TO answer this once an for all, here is Craftsman response:
"Dear Mr. Burke,
Thank you for contacting Sears and for choosing Craftsman.
If the sockets become unusable they will be unconditionally replaced.
Cosmetics would not be considered a reason for replacement under our
warranty."
But in this case it would not be to my satisfaction thus fall under this argument:
"Satisfaction Guaranteed or your Money Back. If any Craftsman hand tool fails to give complete satisfaction, return it to any Sears store in the US or Canada for repair or replacement".
I will have to wait and see if any one on here has tried to return one for this issue.
And yes, I have to much free time on my hands.