What I don't understand, if you bought two new openers i'm asuming from the same place, why they have different Sensors? The only Genie sensors I can recall that only had one light were from much older units.
Here's a few things I've run across. 1st I would check all your wiring.
Sensors out of alignment
Staple in wiring
Depending on how close your doors are, I've seen the sensors interfere with each other. Disconnect the wires to the sensors that are working, see if the light on the other stops blinking. If it does then just remount one set up or down.
I doubt it's sunlight, that would only last a short time. Good luck!