Hey Everyone, my name is Dustin and I live in St. Joseph County Indiana. We recently purchased an old farmhouse built in 1900 on four acres at an auction. It didn't have a garage, so we purchased one with the plan of getting it built by winter (now). Currently, I cannot get a permit to build my detached garage, because the county doesn't have any records of my septic system. The county started keeping records of septic systems in 1974-6 I believe the lady said. I know that my septic was built around the 50's, because of the color of the piping. The lady at the health department informed me that an inspector had to come out to my property first before issuing a permit for the garage. I asked her the purpose of the inspector's inspection and she replied that he just needs to probe the area underneath your garage and then ten feet around the outside of it. Just to be sure it wasn't being built on or around the septic system. I asked her again after that, so the ONLY thing he has to do is come and probe underneath my garage and the ten feet? If it's not on or around my septic, then I can get a permit for the garage? She responded word for word, "Yes. The only thing he is going to come and inspect is the area the garage sits on and the ten feet around it. So please have the garage properly staked out for us."
I wasn't worried at that point, just annoyed in the time delay. The company couldn't place my custom garage order until I sent them the permit. I knew the septic system was on the North side of the house and the garage was going on the South side of the house; roughly 20 feet from my ground well. The garage didn't have any plans for electricity or plumbing in it. Just the shell itself with a crushed limestone surface. Absolutely nothing to do with my septic system, but I understood that for their records, they just needed to be sure it wasn't going on top of it. I then scheduled a time for the one inspector that does these inspections to come out. We weren't living there yet, so I met him out there. What the lady told me ended up being the furthest thing from the truth and this guy immediately starts in on my septic system.
The property is four acres and the back property line to the West runs along a creek. It's nothing but farming country so the creek basically has either fields up next to it or the back of someone's property line. Unless it rains or snow is melting, there isn't much water in it at all. The health inspector is refusing to give me a permit to build the garage until he runs a dye test to make sure that my septic isn't running into the creek. At that time, I had no freaking clue if it did or didn't. The creek is roughly 150 yards from the house and the house sits probably 50 feet higher if not more above the creek on top of higher ground. There is one pipe coming out of the creek bank on our property. Another one that is just on the other side of our property line to the North. One semi newer light blueish/green one and a bigger, older galvanized corrugated pipe. Like a culvert looking pipe, but maybe a foot wide only. Between the house and the creek used to be an old barn and such around it. I know there are field tile systems setup down there to drain the rain water into the creek. I have physically seen water coming out of that pipe when it's wet. The other pipe looks like it hasn't had anything run through in a long time. The neighbor told me that someone informed him the corrugated pipe was only hooked up to field tile systems to drain water. The only pipe that he is going to check for dye for is that blueish pipe, because at the time he came out, water was flowing out of it. We weren't even in the house using any water at that time, so I know it was draining the mud holes full of water from previous rain.
I'm sure it is, because the government can get away with anything, but is this even legal? Do I have any legal grounds to stand on when fighting this dye test? It has absolutely zero to do with my garage and obtaining a permit for it. I can see if I was trying to add a bathroom or something to the actual house, but this is ridiculous. If he did a dye test and it did in fact run into the creek, we would need to buy a new system and it would have to be a mound system. That's $30,000-$35,000 that we don't have. We put everything we had into the house and obtaining a home loan for it. If we had to purchase a new septic, it wouldn't even be an option for us. The septic system works and has only needed to be pumped one time in the last 20 years. This is definitely government overreach, but that doesn't mean squat really.
Besides looking at it from a legal standpoint and what the health inspector is trying to do, maybe someone else may have some thoughts on whether or not the system actually runs into the creek. Here is what I know so far after probing the tank with my neighbor, digging a hole to find the exit pipe and then probing the ground to follow the pipe leaving the tank... The piping is from the 50's. It's that orange tile type of piping. The tank runs lengthwise straight North from my house. The pipe leaving the tank also runs straight North from the tank. It actually makes a couple small angles to the East, away from the creek (but this could be just from us barely hitting one side of the pipe or the other). We followed it for roughly 25-30 feet, almost until it reaches my property line. So the pipe leaving the tank runs parallel with the road to the East and the Creek to the West. In order for it to eventually go towards the creek and out of that blueish pipe, it would have to make more than a 90 degree angle back towards where the pipe is coming out of the bank and then run 150+ yards underground to get there.
Every system I have seen from that time era has been some type of finger system. Our yard and all of the land around it just used to be farming fields. Is there any reason to think that 60+ years ago they decided to run the pipe North out of the tank and then dig a trench that far to drain it into the creek? When they could have just installed and buried a finger system right there? It just does not make sense to me as to why they would run it that far to the creek, but that's a $35,000 mistake if I'm wrong. The healthy inspector is actually a decent guy if he didn't happen to be a health inspector lol he did tell me that people do a lot of different things to make sure the dye doesn't make it to the creek. He only suggests that I don't use quick-crete... The ONLY thing that he says he is going to make sure of is that the dye he puts in doesn't make it to the creek. He's not checking or inspecting anything else.
Thank you to anyone who took the time to read this novel and for anyone who took their time to respond! Forgive my fat fingertips in my efforts to draw a picture on my iPhone!
I wasn't worried at that point, just annoyed in the time delay. The company couldn't place my custom garage order until I sent them the permit. I knew the septic system was on the North side of the house and the garage was going on the South side of the house; roughly 20 feet from my ground well. The garage didn't have any plans for electricity or plumbing in it. Just the shell itself with a crushed limestone surface. Absolutely nothing to do with my septic system, but I understood that for their records, they just needed to be sure it wasn't going on top of it. I then scheduled a time for the one inspector that does these inspections to come out. We weren't living there yet, so I met him out there. What the lady told me ended up being the furthest thing from the truth and this guy immediately starts in on my septic system.
The property is four acres and the back property line to the West runs along a creek. It's nothing but farming country so the creek basically has either fields up next to it or the back of someone's property line. Unless it rains or snow is melting, there isn't much water in it at all. The health inspector is refusing to give me a permit to build the garage until he runs a dye test to make sure that my septic isn't running into the creek. At that time, I had no freaking clue if it did or didn't. The creek is roughly 150 yards from the house and the house sits probably 50 feet higher if not more above the creek on top of higher ground. There is one pipe coming out of the creek bank on our property. Another one that is just on the other side of our property line to the North. One semi newer light blueish/green one and a bigger, older galvanized corrugated pipe. Like a culvert looking pipe, but maybe a foot wide only. Between the house and the creek used to be an old barn and such around it. I know there are field tile systems setup down there to drain the rain water into the creek. I have physically seen water coming out of that pipe when it's wet. The other pipe looks like it hasn't had anything run through in a long time. The neighbor told me that someone informed him the corrugated pipe was only hooked up to field tile systems to drain water. The only pipe that he is going to check for dye for is that blueish pipe, because at the time he came out, water was flowing out of it. We weren't even in the house using any water at that time, so I know it was draining the mud holes full of water from previous rain.
I'm sure it is, because the government can get away with anything, but is this even legal? Do I have any legal grounds to stand on when fighting this dye test? It has absolutely zero to do with my garage and obtaining a permit for it. I can see if I was trying to add a bathroom or something to the actual house, but this is ridiculous. If he did a dye test and it did in fact run into the creek, we would need to buy a new system and it would have to be a mound system. That's $30,000-$35,000 that we don't have. We put everything we had into the house and obtaining a home loan for it. If we had to purchase a new septic, it wouldn't even be an option for us. The septic system works and has only needed to be pumped one time in the last 20 years. This is definitely government overreach, but that doesn't mean squat really.
Besides looking at it from a legal standpoint and what the health inspector is trying to do, maybe someone else may have some thoughts on whether or not the system actually runs into the creek. Here is what I know so far after probing the tank with my neighbor, digging a hole to find the exit pipe and then probing the ground to follow the pipe leaving the tank... The piping is from the 50's. It's that orange tile type of piping. The tank runs lengthwise straight North from my house. The pipe leaving the tank also runs straight North from the tank. It actually makes a couple small angles to the East, away from the creek (but this could be just from us barely hitting one side of the pipe or the other). We followed it for roughly 25-30 feet, almost until it reaches my property line. So the pipe leaving the tank runs parallel with the road to the East and the Creek to the West. In order for it to eventually go towards the creek and out of that blueish pipe, it would have to make more than a 90 degree angle back towards where the pipe is coming out of the bank and then run 150+ yards underground to get there.
Every system I have seen from that time era has been some type of finger system. Our yard and all of the land around it just used to be farming fields. Is there any reason to think that 60+ years ago they decided to run the pipe North out of the tank and then dig a trench that far to drain it into the creek? When they could have just installed and buried a finger system right there? It just does not make sense to me as to why they would run it that far to the creek, but that's a $35,000 mistake if I'm wrong. The healthy inspector is actually a decent guy if he didn't happen to be a health inspector lol he did tell me that people do a lot of different things to make sure the dye doesn't make it to the creek. He only suggests that I don't use quick-crete... The ONLY thing that he says he is going to make sure of is that the dye he puts in doesn't make it to the creek. He's not checking or inspecting anything else.
Thank you to anyone who took the time to read this novel and for anyone who took their time to respond! Forgive my fat fingertips in my efforts to draw a picture on my iPhone!

