I am basically building a glorified garage - 30 x 42 - planning on converting it into a small home in the next few years, but need to live in it as a large open space for now. Located near Brainerd, MN. I'm going to put the tubing in the floor for infloor heat - but don't know that I can afford all of the other components right now. What would be a good "clean" and affordable way to heat it this first winter.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Garage / small home need heating ideas
- Thread starter anderhill
- Start date
kd3pc
Well-known member
zoning may get in the way, as most areas won't permit a garage to live in...same with banks. Check first before you get too far in the build.
But there are only a few sources of fuel for heat, none are "clean" and some may not be available in your area.
Natural gas is usually the first choice, then electric heat pump (you may be too far north/cold for this) and then propane. All fuels fluctuate in price over the seasons and all can be used to run very efficiently. Do your research. I stay away from propane as it has had some delivery issues that drove the price way off the charts, if you could even get it.
Ceiling height and get the BTUs needed then shop for the most efficient unit you can afford. Of course the more efficient will cost more.
You may find that thermal infloor is pretty comparable in price.
But there are only a few sources of fuel for heat, none are "clean" and some may not be available in your area.
Natural gas is usually the first choice, then electric heat pump (you may be too far north/cold for this) and then propane. All fuels fluctuate in price over the seasons and all can be used to run very efficiently. Do your research. I stay away from propane as it has had some delivery issues that drove the price way off the charts, if you could even get it.
Ceiling height and get the BTUs needed then shop for the most efficient unit you can afford. Of course the more efficient will cost more.
You may find that thermal infloor is pretty comparable in price.
theoldwizard1
Well-known member
What would be a good "clean" and affordable way to heat it this first winter.
For 1 or 2 seasons there is not "affordable" solution when you long term plan is radiant infloor heating. Electric is cheap to install, but very expensive to operate. Mini-spit heat pump MAYBE, but only if you plan on keeping it long term and the initial cost is high.
Wood is cheap, but not "clean".
The only other thing I can think of is a gas/propane "wall heater" but you will need at least 2 in a space that big.
Or a used gas/propane furnace. Minimal ducting.
dcg9381
Well-known member
It depends on how much electricity costs. Three options are:
1) heat pump (Ductless) - OK, may have issues in really cold climates
2) Propane - gas heating. Literally you can do this with a 100lb propane bottle if you're willing to refill it.
3) Electric resistance heating
1) heat pump (Ductless) - OK, may have issues in really cold climates
2) Propane - gas heating. Literally you can do this with a 100lb propane bottle if you're willing to refill it.
3) Electric resistance heating
nmk_61802
Well-known member
Or a used gas/propane furnace. Minimal ducting.
This or this and sell when done:
https://www.menards.com/main/heatin...axx-garage-heater/f260560/p-1444441204088.htm
Natural gas if available, if not call the local propane supplier and have them drop a tank off on contract.