Help me pick from these boxes

[Superjoe]

Hey guys,

These are three toolboxes that I've narrowed down to:

http://www.strictlytoolboxes.com/mo...uma-tool-boxes-56-11-drawer-tool-cabinet.html

http://www.devildogtools.com/56intoboroca.html

http://lasvegas.craigslist.org/tls/2254111334.html

I've got the guy on Craigslist down to $1600. It's a nice box with some normal wear in it, but otherwise in good condition.

It's basically a $500 premium over the other two, and I have to arrange to move it to my house, but would having the Snap-On be worth it? I'm not a professional mechanic, this is just for my personal use at home. I just never want to replace the box after this.

Thanks for any input, I know a lot of you have much more hands-on time with these brands, I've only seen snap-on personally.

 

[Superjoe]

The Snap-On box does have a stainless topper too

 

[davidj]

that stainless top is nice. If it was me and I had the money I would go with the snap on because it looks like it is in good shape and it should never have to be replaced. plus the others dont have that top so thats an advantage right there. I say snap on and never look back. you wont be dissapointed. just make sure the drawers open smoothly and the locks work and whatnot... if they dont then talk him down some more and you can get parts from snapon and replace it.

 

[Superjoe]

Thanks, that's what I was thinking. The drawers all work well. There is a bit of resistance to pulling them out, more than I'm used to from a Snap-On, but not like they are binding. I'm thinking with a little lube they'll be good as new.

 

[Scuderia-F1]

I would not even think of any other box then the Snap-On!

 

[Daddy_Rabbit]

the only way I will buy Snap-On is buying it used. Go for the SO box.

 

[Superjoe]

Thanks guys, you confirmed my thoughts. I'm getting it moved to my garage today! Thanks for the help!

 

[Zrexxer]

Weighing in late I suppose, but yes, the Snap On is going to be head and shoulders above either of the other two options. It's worth the extra cash.

 

[Superjoe]

Hey, it's never too late to hear you made a good decision!

 

[David W]

Good buy on the Snap-On but I just have to say, if the Snap-On deal didn't work out, I would go for the International. I personally have the exact same International tool box that's on your list and I would pick it over the Montezuma. The International is 24" deep vs. 20" and it's made in a country that actually has some enviromental and labor standards, Canada.
Plus the box can be purchased through Quality tools for less for $949.

http://qualitytoolsforless.com/Product.aspx?ProductID=509

Free shipping and no internet sales taxes is just icing on the cake although it did take a good two weeks to get it shipped to me.
This box has exceeded my expectations, although I've only had it about 10 months. I'm only a shade tree at home so who really knows how long this will last but so far its been good.

 

[David W]

Here is a pic.

 

[csargents1546]

Go with the so box. Nothing else compares especially for the price.

 

[tvmango]

for the money buy the snap on,, it has a great resale value,, or trade in value to a truck down the road....

if not.. i love my montezuma... they are a good box too..