Steve in MI - chill out bro - It's a forum of ideas and experiences dude (or do your freinds say 'douche'...

).
Check the forum RULES:
- We are all here to help eachother. No kidding. If someone asks for help, don't go calling them stupid. Also don't go knocking other people for what they have or want in their garage. Basically if you don't have anything nice to say don't say it. What is nice about your reply? I haven't called you stupid nor have I knocked anybody for what they have or want in their garage - where do you get this stuff. I only asked a couple of questions. I gave my experience of using Great Stuff foam, it has worked well for me and I thought others might benefit from the information. I didn't tell anybody they should use it. You are the one telling folks not to use foam giving reasons 'moisture degrads it' and 'not water proof' - I know those are not true characteristics for Great stuff so I was interested to know why you would make such claims immediately following my post about Great Stuff. I concluded (since you didn't say what foam you used) that you had used some other foam. I asked what foam, hoping to learn about the foam you tried and found unfavorable. Having worked in foams research for a number of years I'm interested to learn from others experiences etc.
I had already mentioned the problem with UV and Great Stuff and covering with UV stable material. I asked for clarification on the type mastic you were talking about because at least a couple had been mentioned up to that point. NEWS FLASH - NO MENTION OF RUBBER SEALANT (until now) - humm.
My personal experience was stated as: "I wouldn't use foam..." meaning the spray expanding foam because, I've seen it degrade when I used it between my the foundation and wood on my cottage. After a season in the sun before covering it it turned yellow and brittle. As for what I called "mastic", it's a rubber sealant that was used between my driveway and the cement block foundation and was just installed at my neighbours - best stuff I've ever seen - hardens just enough, but allows a little movement, is waterproof and doesn't shrink away.
As for copper in airlines...how would you know what my previous experience is?
You said so. All you have to do is read some plumbing manuals and bone up on the burst pressure of solder under heat. Do some homework: educated people don't get so mad!!