To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

DIY smoke machine for finding vacuum leaks?

brockstar

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
244
Location
Cincinnati
Howdy,

I've been wondering about and searching the internet for a smoke machine. I have an old Audi that has to have a vacuum leak. A smoke machine sounds very appealing to source, but being cheap, I don't want to spend $800 or more buying one. I'm not so interested in the propane or card cleaner methods.

I found this write-up but not much else:
http://forum.e46fanatics.com/showthread.php?t=445181&highlight=diy+smoke+machine

Thoughts, suggestions?
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
OP
B

brockstar

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
244
Location
Cincinnati
Nope. Engine wont start and isnt developing enough vacuum to raise the metering plate in the fuel distributor.

That and I want a smoke machine without having to pay much for it :)
 

Mike83

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2008
Messages
2,156
Location
Wisconsin
I need a smoke test too. I think I have an engine vacuum leak and also a small leak in the EVAP system. No point in throwing parts at it, plus don't want to pay $75 or so for a shop to test it. I'll let you know if I find anything.
 

Tarheelgarage

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 14, 2008
Messages
3,865
Location
NC
The problem with a homebrew smoke machine would be pressure control. It needs to be no more than 2psi or there is a risk of blowing out seals.

BTW, I have the Redline Total tech machine in my shop. Makes a lot of money finding the leaks plus saves time.

You would be surprised all the leaks a car will have.
 

Blacknwhitepit

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 19, 2005
Messages
3,176
Location
Eastern Tennessee
From a prior thread.

Hi

I had to replace 3 rubber flex lines on my jeep that go to the exhaust vapor canister. I was getting the dreaded check engine light on for a slow emissions leak. Anyway, I found 1 bad tube, replaced it but couldn't find the other leak which the dealer was able to. The service guy said they have a "smoke test" tool. I assume this means they have some sort of compressed smoke which leaks out and you can see where the leak is? My question is, is there a back yard mechanic version of this?

I replaced the worst tube for $3.60. The shop charged me $126.00 to do the other 2. Now granted I could have done all 3 but wasn't sure if this was the problem.

Any info appreciated.

Piper

Yes,

There is a "back yard mechanic technique". I did it to find my exhaust leak and later a vacuum leak. I went to a party shop and bought a Party Smoke machine for $29.99.

This is one, but it is more expensive:

http://www.diamondlakerental.com/images/FogMachine.jpg

I put a Rubber hose on it and then reduced or increase it to the size of the orifice I was testing. In this case an exhaust. I ran the smoke through the tail pipe and voilla! smoke came out of my exhaust donut location, not the exhaust manifold (like I expected). The fog juice runs about $8 a quart and lasts a while. This fog machine is even fun to have around for holloween. And this stuff runs on the same fog stuff that the expensive machines use!
To find a vacuum leak, just make sure the car is not running and hook it into the intake manifold (I used the intake manifold vacuum connector that goes to brake booster, it is usually a pretty good size.) Blast the smoke thru and you will see it come out of the leaking hose!


For an even more backyard way(and this is for a vacuum leak) is to run the car and use an unlit propane/butane torch. When the vacuum ***** it up you will hear an audible increase in the vehicles rpms and can "pinpoint" leaks that way.

-BWP
 
Last edited:
OP
B

brockstar

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 14, 2008
Messages
244
Location
Cincinnati
Thanks!!

One question, I understand these burn a glycol or a mineral oil solution - would there be a concern with residue if I use this in a vacuum line?

I'm picturing everything getting coated internally and anything that come out of a broken line getting oily. But I'm probably exaggerating it in my mind..
 

rhandwor

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 10, 2008
Messages
1,366
I have found a lot of vacuum leaks on intakes and other areas. I use a can of carb. cleaner and spray along the edges of the intake if you hit a leak the engine will smooth out.
 

m302483

New member
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
1
Has anyone tried this on EVAP lines? I'm assuming that this work work just as well if I modify somethign to pump the fog in to the filler.

Thanks
 

Mike83

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 24, 2008
Messages
2,156
Location
Wisconsin
Has anyone tried this on EVAP lines? I'm assuming that this work work just as well if I modify somethign to pump the fog in to the filler.

Thanks

I would be concerned that if the fog is water based that you would get condensation/water in the tank and ruin your gasoline. I wonder too since I have an EVAP leak.
 

norry

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 3, 2008
Messages
543
Location
Out of my mind... Be back soon!
I have found a lot of vacuum leaks on intakes and other areas. I use a can of carb. cleaner and spray along the edges of the intake if you hit a leak the engine will smooth out.

Ether's probably better than carb cleaner for this - it evaporates very quickly, so it shouldn't cause any lasting damage to rubber. Spray a l-i-t-t-l-e at a time; you don't want to have a big, explosive cloud of ether hanging around in the engine compartment.

Worked like a charm in diagnosing a bad intake manifold gasket on an old E30.
 

glasses97

Member
Joined
Dec 17, 2009
Messages
5
I am in the process of completing my smoke machine. It is every bit a functional as the professional models. I made the body out of 2 pieces of 3 inch diameter abs sewer pipe, a coupling, cap and a clean out. I used utility box covers for the plates inside that the wick mounts too. I used 18 inches of heating wire from an old dryer element, I wound the wire into two coils (9" each) around a 3/4 inch bolt to form them. My prototype only had one wick but I was getting carbonization of the top part of the wick. I got two wicks from those outdoor torches 7/8 inch diameter by 8 inchs long. I used a propane regulator to control the pressure. I just grabed it off an old bbq at the dump. The requlate the pressure to aprox 11" water column, mine puts out about 13 in wc. If you want to have a adjustable pressure get a regulator off of a disposable propane cylinder. They are usually adjustable from 5" to 17". You want around 13" water column. I also used the orifice off of the scrap bbq and drilled it out to 3/32 of an inch to limit the flow of the smoke. I found if I had to much flow it picked up an oil mist and carried it with the smoke. I used a chunk of clear tube to make a u-tube manometer. It is a very accurate way to measure water column it also serves as a relief valve. If the regulator fails it will blow the water out of the u-tube and vent the system, saving the cars systems. A flow gauge can be obtained from omega.com for just under $100, I have not purchased one yet. If you do go with the flow gauge (rotometer) you can also purchase orifices to "calibrate it for the differents size leaks" very cheap from a pneumatic store. I will posts some pics on line in the next few days for anybody that wants to see what it looks like. The total cost without the flow gauge is under $40.
Almost forgot, my system is powered from a old computer powersupply at 5 volts and about 5 1/2 amps.
 

Papawrench

Member
Joined
Dec 10, 2009
Messages
5
Location
Knoxville,Tn
Ur answer is that it doesn't matter because u need a scan tool to close the vent valve or it will dump right out into the air u won't actualy get the evap system tested at all
 

Toolhorder

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 9, 2009
Messages
5,711
Location
Montana
Ur answer is that it doesn't matter because u need a scan tool to close the vent valve or it will dump right out into the air u won't actualy get the evap system tested at all

There are ways around that. A power probe and a hose clamp tool.
I never used a smoke machine at the dealer and hardly ever used the factory tool. We had a model that had a problem with the filler tube leaking. I used to stuff rags into a rubber glove and stuff it into the top of the tube and use a vacuum tester for the bottom and see if it held or not to test them.

I'd like to see the plans of the guy above who built a prototype. I want my own.
 

Joelfke

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
1,837
Location
Mt Holly, NJ
I need a smoke test too. I think I have an engine vacuum leak and also a small leak in the EVAP system. No point in throwing parts at it, plus don't want to pay $75 or so for a shop to test it. I'll let you know if I find anything.

any chance you have a late model GM car or truck? the vent valves in those die and crack all the time. I just had to replace mine in my 04 monte carlo. Not saying to throw a vent valve at it just saying its a common failure
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Joelfke

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
1,837
Location
Mt Holly, NJ
I would be concerned that if the fog is water based that you would get condensation/water in the tank and ruin your gasoline. I wonder too since I have an EVAP leak.

the screen in newer gas tanks / fuel pumps allow for gas to only be pulled through even if there is water in the tank. unless all you have left IS water...then it will **** the water through
 

Joelfke

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 31, 2009
Messages
1,837
Location
Mt Holly, NJ
I am in the process of completing my smoke machine. It is every bit a functional as the professional models. I made the body out of 2 pieces of 3 inch diameter abs sewer pipe, a coupling, cap and a clean out. I used utility box covers for the plates inside that the wick mounts too. I used 18 inches of heating wire from an old dryer element, I wound the wire into two coils (9" each) around a 3/4 inch bolt to form them. My prototype only had one wick but I was getting carbonization of the top part of the wick. I got two wicks from those outdoor torches 7/8 inch diameter by 8 inchs long. I used a propane regulator to control the pressure. I just grabed it off an old bbq at the dump. The requlate the pressure to aprox 11" water column, mine puts out about 13 in wc. If you want to have a adjustable pressure get a regulator off of a disposable propane cylinder. They are usually adjustable from 5" to 17". You want around 13" water column. I also used the orifice off of the scrap bbq and drilled it out to 3/32 of an inch to limit the flow of the smoke. I found if I had to much flow it picked up an oil mist and carried it with the smoke. I used a chunk of clear tube to make a u-tube manometer. It is a very accurate way to measure water column it also serves as a relief valve. If the regulator fails it will blow the water out of the u-tube and vent the system, saving the cars systems. A flow gauge can be obtained from omega.com for just under $100, I have not purchased one yet. If you do go with the flow gauge (rotometer) you can also purchase orifices to "calibrate it for the differents size leaks" very cheap from a pneumatic store. I will posts some pics on line in the next few days for anybody that wants to see what it looks like. The total cost without the flow gauge is under $40.
Almost forgot, my system is powered from a old computer powersupply at 5 volts and about 5 1/2 amps.

id LOVE to see it
 

stioc

Well-known member
Joined
May 2, 2005
Messages
1,317
Location
SoCal
I'd love to see some DIYer friendly vacuum leak finders (smoke or electronic). To me the troubleshooting skills and tools is what sets you apart from the avg Joe with a socket set.
 

Todd.Brock

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 15, 2008
Messages
4,250
Location
Cincinnati
Brockstar is my brother and heres the funny part.. I dragged that damned Audi out of the shop 3 months ago b/c I was tired of pushing it on and off the lift!!! That and it was possessed. I found it on CL for 200 bucks. The guy was moving, it just stopped running, yada yada. WE were looking for a project and the car was in super great shape. Other than the system he had installed to get it to run on water. The Hydrogenator or something or another. I didnt take him too seriously about that. So we drag it to the shop and work for weeks trying to get it started. Finally give up after a couple months and push it around for a year until it was time to go. 300 at the scrap yard was just the ticket....At least for my sister-in-law!! I think Eric is still stuffering from crushed audi syndrome....
 

JTHill524

New member
Joined
Dec 27, 2012
Messages
1
I know this is a Old Thread but I come up with a very easy Smoke Gun. There is two problems I see to making ones like in this thread.
One you need a air source to push the Smoke
Two you need a Power Source to produce the Smoke.
Will I found that there is something already made to do that & with a little Mods I think it will work Perfect. A Multi-speed Hair Dryer with a Low Heat switch.

Open it and Clip the High Speed & High Heat wires so only the Low & Slow switches work.
Take the screen off the heater & lay a piece Lantern wick on the coils. Then put a extended piece of pipe with a piece of Steel wool as a Filter. Put a cap on the end with a connector for a rubber hose.
On top over the heating coils drill a hole & install a Oil Dripper to keep the wick wet.
Turn on the Coils when you see smoke flick on the low fan.
Check for leaks.................

I was looking at this one...... http://www.walmart.com/ip/Remington-Damage-Protection-Ceramic-Hair-Dryer-1ct/17470846

What you think?
 

DW-Caterham

New member
Joined
May 3, 2013
Messages
2
Location
Worcester, UK
Hi,

I have a couple of old smoke/ fog machines for diagnostics which work really well, but they don't have their original instruction manuals. If anyone has instruction manuals for a:

Vicount smoke machine/ Fogger
Colt Smoke machine/ Fogger
Phantom Smoke machine/ Fogger

...let me know. I'll happily pay for a copy/ scan, or the real thing!

Dave
 

Maxvision

New member
Joined
May 22, 2013
Messages
1
Want a REAL cheap smoke machine for finding vacuum leaks? Go get yourself a lighter, a cheap cigar and a few feet of vacuum hose. Light the cigar and blow the smoke through the hose at possible leak locations.

Also works in reverse. Blow the smoke through vacuum lines and see where the smoke comes out!
 

shampoop

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 12, 2009
Messages
1,947
Location
SW Washington
asffASFD.jpg
 

6 Grrrs

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 29, 2008
Messages
143
Location
Greensburg, PA
Sorry to drag up an old thread. I was watching Wheeler Dealers today and they were using a smoke machine to diagnose a wind/water leak into a cabin of a vehicle. I started searching google and found this thread.

Could I use a $40 fog/smoke machine to do this? My first concern is that if the fluid used is glycol based, that it may damage interior panels.

I have 2 vehicles I want to diagnose. 1 for wind and the other for water leaks in the firewall.

Any assistance is appreciated.
 

oldDat

New member
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
3
can you put mineral oil into a fog machine that's supposed to use glycerin and water?

do you think mineral oil would/could mess up the cat converter or the charcoal canister?

which do you think is better to use for smoke test? glycerin and water, or mineral oil?
 

oldDat

New member
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
3
to JTHill524
did you ever actually make your hair dryer smoke blower?
details please......
 

oldDat

New member
Joined
Oct 12, 2014
Messages
3
I don't know how to use this forum yet.
did u make your hair dryer smoke blower?
work good?
details?
 

JAKE-THE-TOOL-MAN

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 20, 2010
Messages
1,157
Location
Bremerton, WA
Although this is a really old thread If you do some searching around on here you will find a write up on building a DIY smoke machine. IIRC MechanicNamedJohn built one and posted about it in his HF tool box thread.
 

shampoop

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 12, 2009
Messages
1,947
Location
SW Washington
Want a REAL cheap smoke machine for finding vacuum leaks? Go get yourself a lighter, a cheap cigar and a few feet of vacuum hose. Light the cigar and blow the smoke through the hose at possible leak locations.

Also works in reverse. Blow the smoke through vacuum lines and see where the smoke comes out!

+1 works great for most diy situations!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom