To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

I’ve sinned. I bought another tool brand.

mercracing

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 14, 2015
Messages
156
I’ve been a Dewalt guy for years. I have maybe 8 tools and batteries. Yesterday I needed a rotary hammer drill. Walked right to the Milwaukee section and bought a nice one and picked up a battery and charger since it doesn’t run on hopes and dreams. For whatever reason, I didn’t even think to look for a Dewalt version that would work with the batteries I have. Used it yesterday to drill one 5/8 hole and it worked amazingly. Looked on Dewalts website this morning and of course, they have a similar product that I’m sure works great. 🙄

So this is me being frustrated that I now have two different brands powertools and batteries.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

speed bump

Well-known member
Joined
May 28, 2008
Messages
6,317
Location
Butte Montana
That way you can get the deals. For some reason the base DeWalt stuff seems super easy to find deals on and the more premium Milwaukee stuff seems to be easier to find deals on.

At work our maintenance department has Milwaukee and the production department has DeWalt. Biggest difference seems to be DeWalt makes a better grinder and drill and Milwaukee makes a better impact as well as some tools our electrician's flat out love.
 

Walkers

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2021
Messages
3,912
Location
Cave Creek Az

jrsavoie

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
1,468
Location
North east Illinois
Is there an adapter on Amazon to use a DeWalt 20 volt battery on a Milwaukee V18 tool?

I found this on eBay

 

Bubba Fett

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 11, 2018
Messages
1,516
Location
Eastern NC
DeWalt, Makita, and Milwaukee are all considered top of the line for cordless power tools, but some models are better than others. Sometimes the best tool for the job is one from another brand.

The whole battery platform compatibility thing is more of a convenience than a necessity. Do what works for you.
 

jrsavoie

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 4, 2013
Messages
1,468
Location
North east Illinois
DeWalt, Makita, and Milwaukee are all considered top of the line for cordless power tools, but some models are better than others. Sometimes the best tool for the job is one from another brand.

The whole battery platform compatibility thing is more of a convenience than a necessity. Do what works for you.
The main reason I kept Milwaukee tools. Was I liked my Milwaukee circular saws better than DeWalts

Legislators always want to legislate everything. They should legislate battery compatibility!!
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!

vavet

Well-known member
Joined
Mar 6, 2012
Messages
5,325
Location
Ashland, VA
Repent! Send me the offending tools and go buy yourself the appropriate yellow tool. I will handle the rest.
 

stubbsrodandcustom

Well-known member
Joined
Aug 30, 2012
Messages
70
I know a guy who had all Milwaukee batt. powered stuff, I couldn't stand it due to battery life being dismal and granted it was the old little battery packs but, my Roybi outperformed it 10 fold. I was a DeWalt guy for years 14.4 v, But having drills just burn up motors after 2 years couldn't deal with that. I have a 8 yr old Ryobi drill, still works great. Now I have Porter Cable grinder and Heat gun, Rest of my handhelds are Ryobi, Except for the S-O impact and die grinder. Only thing that I have had issues with out of all the Ryobi stuff is the leaf blower switch some days acts up, probably needs a good cleaning. Personally I have heard the latest Milwaukee stuff is really good so I don't think you will have any issues there. When you find something that works and doesn't break the bank, you stick with it as long as its good to you and gets the job done.
 

subroc

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2017
Messages
781
Location
Dover, NH
Why not? Truth is for a long time I would have cautioned against such a thing. But it was more of a budget or logic argument. If you are building up a set of tools it makes sense to add to an existing set. You could add a bare tool at a cost savings or a kit with a battery/ies that will work in all your stuff. Once you reach a point where you have all the batteries you might need who cares on the next tool/s? If it isn't only about the cost savings and logic of the thing have at it. Tell us how it works out.
 

ecotec

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 5, 2010
Messages
5,451
I have avoided this so far… but a cordless drywall sander has been tempting me.
 

nbpt100

Well-known member
Joined
Oct 19, 2016
Messages
2,301
Location
Massachusetts
Impulse buys can later be annoying. However, you seem happy with the hammer drill. How often do you need to use it? If not often, you did well. Do not worry about it. If you use it alot having some extra batteries around can be convenient.
 

j3rf

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2018
Messages
488
Location
Ohio
I use 12v Dewalt and 18v Milwaukee in the auto industry. I thought for a long while that I only wanted one brand. Turns out I was wrong.
 

livinloud11

Well-known member
Joined
Dec 23, 2014
Messages
103
Location
Deltona, FL
I have mainly Dewalt 20v however I did buy Milwaukee 12v screwdriver/ratchet combo and added the rotary tool. Couldn't be happier with the two platforms.
 

fourjeepin

Well-known member
Joined
Feb 12, 2011
Messages
3,659
Location
Atlanta, GA
Staying with one battery platform is overrated imho.
I love having one brand of batteries. It keeps me from ever running out of charged batteries. And I intended to stick with one platform but caved and now have two, but run adapters.
 

mogandave

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2021
Messages
3,052
Location
Bangkok
Assuming you can make it fit, if you run a 12VDC tool with an 18VDC battery, will it not just run faster?
 

bonneyman

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 22, 2010
Messages
8,815
Location
Desert SW
Assuming you can make it fit, if you run a 12VDC tool with an 18VDC battery, will it not just run faster?
Yeah, but the motor windings aren't rated to handle that higher voltage consistently. It'll run faster, but hotter. A 50% higher voltage is sure to burn it out fast. Not something I'd want to do if I like the tool.
I know the 9.6 Makita's can take some overvoltage. Fresh batteries supply about 11 volts, and then drop off to the nominal 9.6-10. So it can take that little ( about 11%) over voltage. But my 6092 drill has an over temp auto reset switch built in, so it kinda gives me a safety valve.
I have a 7.2V angle drill that I run off of 9.6 batteries. (I don't have a 7.2v battery, and 9.6v slide in, though it sticks out the end). It runs faster, but I figure as the battery drains it can go alot lower then usual and still run the tool. If I fry the motor, I'll frankenstein it and swap in a 9.6 volt motor I have as a spare.
 

lbhsbz

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 13, 2010
Messages
1,181
Location
Long Beach CA
The Dewalt chuck comment....I thought it was just me....I found an old 18V dewalt drill in the trash and swapped the chuck from that, it doesn't work much better.
 

mogandave

Well-known member
Joined
Nov 4, 2021
Messages
3,052
Location
Bangkok
Yeah, but the motor windings aren't rated to handle that higher voltage consistently. It'll run faster, but hotter. A 50% higher voltage is sure to burn it out fast. Not something I'd want to do if I like the tool.
I know the 9.6 Makita's can take some overvoltage. Fresh batteries supply about 11 volts, and then drop off to the nominal 9.6-10. So it can take that little ( about 11%) over voltage. But my 6092 drill has an over temp auto reset switch built in, so it kinda gives me a safety valve.
I have a 7.2V angle drill that I run off of 9.6 batteries. (I don't have a 7.2v battery, and 9.6v slide in, though it sticks out the end). It runs faster, but I figure as the battery drains it can go alot lower then usual and still run the tool. If I fry the motor, I'll frankenstein it and swap in a 9.6 volt motor I have as a spare.
If you don’t run it full speed it might not get hot…
 

dchawk81

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
14,382
I’ve been a Dewalt guy for years. I have maybe 8 tools and batteries. Yesterday I needed a rotary hammer drill. Walked right to the Milwaukee section and bought a nice one and picked up a battery and charger since it doesn’t run on hopes and dreams. For whatever reason, I didn’t even think to look for a Dewalt version that would work with the batteries I have. Used it yesterday to drill one 5/8 hole and it worked amazingly. Looked on Dewalts website this morning and of course, they have a similar product that I’m sure works great. 🙄

So this is me being frustrated that I now have two different brands powertools and batteries.
Cheating hussy. 😡😃

160777-004-97B9BA24.jpg
 

F-22

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 23, 2022
Messages
1,830
DeWalt, Makita, and Milwaukee are all considered top of the line for cordless power tools, but some models are better than others.
IMO usually it's some minor difference, like a fraction of a second faster speed you can notice on a youtube review. But those are so one-sided towards things they can measure/show - if you actually use the tool it often ends up meaning the "faster" and "more powerful" tool can also vibrate more or be more tiring to use.

In the end the differences are all very minor, just enough to start such arguments :)


I use Makita because their batteries are the most "standard" ones. With that I mean that you can get fake Makita tools on Aliexpress easily, but you won't find bosch or milwaukee or dewalt or hilti or metabo at all. I don't need the best of everything, sometimes a cheap brushless chinese power tool works great for home use, but the fact they use the same batteries is a huge advantage for me.


Very interestingly, there's even some development done by the Chinese. Makita only makes professional pruning shears that are ridiculously expensive for home use (like, I think 1200-1500€). The chinese make some shears totally unrelated to Makita for 45$ but they use the same battery:
or-Makita-18V-Battery-without-battery.jpg_Q90.jpg_.jpg

Ironically these end up being the best homeowner pruning shears on the market. They're the most narrow/versatile ones out there and they work great. The chinese even offer a long extension-handle for pruning tall brances, it hooks up on the battery port. Here's what Dewalt offers:

DCPR320B_1.jpg

Not sure what they were smoking when they thought of that??? Also they cost 5 times as much as the chinese ones and seem to use a brushed motor?

