Dewalt 10amp or 12 amp reciprocating saw

[Yankee]

I just purchased the 10amp saw, but I see there is a 12amp saw for just $10 more. I will not be using this professionally, but I do want quality tools. Is there much of a difference between the two? I've used underpowered tools in the past and I don't want something that doesn't really perform, however since it will be lightly used, would I even know the difference..

Thanks in advance for you opinions.

 

[Gotcha640]

I have the 12 amp, primary use is breaking up pallets, also used on small trees when I didn't have a chainsaw handy, and rough curves when I didn't have a jigsaw handy.

If it catches on a nail in a pallet or a knot in a branch/piece of lumber, it will try to tear my arm off. For casual use, I expect the 10 would be fine.

On the other hand, unless it's significantly lighter, why not go for the 12?

 

[Yankee]

It's 2lbs lighter (7lbs vs 9lbs)

I've already got the 10amp home, was wondering if it's worth taking it back.

 

[bcradio]

I would avoid DeWalt corded reciprocating saws myself. I have heard a number of issues with them. I would get a Milwaukee or Makita myself.

 

[PoorOwner]

http://m.homedepot.com/p/Milwaukee-12-Amp-SAWZALL-Reciprocating-Saw-with-Case-6519-31/202438078

Just get the Milwaukee they still have it with a little discount right now
You can't go wrong. Also the blade is probably more important than the tool itself.

 

[Coach James]

A 10amp recip. saw is not underpowered unless you are cutting a battleship in half. If it is comfortable in your hands, I would be fine keeping it.

+1 on getting good blades and the right blades for the job.

Coach

 

[nieuport17]

I went through the exact same debate myself a few weeks ago. I went with Dewalt mainly for the ease of flush cuts. I have lots of dead small trees. Between the 10 and 12 amps, I pulled the trigger on 12 amps from home depot.
Mainly because its only $10 more and I could use all the power I can get.
Dewalt's saws are known for their vibration, so the sooner I finish, the better...
I used Diablo 12" and 9" for my project, and after I was done, my hands were sore.
Depends what you use for, 10 amp might be enough.