To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

drive in or back in your garage?

Drive in, or back in garage?

  • Drive right in

    Votes: 77 42.3%
  • Back right in

    Votes: 75 41.2%
  • Gimme beer

    Votes: 30 16.5%

  • Total voters
    182

SALIV8

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 11, 2008
Messages
2,114
Location
chicago and s/w michigan
I see so many of our neighbors drive in their garage. My wife, and I, back in so we're facing out.

What about you guys? I would think backing in is safer, as you can see traffic coming down the alley..
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

Stevie-Ray

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 23, 2013
Messages
2,894
Location
Michigan's Sunrise Side
Drive in. Backing out is easy, as I use the rear camera to see where I'm going, back into an area in front of the house, then drive out the rest of the way to the highway.
 

Danver

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
159
Location
Upper Peninsula of Michigan
I back in simply because my attached garage is on the left side of the house and backing in puts my door facing the man-door going into the house. If I pulled in forward I wouldn't have room to walk behind my truck to get in the house, and when leaving I would have to open the garage door before I could even get in my truck. By backing in I can be in the vehicle and ready to go before I have to open the garage door and let in the weather.

If the garage was on the right side of the house I would pull in forward for the same reasons.
 

stikman56

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2014
Messages
3,127
My daily goes in a carport, I back in. I also back into parking spaces, much easier than pulling in , because you can't see easily to the sides when you leave. Backing is second nature for me after so many years of it with very large vehicles. Garage, usually pull in for two reasons, one it's always hard to go from daylight into a dark building until your mirrors get in the building and also exhaust fumes are much greater when your pipe is at the back wall.
 

rsanter

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 22, 2007
Messages
18,521
Location
visalia ca
Drive one in and back the other in
I have a full sized crew cab truck that I back in. I have more room to get out between the cars then

Bob
 

RVDan

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 9, 2011
Messages
2,213
Location
North America
Since I have only a couple inches on either end of my car with the garage door closed, I have to back in to be able to get out of my car and into the house.
 

Throbbin Rods

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 17, 2013
Messages
801
Location
Lebanon, NH
Back in , for same reason I back in to parking spots and leave a car length in front of me in traffic. If the poop hits the fan and I need to beat feet I don't have to fart around, just push the loud pedal and go.
 

Jarhead0408

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 1, 2012
Messages
5,740
Location
Who knows?
Ah, I should've known.

I drive in, but not into my garage. I drive in my shop. I actually don't have a "garage" that stores vehicles. I could see having a garage for the wife, but I'll keep my 3-bay shop.
 

kamlung

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 29, 2011
Messages
141
Location
North NJ/NYC, USA
and also exhaust fumes are much greater when your pipe is at the back wall.

this is why I don't back into my garage... the door to the house is on the back wall of my garage so i'd be blowing exhaust fumes against that door...

any other space outside though, I back in...
 

tdkkart

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
6,887
Location
Eastern Iowa
DD car gets driven in, truck doesn't get driven often but gets backed in for quick exit when responding to volunteer ambulance calls.
Wife can barely get the car in going forward, let alone backing in.
 

wssix99

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 2, 2011
Messages
5,161
Location
Chicago, IL
The engineering answer is that generally, a car with front wheel steering should always pull in to spaces forwards. (If you have a rear wheel drive vehicle, like a forklift, you'd want to pull in backwards most times.)

[pause inserted while everyone flames out about this...]

There are no absolutes in life, so depending on the situation, (access to vehicle compartments, sight lines, weather, street one is pulling on to, etc.) the answer may be different - or different on different days.

BTW - This rationale is the same for parking spaces. Standard parking spaces are designed by engineers for cars to pull in straight, which allows them to be smaller - cramming more cars in to a lot.

The reason behind all of this is the steering/wheel geometry. The rear wheels (on a front wheel steering vehicle) take corners much more tightly:

corneringwheels.jpg


In the extreme situation, (parking space) a normal "backed-in" car has to pull out of the space further (and in to traffic more) before the rear fenders/corners can clear the space as the rear wheels make a tighter corner coming out. For a "pulled-in" car, the car doesn't need to pull out in traffic as far when coming out because that problematic tight rear turn starts happening once the rear is out of the space. (This also reduces the need to do a 3 point turn.)

Of course, for a garage, this issue isn't as severe if there is a long driveway leading up to the garage. However, the rear swinging thing may come in to play at the end of the driveway, depending on how much space there is, how much you love your mailbox, etc.


I don't recommend believing everything on the internet, but this stuff can be calculated:

ctangles.jpg


If you are like me and gave up complex geometry a long time ago, the concept can be tested with a toy car with steering. (It's a lot easier than risking the fenders of a real car!)
 
Last edited:

mikechicago

New member
Joined
Dec 8, 2014
Messages
4
The engineering answer is that generally, a car with front wheel steering should always pull in to spaces forwards. (If you have a rear wheel drive vehicle, like a forklift, you'd want to pull in backwards most times.)

[pause inserted while everyone flames out about this...]

There are no absolutes in life, so depending on the situation, (access to vehicle compartments, sight lines, weather, street one is pulling on to, etc.) the answer may be different - or different on different days.

BTW - This rationale is the same for parking spaces. Standard parking spaces are designed by engineers for cars to pull in straight, which allows them to be smaller - cramming more cars in to a lot.

The reason behind all of this is the steering/wheel geometry. The rear wheels (on a front wheel steering vehicle) take corners much more tightly:

corneringwheels.jpg


In the extreme situation, (parking space) a normal "backed-in" car has to pull out of the space further (and in to traffic more) before the rear fenders/corners can clear the space as the rear wheels make a tighter corner coming out. For a "pulled-in" car, the car doesn't need to pull out in traffic as far when coming out because that problematic tight rear turn starts happening once the rear is out of the space. (This also reduces the need to do a 3 point turn.)

Of course, for a garage, this issue isn't as severe if there is a long driveway leading up to the garage. However, the rear swinging thing may come in to play at the end of the driveway, depending on how much space there is, how much you love your mailbox, etc.


I don't recommend believing everything on the internet, but this stuff can be calculated:

ctangles.jpg


If you are like me and gave up complex geometry a long time ago, the concept can be tested with a toy car with steering. (It's a lot easier than risking the fenders of a real car!)

I'm seriously impressed by this explanation. Nicely played.
 

Thumper68

Well-known member
Joined
May 16, 2013
Messages
5,134
Location
Duluth MN
I Have always been taught that backing in is safer than pulling in unless it is a pull through where you would never have to back up.

I tend to back vehicles into the shop since I have my box by the door, but if I am working on the *** end of a vehicle only I will pull in forward.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

evildky

Well-known member
Joined
May 1, 2005
Messages
774
Location
Louisville, KY
I back in my GF drives in. My garage is narrow and this allows us to have more room in the middle for loading unloading etc. Downside is when we go together one has to pull out before the other can get in. Even if space weren't an issue I'd prefer back in, I drive a truck and you got to get a lot more truck out of the garage before you can see what's coming down the alley, I don't have much of a driveway to to back out blind isn't ideal for me.
 

ixlr8

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 15, 2009
Messages
435
Location
Mid-Coast Maine---> Eastern Shore Virginia
I drive in, Mrs. backs in. I have never hit anything, she has several scratches/dents in her car from hitting things... which she blames me for because I left something out. How do you not see a wheelbarrow at the entrance to the garage??
 

tdkkart

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 17, 2006
Messages
6,887
Location
Eastern Iowa
The engineering answer is that generally, a car with front wheel steering should always pull in to spaces forwards. (If you have a rear wheel drive vehicle, like a forklift, you'd want to pull in backwards most times.)

[pause inserted while everyone flames out about this...]

There are no absolutes in life, so depending on the situation, (access to vehicle compartments, sight lines, weather, street one is pulling on to, etc.) the answer may be different - or different on different days.

BTW - This rationale is the same for parking spaces. Standard parking spaces are designed by engineers for cars to pull in straight, which allows them to be smaller - cramming more cars in to a lot.

The reason behind all of this is the steering/wheel geometry. The rear wheels (on a front wheel steering vehicle) take corners much more tightly:

corneringwheels.jpg


In the extreme situation, (parking space) a normal "backed-in" car has to pull out of the space further (and in to traffic more) before the rear fenders/corners can clear the space as the rear wheels make a tighter corner coming out. For a "pulled-in" car, the car doesn't need to pull out in traffic as far when coming out because that problematic tight rear turn starts happening once the rear is out of the space. (This also reduces the need to do a 3 point turn.)

Of course, for a garage, this issue isn't as severe if there is a long driveway leading up to the garage. However, the rear swinging thing may come in to play at the end of the driveway, depending on how much space there is, how much you love your mailbox, etc.


I don't recommend believing everything on the internet, but this stuff can be calculated:

ctangles.jpg


If you are like me and gave up complex geometry a long time ago, the concept can be tested with a toy car with steering. (It's a lot easier than risking the fenders of a real car!)


Which is all fine and good, but in the real world most people can barely FIND their car in the parking lot, let alone deal with the geometry involved with parking their damned car. Have you watched people try to negotiate a simple parking spot??
 

nolimits76

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 11, 2013
Messages
959
Location
Oklahoma
In my 2 car bay, I drive in. Primary reason is I park on the far right and have a 4x4 Ram truck that is a space hog. I hug the right wall so I have more space to get out in the middle.

Wife parks next to me, and no way I trust her to back in, lol. Not only that, but we actually have 2 man doors in our garage so it's both natural to exit on the left of the car and walk to the man door (located on left) -- although in fairness I tend to use the far entry door more often than the one closest to my vehicle.

Right now my 3rd car bay houses a zero turn and other projects. If I were to park a vehicle there I would back in because of logical access to the man doors. Come to think of it, I even back my zero turn in.
 

Steevo

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 18, 2009
Messages
8,738
Location
43.49600, -112.04300
It depends.
At my last two homes, my wife pulled and I backed in, because space was narrow and I could get up against the side wall to have safe door clearance between cars.
At my current home, we have enough width to both pull in straight, side by side and have sufficient clearance between cars. I do back in when we come home with groceries, just so they are close to the inside house door for unloading.
I back my truck in the third stall, as it is very narrow and I have to get it just so to clear the right mirror while I fold in the left one.
 

steve308

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 20, 2011
Messages
2,075
We have a long uphill driveway and it's easier to back up the hill into the garage than to back out down the hill. Also when it's snow and ice covered much easier to see where your going to run into the ditch going out of the garage forward.
 

mikeyr

Well-known member
Joined
Sep 16, 2005
Messages
1,971
Location
Santa Barbara, CA
have to drive in. I park under my lift and the car is wide, only a few inches to spare on each side and absolutely no rearview visibilty, it has to be driven in.

Before the lift I always backed in.
 

wssix99

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 2, 2011
Messages
5,161
Location
Chicago, IL
Have you watched people try to negotiate a simple parking spot??

Yea - especially the ones who have a hell of a time backing in! lol Another thing that would be solved by everyone pulling in straight is rear fender dings. I never park next to people backed in because their front doors ding the heck out of my fenders.
 

Danver

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 24, 2012
Messages
159
Location
Upper Peninsula of Michigan
Which is all fine and good, but in the real world most people can barely FIND their car in the parking lot, let alone deal with the geometry involved with parking their damned car. Have you watched people try to negotiate a simple parking spot??

I just saw this one posted elsewhere yesterday. Advanced warning: It is extremely frustrating to watch this level of stupid.

http://gawker.com/q-is-this-guy-still-trying-to-get-out-of-a-parking-lot-1668100854


Same video in case the first one doesn't work:
 

DodgeMech

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 17, 2012
Messages
1,858
With my Tacoma pickup(w/backup camera), I back in....
With my wife's Camry, we drive in...

i know the new taco's have gotten bigger since my 02, but i really hope you don't need to use the camera too much...these lil trucks are made to get around trails super easy...which lends itself to city driving too...

either way, my spot at work, i back into, and when i rarely do go into the garage, i pull in...door to the house is on the left when looking into the garage
 

Silver Heels

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2011
Messages
126
Back in- when you are running late for work and finally open the garage door only to find 6 inches of fresh show on your uphill driveway, you'll know why.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom