Husky vs. Quincy 60 gallon compressors

[jfrazier30]

I can't decide between the Husky C602H and the Quincy Q13160VQ.

I'm looking at the Husky because it's affordable.
I'm looking at the Quincy because it's a... Quincy.

I am an avid DIY'er. I spend most of my weekends tinkering in the garage, and either of these machines can definitely handle my needs. I would like for this compressor to last into the foreseeable future.

It's a SIGNIFICANT price difference. Is the Quincy really that much better? Is it quieter? Will 135 psi vs. 155 psi. make any difference to me?

I'm not comparing any other models at this time, so let's keep this discussion focused on these two.

Thanks for your opinions!

 

[DerekV]

Both of those will provide very similar, if not identical performance. If those were my only options, I'd get the Husky hands down. That Quincy isn't a "real" Quincy anyways...it is absolutely NOT worth $800 IMHO.

 

[tarbellb]

Anything but top of the line Quincy these days is typically a clone and not worth the asking price.

Do a bit more research on this forum, you will find a wealth of info on sub $1000 compressors. To cliff note: these are not your best options for the price.

 

[md21722]

I would not buy either of them. Buy a dual stage.

And DerekV is correct, that is not a Quincy QR that built the Quincy name. It's an import pump that you'll find on many other compressors like ones from NAPA, etc. The only thing about it that's Quincy is the paint color and the service you may receive after purchasing it.

 

[Stevenn1]

I have reason to believe Husky is made by Campbell Hausfeld.

 

[American Locomotive]

A friend of mine has the Husky. It works fine, but it's pretty loud. Not oil-less-direct-drive loud, but still loud.

 

[dnschmidt]

Quincy's pro line is still great. Their Lowes and other places line *****. Sort of like Snap-On selling **** made in China at Costco. Corporate greed always wins out.

 

[jfrazier30]

OK, with everyones opinions, I have decided against this Quincy model. If I get a budged compressor, I don't want to pay a premium price.

BUT NOW... I'm looking real hard at the Quincy 2 stage, 60 gallon.

It's more than I'll ever need, but it's more likely to last forever, and I don't have to worry about outgrowing it.

So, the question is.. get the cheap Husky and probably be just fine, or get the Quincy 2 stage and invite all my friends over so I can brag about it?

 

[pcmeiners]

Get the Husky if you can't wait. The Quincy your looking at is not a high end 2 stage as the QR series. Truly your best bet is to get a used QR 325 or better off Craiglist or Ebay. With a bit of patience they do show up, I got QR 325 off CR which was removed from service after 1 month of use.

 

[ADSR]

I have this compressor and have been very happy with it. can't go wrong with 18.5CFM @100 psi

https://www.aircompressorsdirect.com/Eagle-C5160V1-Air-Compressor/p5492.html

 

[dnschmidt]

I'm with Lorddiesel on this one. A high output single stage works well for most applications. That's a hell of a deal and a lot of air for little cash.

 

[Kenskip1]

I have the Husky.However I payed less. For what you described this would work.You are able to adjust the shut off pressure. I have mine set to turn off at 165 psi.It does make more noise that others but for my requirements it is ideal. Ken

 

[md21722]

Once you get dual stage you never go back. You need to set the regulator around 120 PSI just to get decent air flow for impacts, etc. on a 3/8" 50' hose. So the 145-175 PSI cycling of a dual stage is perfect. Single stage is for specific industrial applications like climate control or fire sprinkler, media blasting, or painting where lower pressures are used.

I am not a fan of the QT-54 either. It's their low end pump and spins fast. The "good" compressors spin 575-800 RPM but cost more than $2,500 new.

All that being said, the QT-54 is decently priced for what it is. You can also look at the HF 5 HP air compressor. It's the same as NAPA, Bel Air, and a bunch of others, with a different paint color. Unlike most things with power cords at HF, a couple of their compressors are actually quite good. And that's coming from someone who generally does not buy HF.

Since your location is not listed, there's no way of knowing where you're located. But if you have a Northern Tool nearby... go to the store and look around, and also look at the catalog. Sometimes they have the QT-54 on the floor where you can look at it in person.

 

[sberry]

A home time user wont wear out a cheap comp, I like the 2 stage.

 

[dnschmidt]

According the the specs on the Eaton it goes up to 150psi. 175 isn't that much more. For the additional CFM produced by the Eaton I'd give up the 175psi every time. Using both cylinders to produce air rather than one to produce it and the second to squeeze it a second time makes perfect sense. Lack of CFM is normally a much bigger issue particularly if you're running a spray gun. They run at 2 bar (29 PSIG) and 150 will power any air tool as they are all rated at 90 anyway. Set the regulator to 120 and no matter how long your hose it you should be fine. CFM is what you need. For example my SATA Nr2000 uses 17cfm at two bar. That's a shitload of air.

 

[EOC_Jason]

As others have said, the first quincy you linked is an import non-quincy pump. The second quincy you linked is okay quality but it is very loud and high RPM... You might be able to silence it some with an intake muffler but for the price I would still look elsewhere...

With 4th of july around the corner, I would bet stores will have sales / coupons (or at the very least asking for 10% off in HD would be approved).

If you need it now, just get the cheap husky. If you can wait, watch craigslist for an older Champion, Quincy, Saylor Beall, Kellogg American, etc...

 

[bigredjeepone]

For under $1000 this is my choice.

http://www.northerntool.com/shop/tools/product_211720_211720

 

[Trey T]

In term of quality, I would say they're equal. In term of performance, the Quincy can output couple CFM more @90psi. It narrows down to price difference of $300; is it worth it? Highly doubt it!!

 

[montanafordman]

I purchased the Quincy Qt-54 and love it. It will more than keep up with constant use from die grinders and cutoff wheels which eat A TON of air. The dual stage is the only way to go if you're going to buy a compressor for anything more than an impact wrench. (grinders, sanders, HVLP paint guns etc)

 

[sberry]

Dual is for running tools, it turns on where a single is turning off. Makes it able to supply constant pressure thru a regulator with enough headroom to compensate for line loss thru hoses to the tool.