Hey guys, looking to purchase both a SAE & Metric combination wrench set for my travel bag. Now I generally buy higher end tools for my shop and at home (Snap On, Hazet, PB Swiss, Wera, etc) but I don’t need anything really high end for my travel bag. I’ve bought a few icon products and they seem to pretty good. Looking at their 14 pc metric & SAE anti slip sets. Anybody here have feedback? Good or bad? With a 25% coupon it seems to be a no brainer. Let me know your thoughts or maybe you have another set in mind. Thanks!
Icon Combination Wrenches
- Thread starter Rickkyyr8
- Start date
I have Icon shorty combos, they're good. The chrome was nice and consistent. If you're rarely going to use them, the Pittsburgh are also fine. My travel set is Pittsburgh and they've been doubled up and hammered on in rusty junkyard scenarios. I'm not saying they survived the abuse flawlessly, but they're not bent and still turn bolts fine.
Badgerstate
Well-known member
Theyre good wrenches. Easily as good as anything Snap-On at a fraction of the price. Theres been number tool tortune tests done and the high-end stuff doesnt perform any better than the Icon stuff does.
I don't have the anti-slip models, but have the regular ones and they're very nice.
The anti-slip models tested very highly in the Torque Test Channel video on anti-slip wrenches (this was the 64712 set):
(since then Mac has released a new design that blows everything else away, but Icon scores similarly to the Wright and SO FD+)
The anti-slip models tested very highly in the Torque Test Channel video on anti-slip wrenches (this was the 64712 set):
(since then Mac has released a new design that blows everything else away, but Icon scores similarly to the Wright and SO FD+)
jsmeece
Well-known member
The anti-slip versions I have are Channellock, in both SAE and Metric. Do It Best hardware stores have them. Very similar to Carlyle, probably same manufacture.
hmmm not quite true. But you are correct that many Taiwan brands have really closed the quality gap. Gearwrench is not too shabby and there are other stand outs.
Looking at TTC data on anti-slip open ends, and reading between the lines, Icon look really good. They are thicker and softer than Snap On, which could result in real world slipping or rounding. They didn’t score as high as snap on or Wright. But they appear as tight as Snap on (Unlike Wright). So for non extreme jobs, I think Icon is an excellent choice.
If you want smooth jaws, then Williams or Gearwrench may be worth looking at.
Infar probably .
oldschoolcraft
Well-known member
How do you get 25% off coupons? I don’t get junk mail to my home. I’ve heard they send it in junk mail. Is that the only way?
assassin10000
Well-known member
- Joined
- Feb 11, 2022
- Messages
- 370
Email or the hf coupon app.
Same. Very happy with that purchase. Great wrench set for the price.
This weekend they have a coupon for 20% off any ICON tool, 25% for ITC members.
Sometimes they'll email you one if they have your email and you don't shop there regularly.
Right now they have 20% off for nearly everything.
How much do you tip your mailman?
The only Icon tools I have are a set of extra long zero offset ratcheting wrenches and a long flex head 1/2" drive ratchet. I haven't had a single problem with them and they seem like a decent quality tool...they get used daily in a pro environment and live in a toolbox packed full of Snap On and Proto wrenches and ratchets, so that is saying something if you ask me. Icon isnt the Harbor Freight stuff of olden days. I can't imagine their combo wrenches are any less impressive for the price. I would definitely consider them if I needed another set of wrenches.
bcradio
Well-known member
Were you able to use the coupon multiple times?
I bought a set of ICON combination wrenches to replace a set of Snap ons that I had to sell, regrettably. They look pretty much identical but I believe the ICONs are anti-slip where Snap on were smooth jaw. I've generally been happy with the ICONs except for my last project where I was putting them through the paces on a BMW front end. Had a few issues with slipping and / or rounding off. Not sure if it was the wrench expanding or worn BMW hardware. Still wish I had the Snap ons but ICONs get the job done (mostly). No catastrophic failures which is high up on my requirements list lol.
Yes
Attachments
oldschoolcraft
Well-known member
Is this 20% a coupon or it’s automatic to everyone in the store? Their website makes it seem like it’s automatic.
Is a very sensible buy at 65 bucks a wrench set, not easy getting things silly cheap in current times so this price and potentially usable warranty is a proper good deal .
I not biggest fan of the taiwan antislip open ends as all pretty sloppy fitting and mark up fasteners more than the better US open end jaw designs .
Fedwrench
ALLIANCE MEMBER
Visit the Harbor Freight website. They have the coupons posted there along with their current sales.
You have to have the coupon to get the discount. It's not automatic.
The current 25% off coupon is only for Inside Track members which is like $30 annually. Non Inside Track Members current deal is 20% off.
stonesfan68
Well-known member
Something good I noticed about the Icon wrenches: They don't have a large chamfer where the box end is broached. I suspect in order to make broaching easier many combo wrenches have a coned area (the chamfer) where the broach starts. This does help slide the wrench onto a nut. However, it also means the height of engagement with the nut is smaller for a given thickness of wrench and you can't grab towards the base of a nut when it's against a flat surface. This seems to be one of the areas where cheap box end wrenches show their colors. They often aren't that thin because if they are the large chamfer results in very little height of grip on the nut. I modeled the picture to show what I'm trying to describe.
Attachments
the chamfer is purely aid getting wrench on the fastener .
Will have take a look at the ICON combo wrenches as not noticed this .
Some manufacturers advertise the non chamfer design as increased engagement/grip, I have an aviation long double box end set like it and is useful advantage .
Will have take a look at the ICON combo wrenches as not noticed this .
Some manufacturers advertise the non chamfer design as increased engagement/grip, I have an aviation long double box end set like it and is useful advantage .
Badgerstate
Well-known member
Check out Project Farm on Youtube. You might be surprised. Its funny you mention Gearwrench because they tend to do among the worst. Ive got a set and theyre OK but they certainly dont compare to the nicer brands out there (my Tone set is a work of art compared to them) and I certainly wouldnt say they live up to the prosumer image that Gearwrench seems to have.