Hi,
We don't test or compare our products to competitors products so not really sure how to answer that, and we generally don't comment on competitive products. The little we do know, ours seems to work in a similar fashion as a thick resurfacer, and the products seem to all be in the same acrylic family. The product being very thick covers up the old, splintered wood, and gives many years of new life to an old deck. The other issue is that all manufacturers of coatings have had to remove many of the ingredients that made outdoor coatings last a long time, hence it's almost impossible to manufacture coatings for decks and outdoor use that last a long time so this product has seen tremendous growth as people don't want to keep repainting every 2-3 years.
We really don't know how other's make theirs. We know ours works well and we have many thousands of satisfied customers!