Jack stands - ok to use after a roll off?

[pendragon1998]

I was replacing a starter today and it about wore me out, with temps near 90, two broken bolts, one broken drill bit, and a very hard to access bolt. When I got done, I buttoned it all up and hopped in to test start it. Then, like an idiot, I backed it up, completely forgetting I was on jackstands. Well, I rolled off the stands, there was a loud clattering to remind me, and the stands look fine, except for a little scuffing on the feet. No cracks that I can see. Is there any reason to lose trust in these stands in the future (i.e., could rolling off of them make them more prone to fail next time they are used)? I am already not crazy about them, but they have always worked for me (made in china craftsman high lift 3 ton SUV jack stands).

 

[geartow]

I think I would replace if I could. They were side loaded as they came over I would be afraid of the my self.

 

[Davefr]

That's a tough call.

If they're the modern heavy duty style and look perfect then I'd probably keep them. But that's only if you're following safe working procedures like ensuring redundant support. (ie never a single point of failure!!)

If they're the old style then it's probably best to upgrade.

 

[PSYKO_Inc]

As long as they're not bent or cracked, they should be fine.

 

[Empty Pockets]

If you rolled off of them, regardless of how they look, I'd replace them. A couple of jack stands are always cheaper than a hospital bill (and safer too)

 

[PureLeaf]

I can't offer any advice as to whether they're now considered dangerous or not. But if you decide to buy some new ones, and want to go the cheap route. Craftsman is having a sale on these craftsman professional 4 ton set for 22.99.

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-prof...D=1225267&AID=11042411&sid=IAx20050830x000545


Another alternative: I just bought some US Jack ones and posted photos of them in the new tool arrivals. 150 bucks for 6 ton per stand rated jacks.

 

[BD1]

$100.00 for NEW ONES would place my mind at ease.

 

[CutterFarms]

When the ground gave way under my truck it slightly warped a set of my stands and I replaced them before going back under it. I would never risk it as cheap as stands are. Imo

 

[royesses]

Save them for light duty stuff like keeping a transmission up while changing its mount. Get new good ones. I'd not trust them again. Just my opinion. A life is worth more than anything in the world.

 

[Eds_tls]

Jack stands are dirt cheap. I personally would pitch them

 

[DMAR]

I can't offer any advice as to whether they're now considered dangerous or not. But if you decide to buy some new ones, and want to go the cheap route. Craftsman is having a sale on these craftsman professional 4 ton set for 22.99.

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-prof...D=1225267&AID=11042411&sid=IAx20050830x000545


Another alternative: I just bought some US Jack ones and posted photos of them in the new tool arrivals. 150 bucks for 6 ton per stand rated jacks.

Those US Jack stands are real nice. That's also a good deal on the Craftsman....

Although I think you're probably fine with the stands that got knocked over (if they check out OK) for that price, I'd buy these Craftsman stands and have some piece of mind. Or, spend the dough, and get a nice set... I have a couple of sets of Hein Warner, no complaints..

 

[Git]

Post of pic of your jack stands?

 

[mrvm]

If you decide to repurpose them for light-duty use rattle can them an specific color to remind you what they have been repurposed for.

 

[blackwire]

Save them for light duty stuff like keeping a transmission up while changing its mount. Get new good ones. I'd not trust them again. Just my opinion. A life is worth more than anything in the world.

Also good for supporting an extension while working on a tight fastener. Like crankshaft bolts, lug nuts etc.

 

[Bierisch]

http://www.homedepot.com/p/Big-Red-12-Ton-Steel-Jack-Stands-2-Pack-T412002/100595190

I know a guy that has had a set of these sittingoutside in the weather and sun for about 6 years and theyre still holding up well. Sitting under the front of a 95 F-150

 

[AmishFury]

I can't offer any advice as to whether they're now considered dangerous or not. But if you decide to buy some new ones, and want to go the cheap route. Craftsman is having a sale on these craftsman professional 4 ton set for 22.99.

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-prof...D=1225267&AID=11042411&sid=IAx20050830x000545


Another alternative: I just bought some US Jack ones and posted photos of them in the new tool arrivals. 150 bucks for 6 ton per stand rated jacks.

you say per stand but the sheet in your photo clearly states per pair

 

[PureLeaf]

you say per stand but the sheet in your photo clearly states per pair

I see what you're saying. I think its just confused writing. They're very explicit:

Per US JACK's website " Rated capacity is PER stand, stands are packaged in PAIRS. "

http://www.goestores.com/storename/usjackco/ViewDept-276440.aspx

Also Note the labelling on the jack. "6 Ton Capacity Each".

 

[MikeF2316]

Test them. If you use 2 stands to hold up one end of your vehicle, jack it up and put just 1 in the center. If it handles that, you're good to go.

If it doesn't, then it will be in a condition to remind you not to use it again.

 

[thegroundpounder99]

I'd replace, not worth the worry or the risk.


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

[Warrenator]

Inspect them. Metal isn't magic, it is a strong yet malleable material. It is has been damaged there will be signs such as bending, cracking, broken welds. Grab the various parts and see if you can twist them. Look at the paint to see where any impacts were. Use a magnifying glass to look at the welds and stressed areas.

I bet they are fine.

 

[Jacobson]

It's going to be in the back of your mind as you use them the next time.

 

[pendragon1998]

I hear all of you. I think a new set is in my future. Thanks, y'all!

 

[usdemt]

Why are you using jack stands without wheelchocks? Get new and use chocks

 

[pescados666]

I can't offer any advice as to whether they're now considered dangerous or not. But if you decide to buy some new ones, and want to go the cheap route. Craftsman is having a sale on these craftsman professional 4 ton set for 22.99.

http://www.sears.com/craftsman-prof...D=1225267&AID=11042411&sid=IAx20050830x000545

Damn, was gonna grab a pair of these but the offer expired. Hopefully it comes around again soon

 

[928'er]

As they say, "buy a cheap helmet if you have a cheap head."
Your jack stands are past their "sell by date." Recycle them.

 

[2oolhound]

You could always jack up a really big truck, bus etc. and see if they support that ok. Then you'd feel safer about using them on a smaller vehicle.

 

[nikerret]

I wouldn't have considered not using them, if they appeared okay. Perhaps, I should... After reading the replies, including the most cogent point: cheap to replace, I would get new and use the rolloff one for under the rear of the trailer, when I load the tractor.