I know this wont directly chime in to what you guys are saying about mechanics(being Canadian) but I am a Nissan dealership mechanic and I thought I would throw in my 2 cents.
A.) in Canada ita a 4 year apprenticeship where you work and go to school - 10 months work 2 months school every year
B.) pay increases as you go further through school
C.) There are many ways to get paid in the automotive industry in Canada depending on the type of shop, I worked straight time(hourly) before and now I work flat rate (hourly based on jobs)
D.) yes its thousands and thousands of dollars in tools. If you look in my first thread (
http://www.garagejournal.com/forum/showthread.php?p=6092200#post6092200 ) you will see my tool box in the back ground. With out tools that cost me approx. 11,000$ Cad and now I don't even need it with my shop as we have built ins. With that said I have approx. 100,000$ in tools between work and home and I love them, I love tools. I have always had the firm grasp of, if I can do it with the tools I may have to buy id rather do it myself.
E.) If you are thinking this would be a career cause you actively love working on cars like I did, well.... it does kill a lot of the drive and enjoyment of doing it when you go home, now you have two jobs not a hobby. And you say it wont get that way but it does.
F.) There can always be crappy customers, and a lack of understanding from them goes even deeper. But that goes 2 ways, explain and show a customer a problem and they typically thank you.
I have explained this job to customers and friends before and there are a few analogies that I use. It is very mush like being a doctor and hear me out..... we take peoples lives in to our hands every day(fail to diagnose something correctly, car crashes fire and death)(we are more liable then doctors in Canada) we get very little information from the customer( my CEL light on.... my car is making a "noise", It feels "off") and we are expected to (in the minds of customers) hook up a computer and it just tells us whats wrong then we "change a part" and charge absorbant amounts of money. On top of that you have to know almost every other trade to be able to do this one.... I.T., Electrical, plumbing, machining, welding, body systems, etc etc etc. anybody who doesn't think that and is in the trade is the previous comment, a "parts changer". With that said I take great responsibility and pride in making people very expensive investments last as long as possible without costing them as much money as humanly possible. I work for Nissan but I work on all brands, in my shop we don't have 1 diagnostician but I am considered the guru, which can be a hindrance cause I don't get paid more, but it does give me personal pride(however selfish this is) to be better then any other tech I know. And I make a **** load of money for someone who works about 7hrs a day. And this is Canada but even here 100,000$ a year is pretty good.