing and sell out to the Overseas concern.
Maybe its time to go back in time to 2013 and re-evaluate whats is more important to Craftsman and return to the "MADE IN AMERICA" labeling that built the company and impacted so many lives, young and old. There are lots of citizens needing work and this would be a great oppurtunity for YOUR future.
Heres hoping I wont have to look you up in history books instead of on the shelves.
I am available for in person opinions. Just look me up at the nearest mechanic,air conditioning,plumbing,carpentry, home garage anywhere in America.
It is not the tools that are the problem. Look at ceo who cares only about himself.
 

Hubscrub66

Well-known member
Joined
May 24, 2017
Messages
107
Location
Tennessee
5 years later..... Craftsman is now Stanley/Black and Decker owned and sears/k-mart (sears holding corp) is hanging by a thread. Sad:(
 

amkluttz

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 8, 2014
Messages
279
Location
Concord, NC
...I stopped going to Sears for my tools once they outsourced their stuff overseas. If I am getting lower quality Chinese **** I might as well pay less for it at Harbor Freight. ...

This! I went to go get a 22mm wrench to change an O2 sensor. Everything else I own is Craftsman so I thought I would keep all the tools looking the same even though I knew they weren't USA made anymore. I want to say it was something like $14 for a single 22mm wrench at Sears. You can buy the entire set for that at Harbor Freight. I ended up going to Home Depot around the corner because you can't buy single wrenches at my Harbor Freight. I think the total was in the $3 range.

I wouldn't mind paying more for a USA made Craftsman but if they are all made in China and all have a lifetime warranty I might as well buy the cheaper wrench.
 

carotene

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2015
Messages
107
Location
Washington, DC
Sears may bleed out and die. We'll see. GM would've went bust in '09 if not for the bail-out. Countless other American brands have seen their demise over the last 20yrs.

The world is getting smaller by the day. Our current political climate leans toward blaming "others" for our poor,unfortunate plight. I grew up in the 80's and 90's. Mary Lou Retton, the space shuttle, Springstein, Top Gun. Days when we were still riding high from post WWII exceptionalism, prosperity and economic expansion. It could be argued that a significant slice of the population believes those days can be reclaimed whole cloth, if only we put up some convenient barriers.

Guess what folks, the rest of the world is catching up! They're not to blame for wanting more. Wanting what we have enjoyed for 50+ years. Since when do we as Americans give up? Point fingers? Claim "we can't compete"? So let's throw up barriers???

How about we man up and go head first into the global economy? Invest in trade training programs, leverage automation and technology, bolster our service sectors. I'm sick of the "woe is me" attitude. Seize the day!
 

Handyandy23

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 8, 2017
Messages
1,523
Location
Ontario, Canada
Those that argue for buying "American made" at all costs, I'm curious, is this just your opinion for tools, or does it apply to everything? What kind of car do you drive and where was it made? What about your computer and TV? Or the clothes you're wearing on your back right now? One of the loudest posters in this thread from 2013 made mention of his 'beloved' Volvo imported from Europe, while chastising people for not buying a wrench made in the US.

The biggest trend I notice is most of the "buy US made" folks are those directly affected by manufacturing jobs. Obviously if you've worked in manufacturing you have a much more vested interest, but it just comes down to how it affects your own situation. Lots of talk about the morality of Chinese manufacturing when you think it's disadvantaging you personally, but no one really gives a darn about any other social or moral issues that don't directly affect them, like gender/racial inequality, factory farming, etc.

Unemployment is steadily dropping in the US, and is as low as it's been in years, so it's not like the whole country is going down the tubes. Times change and the type of work is going to transition.

Maybe Sears / Craftsman quality dipped earlier in Canada than it did in the US, but I have no nostalgia for the brand. In my lifetime here it's always been an overpriced hobby grade product that didn't return good value. I could get the same quality for less from Canadian Tire (no HF here so not sure what that's all about) or much better quality for a few dollars more on the better brands if you do your homework.
 

couch67

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 18, 2016
Messages
1,400
Location
Ontario Canada
Sears was officially dead in Canada just this week. Stores started to close last year and the plug was pulled on 14-Jan.

Over the years it became one of those stores that you would never buy something full price - wait till the weekend and get it for half ! (crappy tire is not far behind in that respect)
 

isb cornbinder

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 3, 2010
Messages
7,073
Location
Pacific South West, BC, Canada
sears closing I cannot say I am surprised about here in Canada. Sears forgot about us decades ago and we forgot about them shortly after.
I have a few prized Sears tools and toolboxes from 50 years ago.
My first rolling bottom and top tool box came from Sears. It was a gift from my Mother for graduating from trade school. I still have it, for not other reason than it is still in use. It will go on Craigslist, like so many other things, if it gets in my way.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom