Got sidetracked but think I tracked it down to one of these models, I'm thinking the G-2593.
Took it apart and one of the cups was old and crumbling (shown below).
My two questions:
1) What the hell is going on in the bottom of the cylinder where the piston sits.
2) Would the blue cup I bought work fine as a replacement even though the old cup has a very square shaped indent/journal in it, while the replacement blue i bought seems to be more curved. (I don't know what to call what I'm describing- its the shape of the area missing from the cup, the trough if you will). The old one could just be deformed from age. They have the same ID, OD, and thickness besides that.