To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Did you ever broke impact socket?

brollona

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2019
Messages
70
Location
floating arround
Anybody ever broke or wore impact sockets?

I have impression that this is not common thing. Maybe I'm wrong, but I see treads about quality (or lack of quality) of CrV sockets while I never seen people complaining on impacts. I newer used them too much so only time I manage to make some damage was when I used them for punching some stuff into bore or bearing on shaft. Rare occasions when I didn't had any other option.

Opinions, experience, pictures?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

2ndGearRubber

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 24, 2014
Messages
14,185
Location
Pittsburgh
They break, and wear out, that's life. I broke a few HF, a sunex or two, and blew up a gear wrench universal (straight factory defect IMO). I've snapped pins on Cornwell impact universals adapters, and gotten regular universal impacts basically frozen from hammering at an angle; the pinless ones can have the spring collapse and get all loosey-goosey to the point of being dangerous. Eventually your common sizes start to wallow out, and they'll need replaced. They're softer metal by design, and you're running them with a pneumatic tool repetitively.

I use mine to make a living, YMMV obviously.
 

RTM

Well-known member
Joined
May 13, 2019
Messages
13,084
Location
SF Bay Area
Back in the late 70s we broke an impact socket, workin on the front end of a used car. Think doing a CV joint. Broke a regular socket, Craftsman, so got a free replacement, and bought an impact at the same time. Got home, put the breaker bar back on, put the pipe cheater back on, and broke the impact socket too. Was back at sears within 2 hours to replace it. Salesman had never replaced an impact before.

Forgot how we finally broke it, but I think it was the Vessel impact driver that finally worked.

Still have the Vessel, but think Dad included the socket with the sale of his bike shop a few years later.
 

bwringer

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 1, 2013
Messages
10,253
Location
Indianapolis
This site is apparently full of mountain gorillas who break tools daily, so warranties are the only consideration when buying tools.

I've never broken an impact socket. I have seen them get a little loose and wallowed out after long use - as mentioned above, that's partially by design.

The only sockets I've broken were very low quality stuff being badly, horribly abused and misused. I've also seen cheap impact sockets that were obviously just un-chromed "normal" sockets.


That said, some tools, like screwdrivers, driver bits, and u-joints, should be regarded as consumables. They wear under normal use, and they cannot be expected to hold up very long under heavy impact use.

There's also some older stuff that just isn't ready for a world with monster 1,200 foot-pound battery-powered impact guns. The foot-pound arms race has gotten silly in the last five years or so.

Some people apparently expect to buy one #2 Phillips screwdriver and use it every day for the rest of their life then pass it to their children and grandchildren.
 
Last edited:

Bogie1632

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 18, 2018
Messages
1,303
Location
Southeastern Wisconsin
I've worn out a few when I worked in a tire shop. Got sloppy in the drive from constant use. Broken quite a few reducers and u-joints though. It happens. Beat on anything long enough and its bound to wear out or fail.

V/R
Bogie
 

jgromada

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 13, 2011
Messages
1,017
Location
Maryland (between DC & Balt)
I've only broken one socket and that is a chrome Craftsman 14 mm socket. I used it with an impact and it was clearly my fault.

Replaced by Sears back in the day under warranty, i lied when i said i hadn't abused it.
 

lolaetype

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 11, 2019
Messages
2,077
Location
North Western Arkansas
I once twisted the squared end off of a cheaply made 3/8" extension. I never broke a socket, but a few of the mechanics I knew in a truck repair shop regularly turned standard Craftsman sockets into tulips by using them with impact wrenches.
 

The Fall

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 20, 2016
Messages
419
Location
Austin, TX
I've worn out a few when I worked in a tire shop. Got sloppy in the drive from constant use. Broken quite a few reducers and u-joints though. It happens. Beat on anything long enough and its bound to wear out or fail.

V/R
Bogie

That's been my experience.
 

908Jim

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 1, 2013
Messages
555
Broken countless pinned flex impacts. The design is inherently weak and they eventually fail with time. On the flip side, I've never broken a regular impact socket. The difference, in my opinion, between high quality and low quality is how they wear when in service.
 

Elbert C.

Active member
Joined
Feb 3, 2013
Messages
30
Location
North AL, USA
depends on your level of work, if you are a mechanic for any duration of time you will have seen some broken impact sockets, of all brands, even when used properly. They do and will break, no its not common, but does happen.
If you are a DIY person and use tools casually for small projects you may never see an impact socket break, depending on the quality of tools you use and the power of your impact gun(s). The better quality stuff does not break that often, whether it has hair-line cracks, or the tool shatters or has an otherwise hard failure.... $$$$ does happen and will happen.
 

Mgdoug3

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 2, 2018
Messages
1,391
Location
KY
I split a Napa 15/16 impact using my Milwaukee once. Went to Napa and they replaced it. Only downside was that the replacement wasn't made in the USA like the original one.
 

Downwindtracker 2

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2019
Messages
1,715
Location
BC
I've never broken an impact socket, even when we have reduced a 1" gun down to a 1/2" drive socket. The reducers have broken though.

A funny story. In the mill I worked in the 3/4" and 1" were company tools and as such walked. So being annoyed with this, I bought a couple of common sized super cheap Princess Auto chrome sockets, 1 1/2" and 1 5/16". That 1" impact did a number on them. I still have the Proto replacements, chuckle.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Downwindtracker 2

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2019
Messages
1,715
Location
BC
I've never broken an impact socket, even when we have reduced a 1" gun down to a 1/2" drive socket. The reducers have broken though.

A funny story. In the mill I worked in the 3/4" and 1" were company tools and as such walked. So being annoyed with this, I bought a couple of common sized super cheap Princess Auto chrome sockets, 1 1/2" and 1 5/16". That 1" impact did a number on them. I still have the Proto replacements, chuckle.
 
Joined
May 14, 2020
Messages
24
Location
Kansas
I once broke an impact socket when trying to pull lug nuts off a Ford Aerostar. The nut was so rounded that I had to hammer on a smaller mm impact socket to get it off and it split in the process but didn't explode luckily. Obviously my fault.
 

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,053
Location
Southeastern Pa
The Snap On 19mm & 21mm thin wall lug nut impacts seem to break a lot, seems to me to happen more on the electric impact guns then the air guns...............
I Also 21mm and 16mm a lot pounding on Volvo frame bolts and my 2 11/16" pinion nut impact socket a couple times too, but it too was a thin wall to fit into the yoke.
 

DugT

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 5, 2020
Messages
51
Location
Truckee, CA (6000' Sierra Nevada Mtns.)
This is irrelevant but I bought an electric impact wrench kit with a few sockets and a case for $30 from Kragens about 20 years ago. Two sockets cracked after about 30 bolts and then the wrench itself disintegrated. (On the other hand, I have a 50 year old Dremel Moto Tool that still works fine. It needed a part a couple of years ago and parts are still available for it.)
 
OP
B

brollona

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2019
Messages
70
Location
floating arround
Thanks for the info guys. My sister's kid is doing wrenching on motorcycles (well, mostly scooters so far) and he has aspiration to become pro. He bought some cheap corded electric impact pistol that came with some ****** sockets and I thought to buy him real impacts. That's when I started thinking if there is point to buy some good brand or cheapest Taiwan. If he's gonna carry them arround to his pals and lost them one by one than I don't want to spend big money.
 

Wrench97

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 23, 2018
Messages
12,053
Location
Southeastern Pa
Gray pneumatic or Tekton impact sockets make decent starter sets both have blow molded cases that make it easy to spot missing sockets if he's traveling around with them.
 

lardy1

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 17, 2019
Messages
3,393
Location
Michigan
Thanks for the info guys. My sister's kid is doing wrenching on motorcycles (well, mostly scooters so far) and he has aspiration to become pro. He bought some cheap corded electric impact pistol that came with some ****** sockets and I thought to buy him real impacts. That's when I started thinking if there is point to buy some good brand or cheapest Taiwan. If he's gonna carry them arround to his pals and lost them one by one than I don't want to spend big money.


For the first time in my life I recommend Harbor Freight.
 
OP
B

brollona

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2019
Messages
70
Location
floating arround
Sorry guys, I didn't aim for specific brand just general opinion since I live in Europe. Choice here is not so diverse at the lower price point. We don't have tekton and similar brands that offer cheap decent tools. But I'll find something.
 

Mr_B

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 21, 2016
Messages
5,374
Location
Reading
In over 30 years I doubt I broke more than 3 impact sockets and those were extreme abuse on stubborn fasteners and high powered air impacts beating and heating scenario .
impact extensions and uj's are the common breakages .
You will wallow out impacts drive end and broach to point they no longer wise to use but you won't bust many not even cheaper ones around 2-3 bucks a piece when bought in sets .
I had more success with good manufacture effort crv over recent years vs crmo, truck brand got returned as they deforming as current trend on lot of bigger names is softer socket for safety concerns/less liability risk .
crmo is no indication of a better socket, crv is just as good and it all down to exact quality of base stock and any extras added to it and most importantly heat treatment process .
Generally a bit of due diligence on looking at manufacture effort in design and final coating along with how the sockets marked gives good idea on likely quality level .
Laser etching is pretty much a waste of time on impacts in pro use or over decades of time . Only reason it become popular is far easier setup style/size/logos and less machinery/production costs over roll stamping .
Those who do roll stamping and bold laser etching useful but larger roll stamping would be far more useful long term .
Most of the visual better effort off brand taiwan tend be pretty decent alloy and good heat treatment thus last well and nice to use due to stepped shouldering, relief cuts and lead edge tapering etc .
Buy him something mid range and preferably with available singles as easy replace a lost one .
Life warranty of no real benefit, they that cheap it better to self warranty as self cover includes everything such as loss and theft plus you get replacement you want and in timespan needed .
In 30 years I not replaced enough tools make the extra cost of truck tool warranty viable expenditure or that useful on basic hand tools .
Now MAC's life warranty on drill bits, carbide burrs and dies etc has been useful ...

If you in europe look at japan style, jubilee tools, toptul, welzh Werkzueg, premier, expert, britool hallmark perhaps ...
 
Last edited:

ovilla

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 18, 2005
Messages
2,342
Location
Plainfield, IL
I was in a bind (had loaned out my impact sockets to a friend) and decided to just buy some Impact sockets while shopping at Menards - don’t recall the name of their in-house tool brand. Anyway, the 19mm socket looked nice and thick walled but literally exploded while I was trying to take off my second lug nut. After that I promised myself to never buy cheap tools again. Just not worth getting hurt (physically or financially) by having to replace tools.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
 

Jazz1

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 3, 2016
Messages
4,184
Location
Thunder Bay On.
I’ve split cheap,,real cheap impact sockets from a set I bought long ago. I’ve shortened a few to keep using them
 

richfinn

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 29, 2011
Messages
4,809
Location
Leeds, Yorkshire, England
I keep breaking those 17mm plastic sleeved impact sockets on VW/Audi wheel bolts fairly regularly, they are thinner walled than regular impacts for the protective sleeve

Consumables for us, they are softer than regular sockets so they dont shatter, usually just split down the side. We can just order new ones from the company (I carry a spare)

Wore quite a few out on air impacts when I worked in the garage
 

plinker

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 28, 2007
Messages
4,286
Location
Northern Wi
I've managed to split/crack these in 3/8 deep Napa/Sunex, 9/16, 3/4, 21mm, 18mm. All got very heavy use. I also broke a 9/16 ADV low profile socket, kinda split right in half. Also broke a GP 1-3/4 3/8 extension. This is from '08-ish to the present date, so not really common but does happen.

The 1/4 & 3/8 drive impact sockets I have are not nearly as thick as the 1/2 drive in comparison, so that may be the reason why. They're really not much thicker walled then chrome sockets (which is a plus IMO). If/when one breaks it can be taken care of without much issue.

I have yet to have a problem with any 1/2 drive impact sockets, normal wear is a separate issue. Impact grade bit sockets are their own story.

I would say just about any impact socket from Taiwan will be a good socket.
 

dmaxfireman

Well-known member
Joined
May 12, 2019
Messages
190
Location
CT
Never broke an impact socket, but I broke a 1/2in snap on impact extension a few years back. It broke right at the female end where the anvil goes in.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom