I have several Maglites and my experience has been very good. For example, my wife has a 2D in her car, it has been through 2 sets of batteries in about 8 years, dropped, stepped on, forgotten under the seat, you name it. I have not had any issues with batteries leaking or corroding. At the risk of offending, I am not shocked at the change in policy, if the battery leaks it just doesn't seem to me to be Maglite's responsibility to give away a new flashlight. I have a lot of cheap junk products that eat batteries, corrode and become more junk than they began, it pisses me off but it is usually cheap batteries or a cheap import or I stored it poorly or failed to maintain it.