Here's what Milwaukee has:
Milwaukee-M12-Brushless-Pruning-Shears.jpg

Better but still sooo fat. Who needs the "jaws of life" to prune fruits?
Here's the real Makita pruning shears, just for a comparison of what a professional tool for pruning is supposed to look like:
DUP362Z.jpg

Obviously by far the slimmest of the bunch, but waaaay more expensive. They're also running a cord to a backpack-harness with batteries so you can work all day with them - not meant as a homeowner tool by any means...
 

dchawk81

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
14,382
IMO usually it's some minor difference, like a fraction of a second faster speed you can notice on a youtube review. But those are so one-sided towards things they can measure/show - if you actually use the tool it often ends up meaning the "faster" and "more powerful" tool can also vibrate more or be more tiring to use.

In the end the differences are all very minor, just enough to start such arguments :)


I use Makita because their batteries are the most "standard" ones. With that I mean that you can get fake Makita tools on Aliexpress easily, but you won't find bosch or milwaukee or dewalt or hilti or metabo at all. I don't need the best of everything, sometimes a cheap brushless chinese power tool works great for home use, but the fact they use the same batteries is a huge advantage for me.


Very interestingly, there's even some development done by the Chinese. Makita only makes professional pruning shears that are ridiculously expensive for home use (like, I think 1200-1500€). The chinese make some shears totally unrelated to Makita for 45$ but they use the same battery:
or-Makita-18V-Battery-without-battery.jpg_Q90.jpg_.jpg

Ironically these end up being the best homeowner pruning shears on the market. They're the most narrow/versatile ones out there and they work great. The chinese even offer a long extension-handle for pruning tall brances, it hooks up on the battery port. Here's what Dewalt offers:

DCPR320B_1.jpg

Not sure what they were smoking when they thought of that??? Also they cost 5 times as much as the chinese ones and seem to use a brushed motor?

Here's what Milwaukee has:
Milwaukee-M12-Brushless-Pruning-Shears.jpg

Better but still sooo fat. Who needs the "jaws of life" to prune fruits?
Here's the real Makita pruning shears, just for a comparison of what a professional tool for pruning is supposed to look like:
DUP362Z.jpg

Obviously by far the slimmest of the bunch, but waaaay more expensive. They're also running a cord to a backpack-harness with batteries so you can work all day with them - not meant as a homeowner tool by any means...
I bought knockoff shears and they're awesome.

20220812_172717.jpg

Came with a little chainsaw.

20220812_184607.jpg
 

Lassen Forge

Well-known member
Joined
Apr 26, 2014
Messages
15,260
Location
The romantic hills of central Umbria, Italy,
I have a pair of knockoff shears - the only bad part is I need to charge the battery 3x a day if I'm using them constantly, but they're a lifesaver. I ALMOST bought the DeWalt ones, but they look big and bulky compared to the ones I have, and if you're using them all day, every day, I don't need something that is bigger, bulkier, and heavier...

By the way - I DO have the 18V dewalt hammer drill - had to drill out an existing 3/16"ish dogleg hole in solid rock (part of the fun of living in a stone tower) from a previous cable install to run my starlink internet cable connector through (needed to be a straight shot somewhere north of 1/2") ... it did the job like a dentist going to town on a mouth full of cavities (in fact, we were joking how I could go into a side business drilling teeth with the thing, the tower was complaining because the novocaine was wearing off, etc)... And of course, it matches the rest of our DeWalt 18V.
 

Bubba Fett

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 11, 2018
Messages
1,516
Location
Eastern NC
Never realized battery powered shears were even a thing. I suppose they would be useful, but for me it would have to be for clearing wooded areas, or something like that. I don't mind using manual shears and pruners for yard maintenance.
 

dchawk81

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 31, 2014
Messages
14,382
Never realized battery powered shears were even a thing. I suppose they would be useful, but for me it would have to be for clearing wooded areas, or something like that. I don't mind using manual shears and pruners for yard maintenance.
I had a thick bush growing where I had a tree cut down. To me they were worth it for that single job. Made insanely quick work of it.

I have a zero turn for a town lot though too just because I don't like yard work. The faster I get it over with the happier I am.
 
To avoid these ads, REGISTER NOW!
Top Bottom